5 ms·
There were many different hypotheses on the outcome of Elon firing 80%+ of Twitter employees: 1. The site would crash and burn the next day. 2. Nothing would
by paxys 4y ago
There were many different hypotheses on the outcome of Elon firing 80%+ of Twitter employees:
1. The site would crash and burn the next day.
2. Nothing would change. All those engineers were anyways just sitting around.
3. There would be no immediate impact (servers can run by themselves after all), but the site would slowly degrade over time as institutional knowledge around maintenance, upkeep and all the various system quirks was gone.
We are now seeing #3 play out in front of us.
- antupis 4y agoI think 3 is happening but the thing is that can this HC-twitter build knowledge and code back so that site functions stay about same before users leave is the real battle.
- sidfthec 4y ago#1 is what non-tech people said. #2 is what hardcore Elon fans said. #3 was always the most likely prediction and is what any actual tech engineer should have said.
- O__________O 4y agoLet’s not pretend like Twitter has never had downtime, they literally popularized the “Fail Whale” meme way before Elon was around: - https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/01/the-story-behind-twitters-fail-whale/384313/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/01/the-s...
- jjeaff 4y agoYes, but my recollection is that the whale fail was usually due to huge growth or unprecedented traffic peaks. I don't think Twitter is growing at a fast rate any longer.
- sneak 4y agoMusk claims often that Twitter engagement numbers are at record highs. I don't believe these are lies.
- O__________O 4y agoAt the very least per tweet it’s possible to see really view patterns, which to my knowledge what’s possible before.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> At the very least per tweet it’s possible to see really view patterns, which to my knowledge what’s possible before. Those numbers have been proven to be incorrect, by people who are posting from locked accounts with 0 followers racking up large nonzero view counts within a few minutes.
- O__________O 4y agoSource?
- medler 4y ago
- stronglikedan 4y agoA simple and short lived glitch does not a #3 make. Twitter is better than ever now. Elon did good.
- mulletbum 4y agoWhy?
- random314 4y agoThis is one of several different glitches and downtime seen this year. A revenue collapse of 40% with a surge in fake verified profiles does not make Twitter better than ever. It is crazy to see a sudden sharp 40% revenue decline being described as better than ever.
- giobox 4y agoWhile I've no trouble believing revenue dropped, where are we getting this 40 percent number and surge in fake verified profiles data from? With Twitter now in private ownership, Musk doesn't need to disclose real data and to best of my knowledge hasn't really.
- camjohnson26 4y agohttps://www.theinformation.com/articles/twitter-manager-daily-revenue-has-dropped-40-500-top-advertisers-have-left https://www.theinformation.com/articles/twitter-manager-dail...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- libraryatnight 4y ago[flagged]
- cowmix 4y ago"Meet the new Boss, same as the old Boss" -- and that's a slam on Elon who promised a ton of things like open sourcing the algorithm, etc. All I get now is a bunch of right-wing weirdo crap in my feed that I didn't subscribe to or ask for. And this thing he was complaining about back in May, he completely f'd it up post-purchase: https://www.makeuseof.com/how-to-fix-twitter-feed-elon-musk/ https://www.makeuseof.com/how-to-fix-twitter-feed-elon-musk/
- sneak 4y agoInteresting to me that when Twitter was ascendant the same predictions of doom were not made so frequently when the fail whale was a regular occurrence. It's possible Twitter didn't need to be spending all the money they were to be maintaining five nines or whatever, given the shift in product focus (humans and not a general/universal message bus - bots can't @-mention anymore, etc). Given that they are unprofitable, if I were a shareholder I would be upset if I did not see experiments being run to see how much cost can be cut and where. I doubt people will abandon the platform en masse over a few minutes of downtime here and there. They will lose 100% of users and be down forever if they don't stop the bleeding, however.
- RC_ITR 4y ago> Given that they are unprofitable, if I were a shareholder I would be upset if I did not see experiments being run to see how much cost can be cut and where. Twitter will never get to $44bn market cap again (much less a valuation with a decent IRR) by cutting costs alone. They need to grow way more than they need to cut costs. If any of those experiments lead to less growth (which I’d argue is true of a broken Tweetdeck), then they are wholly not worth it.
