6 ms·
Genes reveal striking diversity within similar ice age cultures
- dav_Oz 4y agohttps://archive.is/W05Mq https://archive.is/W05Mq
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoReally underscores the validity of the maxim "pots are not people"; looking back we tend to over-emphasize the centrality of the material artifacts we have. So, ceramics and metalwork, etc. And from that draw outsized conclusions about cultures and their boundaries and patterns and migrations, even assuming languages and polities. But there's so much complexity to human culture that's simply lost to time and decay, that we will never see. EDIT: Consider hypothetically, what would happen if far-future archaeologists were to dig up material culture from Quebec, but also hypothetically did not have any language (written, or recorded) or historical knowledge? They'd look at the material culture -- and even maybe genetics -- and be mostly unable to tell the difference between the Quebecois and the surrounding North American cultures. In most respects this is just standard North American material culture. But it's a totally different culture, speaking French etc, with its own distinct history, politics, etc.
- softwaredoug 4y agoAlso that the recent work studying genetics in fossil remains are not a panacea for understanding human prehistory.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoAbsolutely agree. It's just more information, and there's plenty of cases where you can have multiple cultures with the same or similar material culture, similar genetics, but different e.g. spoken language or political arrangements. (Like Quebec in Canada, e.g.) Need that time machine.
- cm2187 4y agoThe archeologists are struggling with cultures that have left no record. We know lots of stuff about, say, the Roman empire. I think future archeologists will struggle with the opposite, with us leaving a gigantic amount of data behind. Just think of what the gmail account of the next Hitler can teach you. I see no reason to think that we won’t be able to preserve that data as the cost of data storage keeps shrinking.
- Eumenes 4y agoWe'll see what an EMP will do about that .. I, for one, think a fresh start would be good for our planet.
- concordDance 4y agoA population under a billion would admittedly make environment management much easier.
- simiones 4y agoGiven that vast amounts of data have already been lost, even ones still considered valuable (e.g. the source code of some popular early games), I honestly see no chance that digital data will survive anything close to how well books survive, let alone comparisons with stone tablets. I'll be honestly surprised if I can still access all my pictures stored today in the cloud by the time I'm in my seventies, 40 years from now. All it takes is a banned account, a forgotten password, one too many lost MFA factors, and bye bye data.
- jl6 4y agoPerhaps today's oversized data legacy is the dirt and rubble through which future archaeologists will have to dig, to find relevant information.
- layer8 4y agoIf there’s ever a breakdown of civilization, or even just a worldwide dictatorship for long enough, that data could easily be destroyed and lost forever.
- 4y ago
- tinco 4y agoThis idea struck me with the recent article about the Danish girl that was reconstructed with her newborn baby. The baby was resting on a swan's wing, and the girl was buried with 200 reindeer's teeth. All sorts of symbolism and mysticism was attributed to the artefacts that were buried with the unfortunate pair. But if you would consider really objectively, how would such a pair be buried today and what would our thoughts be? I feel it would be fitting to bury the baby in the crib she was received in, a swan wing being a pretty convenient object to receive a newborn in. And the girl might be buried with her most prized collection, the reindeer teeth that her dad would gift her every time he returned from a successful hunt. Just basic human things, not even much to do with culture, just these individuals and their circumstances.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoThe feeling I get when I hear of these things is a kind of longing to see and feel their life for a while. Not that I want to live their lifestyle, because it would be hard; but there's just something about the paleolithic time that feels like an almost eternal substratum to the human existence that was then lost. The way people lived for a couple hundred thousand years, a tradition broken only in the last few millennia. Take stone tool making -- an art that goes back beyond our species, to the homo genus itself, as a universal hominid skill. Now mostly lost to us. That's kind of sad.
- farnsworth 4y agoSo many societal issues can be explained by the fact that the conditions that we're living in now are so different than the conditions under which we evolved for hundreds of thousands of years. And also the fact that we were naturally selected for survival, not happiness. Civilization is all about denying your nature in order to build a better way of life based on stacks of technology. This isn't a bad thing, I would also rather live in a modern society, it's just really confusing unless you work out the ways in which your brain is not actually suited for it and how to cope with this.
- riskable 4y ago> Take stone tool making -- an art that goes back beyond our species, to the homo genus itself, as a universal hominid skill. Now mostly lost to us. That's kind of sad. It's not sad! We have much better ways to make tools these days. It's like lamenting the lost art of (incredibly tediously) drawing out circuit boards or drafting blueprints by hand. Will people of the future be sad about having lost the art of finding things to do while a progressive JPEG (porn) loaded over a dialup connection?
