3 ms·
Avoiding doing assignments by having chatGPT do them is obviously a bad idea. Cheating has always been possible, it always will be, we try to prevent it, but ch
by bee_rider 4y ago
Avoiding doing assignments by having chatGPT do them is obviously a bad idea. Cheating has always been possible, it always will be, we try to prevent it, but cheaters are really creative and mostly hurting themselves. Any effort spent on preventing students from ripping themselves off is effort not spent on helping the students who are engaging with the system in good faith and trying to learn.
It seems more troubling if people can cheat their way all the way through college. There are a number of skills that really benefit from kind of boring/non-creative work. In intro classes, part of it is just spending enough time learn “reflexes” that will help later. I’m sure it is easy to find tools that will do this work for you.
But at some point, I mean, junior and senior (Err, I guess this is US lingo maybe, last couple years of college) should be doing actually interesting work, to the point where if they can “cheat” their way through the material with new tools, then… they’ve found an interesting new way to solve real problems. And if they aren’t doing anything interesting at all, then there are much, much deeper problems at the school.
- Balgair 4y agoI don't know how many HNers were in greek life, but every single house has a huge test and homework bank. It's one of the big draws for pledging.
- WalterBright 4y ago> learn “reflexes” that will help later True enough. I inadvertently learned trig so thoroughly that I could "see" many steps ahead as one. I say inadvertently because since every class was a math class, full of incidental trig work, this winds up happening to everyone.
- bitL 4y agoThis only works until people notice that many at the top (company/society) were the cheaters.
- runsWphotons 4y agohonestly doing my assignments seems to have gotten many of my less honest peers better careers. (my smarter peers mostly did better too though)
- bee_rider 4y agoHow do they get to the top? If they’ve cheated their way through school, they shouldn’t have the skills required to do good work.
- zamnos 4y agoWhy "should"? Isn't the important thing whether or not the student has the skills, not how much homework they did? Because not all students pick up things at the same speed, and some are naturally gifted and don't need to through the same amount of homework to get to the same skill level.
- jamilton 4y agoYou're presuming a 1. a meritocracy, that only the most skilled people move up 2. that the skills needed for school are the same skills that allow you to move up. I don't think these are necessarily safe assumptions.