3 ms·
> The fundamental problem is that NSA, CIA, FBI.. can force American companies to hand over data (even if the data is saved in EU) How does this work when it g
by tzs 4y ago
> The fundamental problem is that NSA, CIA, FBI.. can force American companies to hand over data (even if the data is saved in EU)
How does this work when it goes the other way? Suppose a French company in Paris had some data and they stored that data in AWS in the us-east-1 region. A French police or intelligence agency gets a court order (or whatever is the French equivalent) asking the company to turn over a copy of that data.
Can the company refuse (without getting in legal trouble) on the grounds that the data is not stored in France?
- bboygravity 4y agoThis would work the other way around in practice (source: Snowden): the NSA would voluntarily give the data that the French want off of AWS in exchange for whatever data the NSA wants from within the French territory. The company wouldn't have to refuse anything, because they wouldn't even be aware that this is happening at all. All the company knows is that they host data on US servers. I mean this is what Snowden described many years ago, it's probably way worse, more legalized and even more automated now.
- punnerud 4y agoEU don’t have the same kind of laws that don’t obey other countries laws as I am familiar with. So a solution would also be to move headquarters for Microsoft, Apple, Meta… to EU So no, they would not get into trouble (if based in EU)
- tzs 4y ago> EU don’t have the same kind of laws that don’t obey other countries laws as I am familiar with No other country's laws would be involved in the scenario I asked about. It does not violate any US law for a company that has stored data in US AWS to retrieve that data. The French authorities would be asking the French company to give them a copy of data that the French company controls and has legal access to. All the French company has to do to comply is make an API request to AWS, something they presumably routinely do. If merely storing documents outside of your own country, but still within your control (in the sense that you can retrieve them any time you need them by asking whoever/whatever is holding them for you in the other country), is sufficient to make it so your own country can no longer legally compel you to turn over copies of those documents I don't see how that would not lead to massive problems for that country. Wouldn't every company making consumer products, for example, store all documents produced during design and testing outside the country so in case safety issues arise later investigators can't get those documents to help build a negligence case against the company?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]