3 ms·
I thought this was a bizarre (OK, I'll be honest, shitty) article. The beginning starts out by seemingly making the point that Japan has low unemployment becaus
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I thought this was a bizarre (OK, I'll be honest, shitty) article. The beginning starts out by seemingly making the point that Japan has low unemployment because it has a lot of inefficient, "make-work" jobs, e.g. "smartly dressed women help you use the lifts" (subtext being who needs help using an elevator) and "a team of four people was involved in the preparation of your correspondent’s gin martini".
OK, fair enough. But then it starts making the argument that employment in the West is going to look more like Japan. Except places where I'm aware where there are acute labor shortages (e.g. businesses like restaurants, child care, nursing, home services like plumber, electrician, etc.) look nothing like the picture the author tried to paint with his Japan vignettes. I.e. there aren't tons of spare waiters standing around waiting to make your drink where I live. More like you're happy just to get seated in the first place because places are so understaffed.
The current and coming labor shortages in the West are not a surprise - it's simple demographics, with nearly every 1st world country having a fertility rate that is well below replacement level. I think the pandemic did cause some folks to re-evaluate their priorities, but I think even there a lot of explanations are given for people "re-evaluating their priorities", but the reality is that labor shortages are causing some people to leave the workforce because the value of their "labor at home" is now relatively much more. For example, childcare in the US in many urban areas is extremely expensive. It's expensive to the point where if one member of a couple has a relatively low earning potential, it makes more sense for them to stay at home to raise their kids, rather than putting them in childcare, because the economics of it are no longer that favorable.
- 5448346438 4y agoTo be honest make-work type jobs are shitty examples anyway unless their existence is mandated through governance (looking at you Oregon gas stations). Otherwise, whether those jobs seem important or necessary or neither, their existence is a cultural one that's at least as significant as any job related to entertainment or hospitality.
- rsynnott 4y agoI'd wonder how true it is in Japan, either; all feels a bit anecdotal. My impression was that Japan had ~0 unemployment largely due to an increasingly small number of people of working age; per-employee productivity is actually pretty high in Japan. And yeah, certainly around here a lot of stuff is just reducing hours because they can't staff at previous levels.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoPointless comparing Japan to the west at all. The work ethic is completely different, may as well be another planet. Impossible to replicate in the west so pointless to compare economies.
- carlosjobim 4y agoThere's never been any kind of labor shortage in the West, just an unwillingness to pay sustainable salaries for work delivered. Young men and women working in Western countries are horribly squeezed by the massive amount of people demanding to live on their labour. Immense taxes, profits, pensions, rent, fines, mortgages all add up to an unsustainable situation, and people check out. You can't build a future in places like Western Europe without either gaming the system, having luck with inheritance and such, or making a wild shot at some unusual pursuit that could render profit if successful. That means a young person can not afford to spend time working in dead-end jobs such as sadly, almost all traditional jobs are now for people entering the work force. I deeply regret all the years working hard in a traditional job, because it brought me no closer to having a career, a family, a place to call my own, or respect. Why should I ever expect any young person to do the same, when things are much worse for them now.
- ianai 4y agoNot to mention all the customers and people who will tell you that you’re a piece of crap because you work such a job. (Part of why I go out of my way to be kind to people (and tip) is my experience working retail right out of college.)
- snowwrestler 4y agoI agree with most of this, but birth rates are not relevant. Note that Japan has had a very low fertility rate for years but still has folks for all those make-work jobs. In the U.S. what changed over the past 5 years is legal immigration: it was drastically cut and has not been restored. So as citizens and existing long-term residents pursue better jobs or time at home, there are far fewer new residents eager for lower paying jobs. If you talk to businesses that have traditionally employed these newly arrived folks—food service, agriculture, construction, childcare, etc—they will be crystal clear about the impact they are seeing. Places with desirable standards of living don’t need replacement level births. They just need the right levels of immigration. People will come, ready to work on day one.
- ralph84 4y agoThe decline in legal immigration is almost entirely due to USCIS’s drastically decreased productivity during covid. Illegal immigration is still at all-time highs in the US. Why only consider legal immigration? Those industries you mentioned are all big employers of illegal immigrants.
- gadders 4y agoImmigration is a method of wage suppression. The issue is that the businesses don't want to cut into their profits to raise wages to attract native/local workers.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoWhich is why most of your contractors, or kitchen staffs, in the US are Hispanic.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y agoThe government can of course "attract native/local workers" and curb this immigration via means such as raising the minimum wage. When the state doesn't want to, it means that the state and business are working together on this against such native workers. It's of course never as simple as "Immigration is this". You might as well say that "low minimum wage" is the sole root cause.