8 ms·
Autonomous restructuring of asteroids into rotating space stations
- bdg 4y agoHave we solved how to make one spider?
- fnordpiglet 4y ago[flagged]
- gene-h 4y agoUsing automata is a bit silly and has problems. The biggest problems are vacuum welding and lack of lubrication. Vacuum welding can cause higher wear or even failure on metal components. Gears and cams absolutely need lubrication, which is liable to evaporation in a vacuum or requires exotic elements such as molybdenum. Gears and cams also need to be machined, and machining processes do not work well in a vacuum for some of the same reasons mentioned above. That being said, one ton of microchips goes a long way. Why bother with automata, when simple vacuum tubes(in space, a vacuum tube is a couple funny shaped pieces of metal in close proximity) and magnetic amplifiers could be used to amplify signals from microcontrollers into something capable of doing useful work?
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> exotic elements such as molybdenum. What? Molybdenum disulphide grease is available everywhere.
- gene-h 4y agoOn asteroids it will be harder to obtain. It's been found to be present in iron meteorites at about 30 ppm[0]. [0]https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190647926.013.206 https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190647926.013.206
- shagie 4y agoIt's not "exotic" in that it isn't used (it has major industrial Uses) but rather that it is one of the less common materials in the crust. It's less common than many of the "rare earth" elements and less common than uranium (Uranium is the 49th most common element while Molybdenum is the 58th depending on source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth%27s_crust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth... ).
- kwhitefoot 4y agoAccording to your source it is 20th in terms of annual production. Ahead of tungsten and vanadium and a lot of other often used elements like silver.
- Teever 4y agoWhy not just move the asteroid or pieces of the asteroid into a pressurized environment?
- m0llusk 4y agoBecause of the large scale and also because that would be an extra step. This methodology works best if the problem of construction in space has some solution.
- Teever 4y agoIs it an extra step? Like a lot of this stuff is going to end up being used by humans in space so it needs to be pressurized at some point. It doesn't even need to be anywhere near full pressure or breathable gas either.
- balaji1 4y agoCan they build a demo on earth? Maybe reshape a small hill-side into something fun or pretty with "Autonomous Restructuring". That would be fun to watch.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Can they build a demo on earth? Maybe reshape a small hill-side into something fun or pretty with "Autonomous Restructuring". That would be fun to watch. If you are restructuring an asteroid, containment isn’t much of a problem; if you want to do it to an isolated site on earth, it is more of a concern.
- balaji1 4y agowhat is containment?
- ceejayoz 4y agoContainment is to stop the "turn everything into grey goo" robots from considering "Earth" to be part of "everything".
- balaji1 4y agoOh lol we can handle a few sand-castle building robots. ChatGPT on the other hand...
- singleshot_ 4y agoKilldozer would like a word with you, sir.
- foobarian 4y ago> in space, a vacuum tube is a couple funny shaped pieces of metal in close proximity I can't believe this never occurred to me before. The possibilities are staggering :-)
- xen2xen1 4y agoAuthor George O Smith went into great detail about space and vacuum tubes. Actually remember it as a great read.
- actionfromafar 4y agoYeah... there will probably be less fouling, too, because most of the metal vapour will just float away. So the "tubes" should last longer, too.
- Arrath 4y agoJust spitballing: in a use case like TFA, building pieces and structures in/around an asteroid, would they not be subject to fouling by dust and debris from the processes going on around them?
- actionfromafar 4y agoYes sure, but you can still do a lot of interesting stuff without having a lot of radio tubes. You can put up a thin "shield" some meters away. Stuff doesn't have to be very rigid in many cases if it's built "in situ" in space.
- Arrath 4y agoThanks!
- dtgriscom 4y agoI think you would still need the glass envelopes to prevent electrons roaming between devices.
- AustinDev 4y agoFascinating paper, I'm going to have to spend some more time with it later today. I did love this quote though which captures the ethos of what they are proposing: >: Our asteroid restructuring approach can be compared to the effort of early pioneers. A wagon heading west in America in the 1800s could not carry enough supplies to support a family for the journey or at the destination. These pioneers brought tools with them to be self-sufficient [Williams 2016]. Our restructuring relies on self-replication, but more important, on the production of tools to make the restructuring effort self-sufficient and sufficiently productive.
- more_corn 4y agoIf we only had self replicating robots we could have everything we want without having to go build it. This is the engineering equivalent of a perpetual motion machine.
- Teever 4y agoBut self-replicating machines already exist? Life is a good example of one, but the global economy is another.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoits thr holy grail Like Nuclear Fusion, AGI, faster-than-light travel and Biological Immortality. I have a feeling holy grails will stay out of reach for a while.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoOne of these thing is not like the others... I mean, FTL is probably a pipe dream. Nuclear fusion is an economic problem, AGI is on track to happen within our lifetime, biological immortality is in principle possible if you're not super strict about the definitions (i.e. can't beat the heat death of the universe with it), and self-replicating robots are quite literally what all of biology is.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoThey all represent the pinnacle of their respective branch of science. By biological immortality I mean your body doesn't fail, or is fixable - you don't die of old age or random kidney failure. You still die if someone cuts off your head. > self-replicating robots are quite literally what all of biology is By the same argument AGI is just same as human brain. Many people think ChatGPT is so ompressive, that we are on the cust of AGI. I am convinced otherwise - chat gpt makes limitations of current AI approached very clear. My best guess is that AGI will be one of the last items, maybe after FTL
- 4y ago
- jjk166 4y agoEverything important seems to be handwaved away. You can't just say making a "truss building unit" would take a spider 10550 hours of labor, or that spiders operating TBUs will produce truss 416 times faster - show me the design for this spring powered truss builder that takes precisely 3 hours and 3 minutes to produce a unit of truss; show me the spider that builds it, show me the steps along the process of the spider assembling the unit, show me where these numbers are coming from. It would be one thing if these were rough order of magnitude estimations, but the level of precision implies that not to be the case.
