9 ms·
Porn Zoom bomb forces cancellation of Fed's Waller event
- timcavel 4y ago[dead]
- mjhay 4y agoWe have the most competent people possible running our country and the world economy. There was no way to avoid this.
- nvr219 4y agoNot a zoom bomb, it was just one guy signed in.
- fwlr 4y agoTheir settings for this meeting allowed arbitrary users to show their desktops and/or webcams, and didn’t have users muted by default either. Sounds like PEBCAK.
- pharrington 4y agoExactly. The situation was just "a non-mission critical thing had a one-off misconfiguration," which is the least alarming thing in the history of technology.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoIf such a mistake is too easy to make, this sounds to me like a UX design issue.
- charcircuit 4y agoIt's more of a mismatch between the intended use case of zoom of having meetings compared to what they wanted to accomplish.
- ratorx 4y agoIt seems like the kind of defaults that should depend on the visibility of the meeting. Public -> No webcams and muted by default, normal -> webcams and mics.
- bawolff 4y agoMost security issues are from one perspective or another
- fwlr 4y agoThe UX is fine (see https://uis.georgetown.edu/zoom/meeting-controls/participant-settings/#screen https://uis.georgetown.edu/zoom/meeting-controls/participant...), the universe just built a better idiot
- jeroenhd 4y agoAre you sure? Some very basic mass meeting settings are spread across at least five or six menus and popups, all available once the meeting has already started. You can't set the "people can't unmute themselves by default" flag without muting everyone else in the meeting first, it seems. Half or more of these options should go in a single "meeting configuration" screen in my opinion. If you just start using the software, you'll have to go through every menu and click every button just to discover the ways people can disturb your meeting. This seems like a terrible user interface for any meeting that's either important or features more than a handful of people.
- 4y ago
- 1letterunixname 4y agoMaybe if you're a worldwide powerhouse organization responsible for moving markets with reports and forecasts, you should cough up the coin to run your own conference infrastructure or adopt Workplace.
- PraetorianGourd 4y agoMaybe if you're the leading provider of meeting software used the world over, you should work to ensure that it is incredibly trivial to host a secure meeting
- helf 4y ago[dead]
- astrea 4y ago> Microphones and video were not muted by the organizer upon joining. We are decades into videoconferencing software, and 3 years into heavy usage of it by everyone from CEOs to my grandma and we're still fucking up the fundamentals? This is why the government is a joke.
- lazide 4y agoThe government? Everyone screws it up. Let’s not talk about projecting/displaying presentations either.
- dpcan 4y agoEvery week we go through this at work STILL. I sit there with my system working perfectly. I can hear. I can talk. They can hear me. They can see me. It's fine. But there are 3 other people in there that are muted and can't figure it out, someone is called in and on their computer, echo everywhere, someone can't hear, someone can't get their mic to work, someone just gets frustrated and screams that we should "do it in person". I just don't get it anymore. I can't figure out how any of this is challenging for anyone. Especially when they've all done it 50+ times now. Oh, and the team member who only has her forehead in the shot? Or the person who constantly changes their background through the whole meeting? Or the person who just gets up and walks away in the middle. Can you feel it? It's Sunday night here for me. Monday is quickly approaching and I just can't stomach the thought of doing this all over again.
- sn_master 4y agoI have problems with being muted when I join with Google Meet in Safari desktop that goes away when I re-join without doing anything else at all. Many times it's really just bad software and not just user incompetency. The worst part is that it doesn't happen all the time or to all the users, so the engineers don't care or don't have enough steps to reproduce the bug.
- SoftTalker 4y agoEvery virtual meeting in the non-tech world is like this. Zoom is way easier for people than its alternatives but in a world of fools nothing is foolproof.
- civicsquid 4y ago> We were a victim of a teleconference or Zoom hijacking and we are trying to understand what we need to do going forward to prevent this from ever happening again I don't know if there are more details elsewhere, but I feel like a solution here is to not host the meeting in such a way that allows others to share anything (or at least only allow authorized users to join)? Although I would think that a 'broadcast' of the meeting followed by text-based follow-ups from people not physically present would be an even better system. Maybe there are more requirements that I don't know about.
- theshrike79 4y agoZoom specifically has a mode for this. I've been in Zoom meetings with C-level staff and 2k+ people listening in. The people viewing couldn't turn on their cameras or microphones. They could only listen and present questions in a moderated chat channel.
- chongli 4y agoI think what likely happened is that the zoom call was started by a non-technical person who didn’t realize how to properly configure the permissions on the meeting. So once the meeting got started it turned out anyone had permission to share their screen and hijack the call with whatever they wanted to show.
- acomjean 4y agoI use zoom for a couple groups I'm park of. It's actually hard to set screen sharing on by default. To the point where if I use the link I sent out to join not as the meeting organizer, I have to leave and come back before anyone can share. My work zoom link gets around this restriction.. The fact that zoom full screens any share makes this worse. At this point most organizations should have someone adept enough to boot misbehavior. It's a little tricky.
