4 ms·
MBTI are pseudoscience (just like astrology); there is no such thing as an INTP no matter how much you may feel to be described by the type.
by sneak 4y ago
MBTI are pseudoscience (just like astrology); there is no such thing as an INTP no matter how much you may feel to be described by the type.
- tpoacher 4y agoMBTI and things like INTP are 'definitions'. Trying to make business decisions on the basis of MBTI metrics, which is what it is often criticised for, is of course misguided. But saying "MBTI is pseudoscience you cannot be INTP" makes as much sense as "Hair colour names are unscientific, so you can't identify as blond". Sure you can. It's a description. I wouldn't go ascribing intelligence on the basis of hair colour, but I wouldn't doubt you have a hair colour either. And if you've found commonalities / common experiences and like being with other blond people, that's fine too.
- nemetroid 4y agoThe initial sentence of the original comment is the pseudoscientific part. > That's a typical INTP / type 5 enneagram brain wiring.
- thiago_fm 4y agoI love how on the internet, people make a big effort to criticize arguments and not show any evidence that AT LEAST, proves that their criticism makes sense. So here I ask you: given that Psychology is a social SCIENCE, also a part of STEM. And psychologists definitely use those tests, I was personally introduced to them by a psychologist that helped me with career coaching, recognized on his field with a bunch of papers. Now, please explain yourself: why is it a pseudoscience? I want proofs.
- nicoburns 4y agoThe MBTI is descriptive. However, it claims to be descriptive of internal mental processes, which it posits to exist in a certain way (admittedly not everything interprets the MBTI this way, but IMO this is the only interpretation under which the MBTI is an interesting theory). I'm personally quite open to the idea that it's an accurate categorisation, but I do also think that it's an extroadinary claim that requires extroadinary justification. IMO saying "oh, it's just a description" because that evidence hasn't (yet) been found is a bit of a cop out.
- flippinburgers 4y agoLets be real though. Nobody just stops at they are INTP. This is the kind of thing that corporate busybodies in HR - or something related - will use to evaluate people.
- PedroBatista 4y agoCool, you’re pointing out something many also agree, but how exactly is your comment even remotely constructive? There’s much more in OP’s comment than Myers-Briggs.
- nicoburns 4y agoMBTI differs significantly from astrology in that it's posited mechanism of action (genetics/early life experiences) is actually plausible, unlike astrology which suggests that differences in personality are due to astral bodies. It's pretty unsurprising that we're unable to measure the cognitive processes the MBTI posits given how limited our ability is to measure the brain in general. So I wouldn't count it out just because there's no experimental evidence (yet). I've been able to observe the difference between what the MBTI calls "Judgement" (slow thinking) and what the MBTI calls "Perception" (fast thinking) in real life. The example I always give is my high school "Further Maths" class. There were 4 people in my class and it happened that we always ended up working in pairs. However the way in which each pair worked was entirely different: - Pair 1 (me and my partner) worked independently, rushing through the questions by intuiting answers to each step. We'd then compare answers as a kind of checksum. If our answers differed, often one of us would immediately notice a mistake. And if not then we'd fall back to slowly working through the problem together step-by-step. - Pair 2 (the other two students) defaulted to this approach of slowly working through each problem step-by-step together. This took longer up front, but produced more accurate answers. Interesting, both approaches actually ended up taking a similar amount of time overall and yielding a similar accuracy of answer. But there is a huge qualitative difference in the kind of thinking that took place in each approach, and each person in the class also demonstrated a clear and stable preferrence for a specific approach. There is also a vast body of literature on "Dual-process theories" like this one, popularised by Daniel Kahneman's book Thinking Fast and Slow.
- bombolo 4y ago> So I wouldn't count it out just because there's no experimental evidence That's not how science works. If you have a hypothesis with no experimental evidence, discussing it as a fact is akin to doing astrology. I'm sure you're aware that most people recognize themselves in horoscopes descriptions of their personality. This is quite similar to that.