- narrator 4y agoWhat's more fun is imagine pointing this thing at earth instead of an asteroid. Soon the whole crust of the earth is turned into paperclips, or trusses or whatever. oops.
- pmayrgundter 4y agoI disagree with your assessment of importance. A work like this strikes me as being primarily important as a "concept of operation", with sketched numbers from (presumably) sub-studies. In other words, my primary concern would be Does the whole thing hang together? Hard to say for such a vast project, so you need to start somewhere with many estimates and placeholders. I wouldn't shoot down the value based on missing references for sub-projects. Especially for what appears to be a solo-author work. I do agree those would be helpful references. I've contacted the author asking for collateral materials and will post back if there's anything to share.
- jjk166 4y agoThe validity of the concept of operation depends entirely on the validity of the assumptions that went into it. If, for example, the truss building unit can't actually make truss much faster than an appropriately designed spider working directly, or if the project would be done before the TBU could be completed, then suddenly the argument for spending a lot of resources building the TBU disappears. Yeah, you gotta start somewhere, but this isn't the place to start.
- jagraff 4y agoThis kind of concept is explored in the (science fiction) novel Seveneves [0] by Neal Stephenson, specifically the first half. Also explored: reshaping and vaporizing the ice on a comet with a nuclear reactor to create an impromptu propulsion device. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seveneves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seveneves
- nlawalker 4y ago2312 by Kim Stanley Robinson features the idea heavily (the main character is a former "asteroid terrarium designer"). The Expanse series has quite a bit of it too.
- gooseyman 4y agoCame here to recommend 2312 & the Expanse as well! Any other content in this genre you enjoy/would recommend? I'm looking for my "next"
- renjimen 4y agoYou might like Alastair Reynolds’ earlier works too. His short story collections are a good place to start (Zima Blue, Diamond Dogs).
- Oxidation 4y agoStephen Baxter's Phase Space. If those short stories, especially the ones with Reid Malenfant, grab you, then read the Manifold series. If you find yourself wishing it was more Alastair Reynolds, then the Xeelee Sequence.
- adamwong246 4y agoCool but why send people to space? Keeping humans alive in space makes the problem so much more difficult. Just move all our industry into space and have the humans stay home.
- midoridensha 4y agoBecause our robotics technology isn't anywhere near sufficient to operate autonomously without needing repairs, or to make decisions on the spot without human intervention.
- winkeyless 4y agoAsteroids are indeed much more dangerous because no atmosphere exists to protect machines and human from space scraps and lights. That said I think human need to be multi-planet to be able to survive big disasters. And asteroids as a small scale space station has its own benefits compared to planets or space crafts. Guessing as a 21st century human of course :)
- wklauss 4y agoThe novel 2312, by Kim Stanley Robinson, explores this idea and has a fun chapter describing the process of hollowing out and terraforming an asteroid, using the ejecta to give it artificial gravity and a stable orbit in the solar system. Highly recommended.
- xupybd 4y agoThanks I'm always looking for good sci-fi.
- idlewords 4y agoThis is a great example of the space fallacy, the idea that things that are impossible to do on Earth are somehow practical technologies for space. If it's all so easy to do, then go hollow out your local mountain; I promise it will get people's attention.
- adastra22 4y agoHallowing out a mountain would be much easier and in fact not all that impressive if (1) it was actually a rubble pile, and (2) no gravity.
- idlewords 4y agoIt's our bad luck that all the easy stuff got put in space.
- andrewflnr 4y agoI'd settle for hollowing out an actual rubble pile as a demo. I'd be ecstatic, honestly, if you dumped any package of machines on a rubble pile and it autonomously, with only solar power, produced any machine more complicated than a bar of metal (and even that bar of metal would be no joke). Refining raw materials is hard. At least in space you'd be able to melt things in the open without them immediately oxidizing to hell. Gravity is dubious as pro or con. It's honestly kind of handy sometimes, as a spatial organizing principle if nothing else.
- frankreyes 4y agoThe Expanse, scifi book and tv show, explored this concept. So fun
- rzzzt 4y agoCan't the robots pull together space junk instead?
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoMaybe we could start with completely autonomous construction on Earth first?
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoI can't believe HN is poo-pooing this when all you have to do is send ChatGPT to the asteroid and !poof! it will be done.
- pmayrgundter 4y agoHoly moly.. this is amazing. It's incredibly thorough. Thank you David Jensen! Eros is one of the asteroids considered! Take note, fans of The Expanse.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chinabot 4y agoPerfect timing as I'm writing my second book and it has this as one of the premises
- gnarbarian 4y agowhat's your first book? I love stuff like this!
- chinabot 4y ago"The summer of Reasoning" amazon ASIN B0BVBNRSJ7 - Warning its more YA than HN and nothing about space in the first book