3 ms·
That’s often the first impression but in my career I’ve never seen a rewrite work substantially better or save any money. Sometimes they are necessary for other
by SoftTalker 4y ago
That’s often the first impression but in my career I’ve never seen a rewrite work substantially better or save any money. Sometimes they are necessary for other reasons but those two are the arguments usually made and they don’t really hold up.
- switchbak 4y agoI've got experiences in both camps. Well managed rewrites (typically portions of a system) can fix a lot of problems in one fell swoop, but you have to really know what you're doing and actually have concrete plans for improvements. If not, all you've done is just replaced a bad system with another bad system. I've also seen that lately. You're right that often it's just "different" and not better, and that makes it hard to sell the case when a rewrite is truly needed.
- jamesfinlayson 4y agoAgreed - I've worked with one rewrite from scratch and it convinced me that rewriting from scratch is never a good idea. Incidentally, I can see why the company decided on a rewrite from scratch (no separation of MVC logic, no framework, almost no tests, only ran on special environments, production had an extra set of patches that for some reason would never get merged back to master) - honestly, it really was too far gone.