4 ms·
> All else being equal, we would expect 50% of homes to be unaffordable to a median buyer. This is the reasonable base figure (not zero). Not so. In a market w
by AnthonyMouse 4y ago
> All else being equal, we would expect 50% of homes to be unaffordable to a median buyer. This is the reasonable base figure (not zero).
Not so. In a market where new homes are produced until prices fall below the construction cost and construction costs are modest, it's possible that a large majority or even 100% of local homes could be affordable to the median buyer.
- nl 4y agoLocation still has value.
- htag 4y ago1. Different houses will be on different sized lots with different locations. This will create variance in price. 2. Different houses will be different sizes, made with different materials. This will create variance in price. 3. This market is oversimplified. Construction costs can rise if too much construction is happening (competition for labor and materials). Lower housing costs would attract buyers into the market that don't currently exist, driving up demand. Affordability is impacted by the cost of financing, which is rising. 4. New construction housing prices are actually really close to land value + construction costs. If you can find a way to make construction costs more modest then you have a fantastic future in real estate development.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> This will create variance in price. Prices can vary and still all be affordable. Everyone isn't required to buy the most expensive thing they can possibly afford. > New construction housing prices are actually really close to land value + construction costs. If you can find a way to make construction costs more modest then you have a fantastic future in real estate development. Zoning and regulatory changes. > This market is oversimplified. Construction costs can rise if too much construction is happening (competition for labor and materials). Lower housing costs would attract buyers into the market that don't currently exist, driving up demand. Affordability is impacted by the cost of financing, which is rising. Lowering the cost of new construction is the premise. Ramping up construction capacity is a short-term issue, after which costs may decline further from economies of scale. "Lower prices increase demand" doesn't result in high prices because if the price remained high there would be no increase in demand. What it causes is an increase in supply, since suppliers can profitably build even more housing at that price and will continue to do so until that is no longer true. Higher interest rates have a largely neutral effect on affordability because they cause sale prices to decline.
- sokoloff 4y ago> Prices can vary and still all be affordable. Some percentage of the top of the range will always be unaffordable to the median income. Whatever a high-floor apartment overlooking Central Park costs is something that a median income won’t be able to afford. (IMO, that’s totally fine/normal.)
- htag 4y agoYea it seems unrealistic. I imagine many people buying a home at $N would prefer to upgrade finishings or increase the size of the dwelling, or put in a tennis court than to actually pay less than $N. You can almost indefinitely add marble counter tops or antique bricks to increase the cost of a home. This luxury side of the market is actually considerable.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> Some percentage of the top of the range will always be unaffordable to the median income. Maybe not in Manhattan, but you can certainly imagine some more modest town where the median house and the highest priced house are priced within the same order of magnitude and the latter is still affordable to the median buyer.
- topkai22 4y agoOnly if there is zero market segmentation going on. My area is seeing a large number of new units go up, but they range from developments with no units below $1.5M to where all units are below $600k. And even if you saw uniformity in the housing stock going in, the existing housing stock is going to vary. My parents just moved from a small city with a super depressed housing market. Current listings range from $90k to $900k- even in bad markets there are pockets high prices.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoStill possible with market segmentation. Suppose the median home buyer could afford a $300,000 house, but the construction cost for the median existing house is $50,000. $200,000 houses then might exist and the median buyer could afford them, but maybe they have better uses for $150,000 than to buy a house with twelve bedrooms when they only need three.
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago> but maybe they have better uses for $150,000 than to buy a house with twelve bedrooms when they only need three. Especially when a proportion of households are older people who are downsizing. This isn't the Baby boom era anymore when the vast bulk of the home buying population is going after houses based on location to schools or jobs. The locations important for older people aren't exactly the same as for younger people.