2 ms·
This is easy to say from the perspective of someone making tech money, but plenty of people (immigrants, minorities, people below the poverty line, people witho
by paxys 4y ago
This is easy to say from the perspective of someone making tech money, but plenty of people (immigrants, minorities, people below the poverty line, people without a high school diploma) depend on such jobs and will gladly do them. Unless you also have a solution for employment for all such groups, "let's get rid of these jobs" comes off as way too simplistic. The benefits of automation are largely enjoyed by the upper classes, not the people who are displaced.
- hezralig 4y agoYou have realize the purpose of SV automation then. Not to advance human productivity but to rid itself of a class of people en bulk.
- mabbo 4y agoAs is always said when this argument comes up: fine, let's automate the job and then just give those people the money they would have otherwise made. The people in need get the money, but no one has to do the awful job. Win-win. Or we could just pay them to dig holes and fill them back in again, if you demand that they must perform labor to "earn" their way. These are needless jobs. They should be destroyed.
- paxys 4y agoWho exactly is going to "just give" them this money? Big corporations? Why would they do that exactly? Under some law? What would the law say? That each company has to give some random people money? Or is it the government handing out the cash? Who all will they pay? Where will this money come from? What are the chances any of this actually gets voted for and enacted? How will it be enforced? It's easy to create these fantasies in one's head, but think about it realistically for 5 seconds and it all breaks down.