3 ms·
I think the first bar graph in this article is excellent. I was actually pleasantly surprised that you only had to go back to 2013 to find a situation where 50%
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I think the first bar graph in this article is excellent. I was actually pleasantly surprised that you only had to go back to 2013 to find a situation where 50% of houses for sale were affordable on the median income, which is what you would expect in a balanced situation.
In terms of "where this ends", that graph actually made me more hopeful, because it highlights the transitory nature of the current situation. The reason for-sale inventory is currently so unaffordable is you had a ton of people who paid top dollar for houses in the past few years, but at rock bottom rates. Now rates have skyrocketed, but unemployment is also really low, so at present few people are forced to sell. So you have a ton of people who just refuse to sell right now, because the price would be drastically lower than what they paid when they bought, and they're sitting on long-term mortgages with rates that they'll never see again in their lifetimes.
At some point, either inflation will catch up with home prices, or people will eventually be forced to sell (not just due to job loss but for tons of other reasons that people are putting off right now because they don't want to sell at a loss). The overhang could easily last years, though.
- slantedview 4y ago> The reason for-sale inventory is currently so unaffordable is you had a ton of people who paid top dollar for houses in the past few years, but at rock bottom rates That's part of it. The other part is that builders stopped building enough to keep up with population growth over the last decade, which contributed to the massive inventory shortage. Couple that with the supply side crunch of the pandemic, which made it more expensive than ever to build, and we have a perfect storm.
- nerdponx 4y agoThere was an article posted here a while ago about how the supply of smaller starter homes specifically is much lower than it used to be in the past.
- crooked-v 4y agoOf course, much of that is that many major cities effectively stopped builders from building anything. See, for example, Santa Monica, which allowed a total of 225 new housing units per year for the past twenty years, and where there are now thousands of new units in planning this year because of California's builder's remedy rules bypassing local refusal.
- hackernewds 4y ago> The other part is that builders stopped building enough to keep up with population growth over the last decade, the other essential layer is why? because America is spoilt at utilizing their homesteads as their largest wealth generation asset, even supported by the Federal Reserve that consistently chooses to harm stocks and bonds. never meant to be sustainable with those incentives in place.
- nerdponx 4y agoI don't think the situation is necessarily transitory in areas like Boston and New York, which were already experiencing some form of a housing supply crisis since before Covid.