- nicoburns 4y ago> That's not how science works. If you have a hypothesis with no experimental evidence, discussing it as a fact is akin to doing astrology. Sure, but you can discuss it as theory without implying that it's proven fact. Most (if not all?) theories that are now considered scientific fact initially went through a period where they were lacking in conclusive experimental evidence. > I'm sure you're aware that most people recognize themselves in horoscopes descriptions of their personality. This is quite similar to that. I am. And that's why I think the plausibility of the theory is important. There's a difference between saying "people think in way A and way B" and "whether people think in way A or way B is determined by the position of the planets at the time they were born". I guess I would say that it's not quite true that there's no experimental evidence. It's more the case that the academic discipline "experimental psychology" has failed to find evidence. Other disciplines like cognitive science and behavioural economics tend not to have studied the MBTI specifically, but have found experimental evidence for theories that are substantially similar enough to the MBTI's hypotheses that IMO they do count as some evidence. Specifically there is experimental evidence that: - There are qualitatively different ways in which people can think and process information. - People can have a stable preference for a given thinking process. And that such preferences follow a bimodal distribution. - People can have a preference towards either introversion or extraversion (MBTI's I vs. E distinction) - People can think either in a "Fast" way (fast, intuitive, perceptually inaccesible) or a "Slow" way (slow, reasoned, perceptually accesible) (MBTI's J vs. P distinction) That's evidence for ~50% of the MBTI already, and would leave "Feeling" vs. "Thinking" (value judgement vs. descriptive judgement) and "Sensing" vs. "Intiuton" (concrete vs. abstract thinking) as interesting research questions.
- MadSudaca 4y agoI disagree. There’s no casual pathway between Astrology and who you are. With MBTI you respond to a questionnaire, so there is some connection to you. How accurate this is, well that’s a topic for debate. However, the most accurate personality models are also based on questionnaires of this sort. Some time ago I also thought MBTI was bullshit, now I think it’s quite useful. And at least for me, anecdotally, has predictive power.
- sneak 4y ago> How accurate this is, well that’s a topic for debate. Not really; we know for a fact it is not accurate (and thus irrelevant). You can debate it if you wish but the facts of the matter have been long settled.
- MadSudaca 4y agoDepends on how you define accuracy.
- jiggunjer 4y agoAccuracy isn't binary. Not being perfect doesn't mean it is irrelevant. My map of the city could be more accurate but it still gets me where I need to go.
- DarkNova6 4y agoThat’s only in regards to the questionnaire, not the underlying system. If you understand the cognitive function, your prediction is a magnitude more accurate than any test.
- bovermyer 4y agoOK, I'll bite. Not so much because I'm a defender of Myers-Briggs, but because there are significant problems with your two sentences here. > we know Who knows? Who is "we?" > it is not accurate Accuracy is not either "PERFECTLY TRUE" or "PERFECTLY FALSE." It is a range. > (and thus irrelevant) Even false statements or frameworks can provide interesting insights into how we think about a domain. > the facts of the matter Which facts would that be? > have been long settled By whom? In what study or paper? Were they properly tested?
- cjbgkagh 4y agoTheir competitor mainstream psychology was fathered and dominated for a long time by Sigmund Freud. His success probably had more to do to his nephew Edward Bernays and the yearly exclusive balls for the elites than anything scientific. Now there is Nudge Theory which is marred by the replication crisis and repeat fabricators; hardly scientific (though more common in academia than it should be) but it tells governments what they want to hear so it’ll stay successful until the flaws are too obvious to ignore (note that I don’t follow the field overly closely). The MBTI is just a projection of the personality space like the more accepted Big 5. From my experience data-mining behavioral data at scale it’s a pretty good mapping and the relative value questions are adequate and the 4 dimensions do explain a lot of behavior to the point that it is very useful - a fact probability contributing to its success. My main gripe with it is the extrovert - introvert axis is a bit weak with many people being close to the middle. I’m more extroverted around intelligent people which doesn’t happen as often as I’d like, a trait held by far more commonly by ENTJ/INTJ than random chance.