- concordDance 4y ago> But it's a totally different culture, speaking French etc, with its own distinct history, politics, etc. That "totaly" seems just wrong to me. The cultures are incredibly similar in how they live, which is why they leave the same artefacts. A pair of truly different cultures would be something like pre-colonisation Maori and the ancient Hittites.
- mritchie712 4y agoAgreed. I'm from the US, I don't feel out of place or uncomfortable at all in Quebec, but I'd have a hard time operating in pre-colonisation Maori.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoStereotype: American tourists don't feel out of place anywhere :-) As a Canadian, I love Quebec but it feels distinctly quite different. And the point of my comparison here not to compare situations like Maori and now, but that two cultures can be side by side and have a 90% same material (and even genetic) make-up, while still having entirely different linguistic, political and historical aspects. That would not be observable in a purely material analysis, a few thousand years down the line.
- 752963e64 4y ago[dead]
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoIt's coming into sharper focus that pre-historic humans had almost the exact same genetic variability as humans do today. The difference was in the environment: 1. Humans were a *tiny* but growing population (estimated <2M by 50,000BC) 2. The population of fauna and foragable food was in ridiculous abundance 3. Climate was in a Goldilocks period for human growth coming out of an ice age So when humans got to certain population sizes and consumed most of the easy to access food, the whole system collapsed and got flipped upside down into what we have today: society based on excludable property instead of a society based on communal sharing https://kemendo.com/Myth.pdf https://kemendo.com/Myth.pdf
- NorthOf33rd 4y agoMost of the population of North and Central America remained communal until colonial contact. there were plenty of examples of agricultural societies within that group, and they were farming because it was easier than than other food supplies.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoFully concur. The distinction between agriculturalists and nomadic hunters in my estimation is that it was a rapid shift in the majority behavior but there was always some "mix" of nomadic and agricultural starting around 150,000BC It's just that the shift went from 90% nomadic to 99% agricultural over the span of only 100k years or so
- swalling 4y agoSuggesting the Americas were some communal relic of Ice Age cultures before European arrival is laughably wrong. As far north as modern St Louis, the Mississippian city of Cahokia was larger than contemporaneous London 1,000 years before contact. You then have the Mayan, Incan, and Aztec Empires that were highly stratified civilizations featuring warfare, state religion, slavery, and pyramid building. This misperception exists largely because most of the population was wiped out by introduced disease long before European colonization happened in earnest in most areas. (Read 1491 by Charles Mann.)
- precompute 4y agoI lost this post a few paragraphs in, posting anyway: There is only so much that can be gleaned from found evidence. The customs and assumptions of our time also affect the way we reconstruct these stories and civilizations. In many cases, the archaeological evidence is never even recovered: our entire civilization lives above those that came before us. Sometimes, even outright fabrication is allowed for decades[1][2] in the guise of "advancement of Science™". In my opinion, musing about "different populations" on the basis of subtle positioning of things is an exercise in futility. Even with genetic evidence, there is very little that can be said about the relationship between those peoples and the things found -- maybe those were relics carried by outsiders, or remorse by genociders (a population does not just "vanish") or really anything else. Even when closely examining large structures like the Great Pyramid, there's evidence of engineering that far surpasses our own[3][4]. Uncanny coincidences that do not make sense[5] but readily integrate into our myths surround us[6] and are often destroyed by us[7]. So what really is the best way to figure out our past? As with most things, accountability over a long period of time. Humans have trouble keeping history straight over even a few decades. Knowledge lost to out of date customs, or just plain language idiosyncrasies[8] can make even the recent past opaque to most. Even the Epic of Gilgamesh seems to be tampered with: statues of the bull-rider (Enkidu) predate the tablets by many, many years, from before Gilgamesh's reign. We've found that dogs were domesticated over a long period of time. That means there were many, many accidents along the way. Even Woolly Mammoth bones found under cliffs meant there were very intelligent hunters among us. Even the fact that a species survived thousands of years of sub-zero temperatures should stop us in awe. We live in the Holocene, which seems to be life on easy mode: good temperatures, just enough CO2 and conditions favorable to analog information archiving, enabling civilization, hard industry and easy transport, with an easily targetable animal population. This is what I think is true: at some point, the human(oid?)s living in sync with their environment were disrupted by another group, and this group was so fundamentally alien to whatever the norm was, that it quickly conquered most of the planet. Its superiority in numbers seems to have been great enough to enable similar outcomes for groups separated by great distances. Most of the evidence points to that group being us, that we likely genocided many, many humanoid races just to get here. Here's a poem that I like, that seems to convey similar emotion: https://www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poem/poems_copybook.htm https://www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poem/poems_copybook.htm