3 ms·
I don't think that is true at all. A good investment can be one that tracks inflation and simply pays out the labor and capital you put into it. Owning should
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I don't think that is true at all. A good investment can be one that tracks inflation and simply pays out the labor and capital you put into it.
Owning should be cheaper than renting in the long run for the same reason it is cheaper to cook at home than eating out.
Savings by owning should be commensurate with the risk taken, cost of upkeep, and time value of money.
- ethanbond 4y agoA high Land Value Tax accomplishes this. It negates the appreciation generated merely by land scarcity and value of surrounding land, which means the only way to get gains from your real estate holdings is indeed to put labor and capital into improving it.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think annual land value taxes are efficient at resource allocation but unacceptably punitive on owners. You should not be penalized or motivated to sell simply because a 3rd party can get a higher return. Similarly, value gains from land appreciation are taxed at the time of sale. IF I pay annual taxes on land appreciation, I should be exempt from taxes at the point of sale, otherwise I am paying for that appreciation twice.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoLand belongs to society, not whoever has a house on it. If you are using it ineffectively you deserve to be punished by society via taxes because you are directly making the community worse off.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIf you don't believe in property ownership, I think it unlikely we will find common ground.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI absolutely believe in property ownership. And that land is such a unique and important asset that it is utterly immoral for anyone except society as a whole to own it and tax those on it at close to its full value.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIn this we have similarly strong feelings but opposite conclusion. I also think that land is a fundamental and important asset, but conclude from that it is immoral for an individual possession to be reliant and dependent on society. I feel it in the same way that I would not want my ability to beath air to depend on some social utilitarian function that could decide it is better used elsewhere. I suppose you might view this as anti-social.
- danans 4y ago> it is immoral for an individual possession to be reliant and dependent on society. Society is what defines the concept of land ownership and actively protects the ownership of land, so it's not possible to remove a dependency of the latter on the former.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoSociety accepts and protects property ownership of land but is not the only method possible. Legal rights and social processes are just the most agreeable way to manage it amongst several people. For example, You can own land if there is no society or other people to contest it. If you are alone on a island, there is no one to say you don't own it Similarly, you can own land without social dependence if you have the power take or defend it. If you've ever been mugged or read of nations conquered, it is clear that social consensus and the rule of law is but one mode of arbitrating property ownership. That said, it is one that works out quite well
- danans 4y ago
- ethanbond 4y agoYep I (and many other LVTers) are okay with zero taxes at time of sale.
- aeturnum 4y agoI agree that the sort of investment you are describing makes sense - but in practice those kinds of investments are out-competed by ones with better yields. If you are a developer, there is simply no financial incentives to choosing a lower yield financial vehicle. You'll just have more trouble finding funding and have less of a cushion for cost overruns. I also think there's a strong economies of scale argument that "we" (society) would prefer most people rent (and use some sort of fixed or low-profit system that does maintenance at scale) as it'll result in lower overall costs. However it's absolutely true that home ownership is the best vehicle we've found for building inter-generational wealth so I'm not against it. Also one can simply prefer a society with more individual owners and slightly higher overall costs - reasonable people can disagree.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>I agree that the sort of investment you are describing makes sense - but in practice those kinds of investments are out-competed by ones with better yields. I think that is a an advantage, not a disadvantage. There is no need for housing investments to have competitive yields. If you can make a profit building houses which have more value to buyers than your cost of inputs, someone will make them. It just won't be a speculative investment good. I don't worry that people will stop making socks, shoes, or food because the profit margin in that business is lower than the market yield. If there is on opportunity for profit, someone will want do it. They just might not be funded by some massive financial hedge fund, which again, I think is an advantage. Historically, home ownership has been a vehicle for intergeneration wealth building because it means taking on more responsibility, work, and risk instead of paying a 3rd party to do so. I would argue that most people renting would not result in the lowest cost, because it turns responsibilities that a homeowner can do for free into 3rd party services which must be paid for. It is like saying that city run food kitchens would be more efficient than people cooking at home. Maybe it is "more efficient" if you count the homeowners implicit labor, but the dollar cost to the cooker is still going up. I think most people would agree the goal is higher ownership and lower costs than now. I think this is actually reasonable if we fix some of the conditions that lead to house exorbitant growth in house value
- 4y ago
- mixmastamyk 4y agoReturning your money (at 0% ROI) is not what people want in an investment. What you're describing is a savings account, or even a bit less. Historically you might make a percent or two after inflation, but not the last couple of decades.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI disagree. I think a lot of people would be fine with a 0% ROI investment if it comes coupled with a free house to live in for the rest of their lives. A house is not a stock, bond, or number in a savings account. You get utility from living in it as well. A 0% ROI would however make that investment unattractive for 3rd parties who don't live in the house.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThis sounds like an "inflation hedge" rather than an ordinary investment: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/inflation-hedge.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/inflation-hedge.asp
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThere are lots of different types of investments. Housing is historically considered an excellent hedge against inflation ("Land, they aren't making it anymore") However, purchasing a house it is not just an inflation hedge. It comes with a house you can live in! This is an attractive quality for many of us humans who like living in homes.
- arcticbull 4y agoTaking the modern definition of inflation as measured from the purchasing power of currency within the economy, you'll find house price increases are actually a major driver of inflation. If you allowed construction and more supply, house prices would stabilize and inflation would go down. If you want to hedge inflation just buy Series I bonds instead. There's other ways. Really though, I would argue that housing in aggregate is not a good hedge against inflation because while it is true that the price of an average square foot of housing in the United States has gone up almost zero percent adjusted for inflation over the last 50 years, you have had to do 50 years of maintenance on it, 50 years of insurance premiums, 50 years of paint, siding, roofing, etc. And a 5% realtor commission. By definition, it has therefore, on average, trailed inflation. If you are looking at specific houses, in specific areas, that's not "housing is a good hedge against inflation" it's "if we look at the winners in a speculative market, we find that they have won" which isn't so much an investment philosophy as a tautology. That said a mortgage may be a good hedge against inflation but only by virtue of it being a long-duration fixed-interest debt facility with preferential interest treatment at income tax time. And 5X leverage.