- nicoburns 4y ago> My main gripe with it is the extrovert - introvert axis is a bit weak with many people being close to the middle I think that's partly because people don't understand what extraverted vs. introverted mean in the MBTI sense. It's not about sociability. It's actually about how much external stimuli someone likes more generally. This might be social stimuli (Fe), but it could also be physical stimuli (Se) (for example, liking being physically active or out in nature) or more conceptual stimuli / external ideas (Ne), etc. Or a computing analogy: what's your ratio of IO to CPU time. Also, at least in the cognitive function interpretation (which IMO is the only sensible theory in the jungian/mbti family), introversion and extraversion do not apply directly to persons. They apply to thinking processes. An extraverted person is then just a person who uses an extraverted thinking mode more often than not (everyone is theorised to use both extraverted and introverted thinking modes). As you note this bias can be more or less extreme. Indeed, it's been observed that it can both be influenced by external factors (e.g. social expectations), and that it tends to become less extreme over time. As such, a persons "type" is generally considered to be determined by what their preference was in childhood, and (the type) is taken to define their baseline personality (cf. genotype) from which their actually observable personality (cf phenotype) develops.
- a3w 4y agoMBTI are pseudoscience -> This. It absolutely fails to make predictions, except that people who describe themselves as liking to think are people who like to think, and other obvious ideas. It is very hyped in actual application, though. As is homeopathy and astrology. <edit> Big Five Personality traits and the HEXACO model exist, and they seem to have more a more positive scientific review history. “Your boss is probably someone more likely to have qualities from the dark triad” is still bad news when looking at the real world versus an ideal world, but this seems to be a checked fact. </edit> There is some evidence to suggest that the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) may not be as reliable and valid as its proponents suggest. In fact, some studies have found that the MBTI does not consistently yield the same results for individuals who take it multiple times, which raises questions about its reproducibility and the reliability of the results. For example, a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that only about half of individuals who took the MBTI twice received the same result both times. This suggests that the MBTI may not be a reliable measure of personality traits. In addition, other studies have found that the MBTI does not reliably predict job performance or other real-world outcomes, further questioning its validity as a psychological assessment tool.
- nicoburns 4y agoThe questionaire is bullshit (how on earth would we expect to measure thinking processes through a questionaire), but the underlying theory is a lot more interesting. It's terms (like "thinking") are technical jargon that don't correspond to their usual meanings though. For example "thinking" is really "descriptive judegement" (cognition focussed on whether things are true/false/possible/impossible), to be contrasted with "feeling" (which is actually also a rational cognitive process!) just focussed on "value judgement" (cognition focussed on whether things are good/bad/should happen/shouldn't happen). It is also not supposed to measure personality traits in the same sense that other models do. It is two steps removed: 1. It attempts to measure interal cognitive processes rather than external behavoural traits (how you think, not what you think) 2. It attempts to measure people's natural personality baseline (cf genotype) from which their actual personality (cf phenotype) develops as modified by their life experiences and the context in which they live. Both of which make it even more difficult to measure with a questionaire that tends to only ask about current behaviours. But IMO also make it a much more interesting and much more plausible theory.
- Zurrrrr 4y agoIt's not just a pseudoscience, it's a cult.
- callesgg 4y agoIt's a categorical system. It categorises people in to groups on dimensions. Dimensions that are ultimately defined by the questions that give the category. You can measure people on many dimensions, and all dimensions that are not truly random will correlate with some aspect of the persons life. Interestingly, some of the dimensions of the MTBI correlate with dimensions of the "Big 5". Introversion - Extroversion => Almost the same dimension as in Big 5. Intuitive - Sensation => Correlate strongly to Big 5 Openness The longer textual descriptions of the MTBI categories that one can find online are "made up" so they could indeed be said to be a type of pseudoscience.
- ayewo 4y agoWhat do you make of DiSC then? https://www.discprofile.com/what-is-disc https://www.discprofile.com/what-is-disc