- Gigachad 4y agoHold the meetings in person. Zoom has been a disaster for collaboration. If people try to bomb your in person meetings you can have the police arrest them for trespass.
- justinzollars 4y agoPosted 2 days ago. Zerohedge doesn't really trend here. https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/fed-governor-speech-canceled-after-zoom-conference-hijacker-plays-porn https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/fed-governor-speech-cancel...
- treebeard901 4y agoMaybe a distraction to avoid answering difficult economic questions? Was it rescheduled or just not happening? Didn't see the article mention it.
- ericpauley 4y agoLet's be real about the scope here, clearly this is not indicative of the downfall of modern banking infrastructure (or the government itself, as it seems some commentors would have you believe). This was a small event featuring one board member. As the article points out the zoom session itself was run by the hosting institution, some consortium of small banks (I hear those are really known for their technical chops /s). Run enough of these and something bad is bound to happen. Sure, maybe the Fed should improve its policies on meeting hosting rules and make sure people are informed on best practice, but the fact that a Fed-affiliate intern messed up their Zoom settings is hardly damning.
- state_less 4y agoYes, it seems like a small matter. Perhaps before the next meeting he should be asked, “Does the female form make you uncomfortable Mr Governor?” https://youtu.be/bDDGZxb6YhM https://youtu.be/bDDGZxb6YhM
- blue039 4y ago[dead]
- pharrington 4y agoProfessional AAA game programmers write bugs that permanently delete players' save data. Senior engineers at web hosting companies accidentally delete customer's entire servers. Employees at internet backbones accidentally screw up the configuration so bad that huge swaths of the internet go offline. This isn't a UX problem. This isn't a government problem. This is the human experience.
- Waterluvian 4y agoMaybe we can improve the human experience by improving the… user experience.
- karmakaze 4y agoExactly. It doesn't matter if UX was the problem, it can be part of the solution.
- pharrington 4y agoYou're very right. I may have misspoken a little - I just meant that there will always be high profile mistakes. Bu obviously that's no reason to avoid improving the tools.
- RockRobotRock 4y agoIn what roadmap did I block the deliverable of my own happiness? https://youtu.be/DYvhC_RdIwQ https://youtu.be/DYvhC_RdIwQ
- Kukumber 4y agoyou can lock meetings that has started this is not a UX issue, it is people who give no fuck about security of privacy otherwise your government would have voted anti data-spying laws, they haven't therefore they don't care, therefore they didn't think of locking their meeting after it started i can spell the agenda that's cooking https://blog.zoom.us/keep-uninvited-guests-out-of-your-zoom-meeting/ https://blog.zoom.us/keep-uninvited-guests-out-of-your-zoom-... https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/201362603-Host-and-Co-Host-Controls-in-a-Meeting https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/201362603-Host-and...
- neilv 4y agoMaybe this incident was an accident, untargeted random, or purely recreational trolling, but a couple questions... Was this one of those Federal Reserve events in which (if retail investor news is to be believed) the slightest facial twitch can move the stock market in microseconds? What kinds of public/semi-public meetings/events can be disrupted by Zoom bombing, with effects such that often someone will have huge financial incentive to do it?
- defrost 4y agohttps://archive.is/1NxvL https://archive.is/1NxvL
- wallace_g 4y ago[dead]
- m1117 4y agoThe only fed meeting in history that was not boring
- ideamotor 4y agoAnyone involved in deciding the federal reserve should be immediately fired.
- ideamotor 4y agoHaha I can’t even correctly type my online rants given how busy I am now. I meant to say … anyone deciding to use Zoom should be fired. Search for the security history of that app, particularly as it pertains to their macOS version …
- andrewstuart 4y agoDid interest rates go up?
- sf4lifer 4y agowhy did they use a meeting (every participant is visible) instead of a webinar (only presenter's video is visible)?
- vondur 4y agoJeesh. It's not that hard to setup a Zoom meeting to avoid this sort of thing. I recently had to setup 13 separate Zoom rooms all with 10 breakout rooms with these restrictions to avoid this soft of thing.
- JohnFen 4y agoBut keep in mind, you clearly have a lot of experience using zoom. Whoever set this up may not have done it very often. If you're new to it, none of this stuff is obvious.
- UberFly 4y agoSo... Someone at the Federal Reserve didn't set up their zoom meeting correctly and an opportunistic prankster entered stage right and made them all embarrassed. This is barely a story other than where it happened. They should be happy it wasn't worse. And maybe bring on a few more interns to help with the setup.
- hulitu 4y ago>A few minutes before the event was to start, one participant using the screen name "Dan" began displaying graphic, pornographic images, Dan the 1st, Dan the 2nd ? When every Dan can connect to your meeting, you have bigger problems.