And at the risk of making this entire post sound like satire (it's not), here's some links to the Finno-Korean Hyperwar of 8245BC[9][10][11][12] [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2005/feb/19/science.sciencenews https://www.theguardian.com/science/2005/feb/19/science.scie... [2]: http://web.archive.org/web/20220516153818/http://johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/news/protsched.html http://web.archive.org/web/20220516153818/http://johnhawks.n... [3]: https://www.gizapower.com/Advanced/Advanced%20Machining.html https://www.gizapower.com/Advanced/Advanced%20Machining.html [4]: https://www.ancient-origins.net/ancient-places-africa/egypt-pyramids-0013249 https://www.ancient-origins.net/ancient-places-africa/egypt-... [5]: http://ancientmoons.com/trees.html http://ancientmoons.com/trees.html [6]: https://www.ancient-origins.net/myths-legends/dragons-exploring-ancient-origins-mythical-beasts-006407 https://www.ancient-origins.net/myths-legends/dragons-explor... [7]: https://www.ancient-origins.net/myths-legends-asia/dragon-teeth-hunters-and-mindless-destruction-history-009731 https://www.ancient-origins.net/myths-legends-asia/dragon-te... [8]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bar_joke#cite_note-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bar_joke#cite_note-1 [9]: https://vixra.org/pdf/1809.0081v1.pdf https://vixra.org/pdf/1809.0081v1.pdf [10]: https://old.reddit.com/r/AlternateHistory/comments/nba85t/today_i_found_out_about_the_finnokorean_hyperwar/ https://old.reddit.com/r/AlternateHistory/comments/nba85t/to... [11]: https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/2007541-his https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/2007541-his [12]: https://old.reddit.com/r/imaginarymaps/comments/puryu1/eurasia_in_the_midst_of_the_finnokorean_war/ https://old.reddit.com/r/imaginarymaps/comments/puryu1/euras...
- photochemsyn 4y agoAn interesting, and still somewhat contentious question, is whether these groups of people are responsible for the extinction of the mammoth population of Europe. It's likely that humans did play a central role in the destruction of the large mammal population, and some groups of humans disappeared or moved on after they'd hunted down the last of the big game. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-10714-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-10714-x > "Furthermore, it is possible to conclude that the Late Epigravettian population had high degree of quarry-fidelity; they left the basin when these mammals vanished." The notion of hunter-gather societies living harmoniously in equilibrium with nature that some people seem to view as an optimal societal arrangement doesn't fit very well with this scenario. Granted, it's unlikely that they wanted to hunt all the large animals to extinction, but it's another case of not having knowledge about the long-term consequences of their actions (which is not an excuse for human behavior today, however).
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoYou're correct that there is no consensus on WHY but it's very well agreed upon that the crash did happen 1, 2, 3 below In my research, it seems to follow pretty closely that within 5,000-10,000 years of humans arriving in a territory with abundant mega-fauna, that the megafauna are completely wiped out. However the increase in global temperature put additional pressure on mega-fauna as the earth warmed My naiive interpretation is that climate warming into the Holocene put significant pressures on mega-fauna ecology, and humans took advantage of these new pressures and over-consumed the fauna. They did not realize there was such a thing as "running out of food." It seems pretty clear to me that 200,000-10,000BC was this kind of wonderland of human growth because all of the conditions were perfect for humans to just totally dominate the landscape with relative ease. The problem is, we are just smart enough as a group to mess things up really efficiently for short term benefits (within two generations), but we're not smart enough to act as though we're planning for 5-10 generations into the future. [1] Christopher, S., et.al. (2014). Global late quaternary megafauna extinctions linked to humans, not climate change. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences [2] Ellis, E.C. (2021) People have shaped most of terrestrial nature for at least 12,000 years, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118 (17). [3] Stewart, M., Carleton, W.C. & Groucutt, H.S. (2021) Climate change, not human population growth, correlates with Late Quaternary megafauna declines in North America. Nat Commun 12, 965.
- entropicgravity 4y agoWith prehistoric humans there's a constant tension between us vs them on the one hand and inbreeding on the other hand.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoI cannot understand why it is so hard to get people interested in our current genetic diversity and how it may change out comes in everything from diet to disease. I became a bit of a amateur nutritional geneticist over the last ten years it I have cured my self (mostly) of schizoaffective bipolar disorder as well as my anklosing spondylitis through a mixture of genetics, diet and supplements. Our genes are shaped by our environment, and that was true even back 30,000 years ago. They say in that article "Despite broadly similar hunting and gathering lifestyles, people in Western Europe remain genetically distinct from those east of the Baltic Sea." Hinting and gathering what? Fish or plants? That difference will change FADS1 and FADS2 genetics in a few generations. And we all carry genetics older than our great grandparents from divers places and everyone things we should all be eating the same food and living the same life. And in he end they lay it down to population mixing! MAybe it has more to do with environmental pressures.
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]