3 ms·
Sure. You could do even better: keep your computer on at all times and keep everything you do in RAM. No encryption is necessary here, just a $100 UPS and your
by IgorPartola 15y ago
Sure. You could do even better: keep your computer on at all times and keep everything you do in RAM. No encryption is necessary here, just a $100 UPS and your laptop's own battery.
The problem with all these comments about "what if I give half of my phrase to a friend?" or "what if I write it in the dust at the entrance to my house and the FBI wipes it away when they bust in?" is that it doesn't really address the core issue. There is no technological solution to this situation:
1. The gov't can just give up on the idea of looking at encrypted drives. Not likely and possibly bad for society as a whole. I am not able to judge that.
2. The judge can just refuse to understand that there is no way to decrypt the drive and hold you in contempt of the court indefinitely at which point you'll be cursing yourself for not burying the passphrase chiseled into a stone in your back yard.
3. The gov't makes it illegal to encrypt drives without giving them the keys. At best this is done through some kind of third-party escrow service so that an actual warrant needs to be given before the key is given out. At worst, you just drop off your encryption keys with the nearest post office.
4. There is no #4. The judicial system won't just go "well, this guy has an encrypted drive and we can't get in. Let's just let him go since he clearly outsmarted us." They either will find something else on you, or compel you to decrypt the drive.
Like I said, there is no technical solution, only social/behavioral. Encryption became too sophisticated and there isn't much that we can do nowadays.
- trotsky 15y agoFor what it's worth, it's very common for forensics teams to get memory dumps before the computers are turned off or moved.
- X-Istence 15y agoWhy dump memory when you can do this instead: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erq4TO_a3z8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erq4TO_a3z8
- trotsky 15y agoFor chain of custody etc. you always need to make a master copy and sign/hash it and then work off of a copy. If you tried to do forensics on the actual computer as seized you'd be busy destroying disk & memory evidence as you worked.
- X-Istence 15y agoThat is fine for working on it (and having taken computer forensics classes at college something I am intimately familiar with), however it no longer needs to be done on location. The device can safely be removed without requiring a tech to go out to the location.
- IgorPartola 15y agoNo problem. With enough money you could set up a dead man switch to erase your laptop if you step more than 3 feet away from it which is bound to happen if the FBI drags you away. Or set up a voice recognition system that would listen for the words "Open up! Police!". My point is that with all these amateur lawyer "I can outsmart them on a technicality" schemes I think it needs to be said that you probably don't want to do any of that. Instead, if you do have something that you feel you don't want to expose, use whole disk encryption with hidden volumes, duress codes, etc. but keep your options open. The worst possible scenario to be in is where the only way to prove that you are innocent (or to enter into a plea bargain) is to decrypt your drive but some crazy scheme of yours now prevents you from ever recovering your passphrase. EDIT: Can someone please explain the downvotes?
- baddox 15y agoYou can also just, you know, refuse to decrypt the drive. If they're going to torture you, you're pretty much screwed anyway so you probably don't care about the data (unless perhaps it contains crucial private information about friends and family, or business dealings).
- X-Istence 15y agoThey make devices that can safely transfer power from the wall socket to a UPS so that they can take the device with them. Take a look at this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erq4TO_a3z8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erq4TO_a3z8
- wisty 15y agoThe solution - an online storage system that only you know about. As long as they don't get a RAM dump, you're fine. The problem with an encrypted drive is that they know it's there.
- pygy_ 15y agoThis is probably good enough for most cases, where ham-fisted cops will pull the plug to seize the computer. But RAM isn't instantly wiped when turned off. The capacitors take some time to discharge, and it is possible to quickly snatch a RAM stick and put it in a device that will preserve its content and allow to read it later on. If the strategy you propose becomes more prevalent, law officiers will adapt.
- jrockway 15y agoIf the strategy you propose becomes more prevalent, law officiers will adapt. As will the encryption software. Good luck dumping my L1 cache.