- random314 4y ago[flagged]
- hef19898 4y agoIf I were a former Twitter shareholder, I'd be extremely grateful to the board for selling the whole thing for 44 Bn. No way tje company would have reached this evaluation without Musk. And Musk knew it, he just signed himself a contract he couldn't het out of.
- RC_ITR 4y agoAs a nit, Twitter traded well above $44bn for good portions of 2021. It was arguably even a fair price when he offered it (acquisition always have premiums), the market just turned.
- user3939382 4y agoAll services have downtime. Look at AWS last year.
- emilsedgh 4y ago4. Something in between? In short term we'll see some issues but overall nothing important will change and these downtimes and small issues are a justifiable cost for letting such massive cut in the payroll.
- bfeynman 4y agolol, I guess every tech company that has major KPIs for availability is wrong and people are totally fine with apps being down constantly, and new users will totally come back after trying to signup and failing. It's a tech company, a few thousand employees supporting perhaps hundreds of millions of users is pretty standard economies of scale.
- emilsedgh 4y agoWhat keeps Twitter up as a major social network is not %99.99 uptime. It's strong network effects in play. What will sink Twitter is not %99.8 uptime. It's those network effects fading away. For example, if people stopped using MySpace, Facebook, etc it was not because of their availability. Again, I'm not saying this is cool. Im just saying if that extra %0.2 downtime (in short term) costs you 80% of your work force costs, a business manager may consider that acceptable.
- Forgeties79 4y ago>these downtimes and small issues are a justifiable cost for letting such massive cut in the payroll. Well we're not even a year in and these "small issues" seem to be repeatedly occurring. Let's get a little further out with some more stability before we call them justifiable lol
- xwdv 4y ago4. The institutional knowledge is not gone, in the event of any massive catastrophe employees who previously worked at Twitter can return as “consultants” and charge very high rates to fix issues as they occur. It’s pay as you go.
- the_snooze 4y ago>return as “consultants” and charge very high rates to fix issues as they occur. Elon Musk has a rock-solid reputation of paying his bills, after all.
- SamBam 4y agoMassive catastrophes are averted by people with institutional knowledge correctly adding to the hardware/codebase over time, with new features that integrate well with old one, knowing how to scale hardware correctly, patches being applied, etc. Not by bringing people in during a fire and pointing into the smoke and saying "fix that!"
- swatcoder 4y ago> return as “consultants” and charge very high rates to fix issues as they occur. I'm sure there are some people who would do that, but those opportunities become very expensive-to-impossible when you burn bridges the way certain new management has. People hold personal value on things like respect and principle that can make them behave "irrationally" in naive analyses like this.
- tablespoon 4y ago> 4. The institutional knowledge is not gone, in the event of any massive catastrophe employees who previously worked at Twitter can return as “consultants” and charge very high rates to fix issues as they occur. It’s pay as you go. What you're describing is the loss of institutional knowledge with a fantasy tacked on the side. 1) There's no reason to expect those employees would come back, even at rates far higher than Musk is likely willing to pay. Everything indicates Musk has destroyed a lot of goodwill with his shambolic layoffs, and getting people to come back is one of the situations where you need goodwill. You're basically talking about gig-work on a shitty boss's terms. Only desperate people would play that game, and the people Musk would need probably aren't the desperate ones. 2) Any employees that come back are going to be rusty and lack the institutional of what happened after they left, so their effectiveness at immediate fire-fighting will be greatly reduced. 3) If there's a "massive catastrophe" at Twitter, do you think they even know who to call back? I wouldn't be surprised if they've lost a lot of the institutional knowledge about who knew what, at this point.
- soheil 4y ago[flagged]
- guluarte 4y ago3 was the most likely, third party changes slowly breaking stuff
- Ambolia 4y agoOption 4., Twitter was always bad and had strange bugs and outages, but now it's political and people care.
- koumou92 4y agoAlso #4 they are shipping features much more than before. Shipping more always will likely lead to more errors happening. IMO it's a combo of #3 and #4
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]