3 ms·
Someone walking away from a house doesn’t destroy the house. The lender’s risk is therefore limited to the difference between purchase price and actual value o
by Retric 4y ago
Someone walking away from a house doesn’t destroy the house.
The lender’s risk is therefore limited to the difference between purchase price and actual value of the property. Which is something they can hedge or simply not make a loan if they think the property is wildly overvalued.
- sokoloff 4y agoA down payment of 20% provides some of that exact cushion (and makes it less likely for a borrower to casually walk away from a house that fell in value or was otherwise a poor purchase).
- Retric 4y agoIn theory sure, but 20% is an arbitrary regulation not some measurement of risk.
- sokoloff 4y agoDo you think it was chosen without any regard to the risk-mitigation that it offered?
- Retric 4y agoAny regard is a really low standard, minimal is more accurate. You don’t end up with nice round numbers like 20% which never changes due to economic conditions etc from calculating some formula.
- quonn 4y agoIf you look between countries you would see that it‘s usually around 15-25%. So it‘s around 20%, almost everywhere.
- Retric 4y agoThe global range is wider than that and reflects the reasonable range of this kind of regulation. If it’s say 75% then what’s the point of a loan? On the other hand if it’s 1% what’s the point of the regulation? Regulators are basically picking a number between 3.5% to 35% and 20% is a nice round number in the middle of that range.
- bumby 4y ago>Someone walking away from a house doesn’t destroy the house. The experience of the foreclosure crisis seems to differ. I know people who moved into houses where holes were punched into walls and everything was removed that could be, from door knobs to outdoor deck planks.
- uoaei 4y agoYou describe damage to a property that a bank owns. Therefore the costs fall on the bank. This is part of the definition of the concept of "taking on risk" and if banks are not accounting for these outcomes in their business model, they're simply bad at business.
- bumby 4y agoYes (except in the cases of short sales, where I’ve seen the same). My point was not about who assumes that risk, just pushing back on the idea that people wouldn’t damage a house they were going to be forced out of.
- quonn 4y agoOkay, and accounting for the risk is exactly why there is a significant down payment.
- Retric 4y agoSignificant down payments are a result of government regulation not choices by banks.
- bumby 4y agoThis is only true for a federally backed mortgage. Yes, down payment levels, in the context of whether someone needs mortgage insurance, is set by regulation. But down payments can be much less significant if you’re ok with mortgage insurance. Down payments required by banks were typically higher before regulation.
- ejb999 4y ago>>Which is something they can hedge Which is precisely what PMI is for.
- Retric 4y agoPMI is held buy the purchaser not the lender. It’s one of the few financial transactions set up like this.