4 ms·
> A few weeks ago I was pretty sure that Beijing would not be that stupid... The US is executing the same broad strategy against both China and Russia - surrou
by roenxi 4y ago
> A few weeks ago I was pretty sure that Beijing would not be that stupid...
The US is executing the same broad strategy against both China and Russia - surrounding them with US-friendly states who then get military support. It seems to be working extremely well against Russia since they can barely get Russian troops into the Donbass safely.
While I, personally, agree that it would be stupid I can certainly see that situation from the perspective of a hypothetical Chinese military planner. A destabilised Russia would potentially have a colour revolution leading to a US encirclement on 3 compass points. China would therefore have no choice but to support the war effort against Ukraine.
- wkat4242 4y ago> The US is executing the same broad strategy against both China and Russia - surrounding them with US-friendly states who then get military support. It seems to be working extremely well against Russia since they can barely get Russian troops into the Donbass safely. What US-Friendly states are between Russia and the Donbass then?
- wsc981 4y agoI think he meant that Russia is pretty much surrounded by NATO allies, excluding of course China and this is something Russia is not to happy about (stated this many times in the past as NATO was expanding).
- gebruikersnaam 4y ago> I think he meant that Russia is pretty much surrounded by NATO allies, excluding of course China And Kazakhstan. And Mongolia. And North Korea. And Belarus.
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago> > NATO allies, excluding > And Mongolia https://www.state.gov/u-s-relations-with-mongolia/ https://www.state.gov/u-s-relations-with-mongolia/ > Bordered by Russia and China, Mongolia describes the United States as its most important “third neighbor.” In 2019, the United States and Mongolia upgraded their bilateral relationship to a Strategic Partnership. > Mongolia deployed troops to Iraq from 2003 through October 2008. In Afghanistan, Mongolian soldiers supported Coalition operations for 18 years, with withdrawal underway in 2021 in coordination with the planned exit of U.S. forces. Training and equipment provided by the U.S. government support the professionalization of Mongolia’s defense forces and their continued engagement in United Nations peacekeeping operations. The United States military also regularly participates in Mongolia-hosted peacekeeping and humanitarian relief exercises, including the annual Khaan Quest exercise. Seems like an "ally" to me. > Kazakhstan And while not as close, still maybe an "ally"? https://www.state.gov/u-s-relations-with-Kazakhstan/ https://www.state.gov/u-s-relations-with-Kazakhstan/ > In the years since Kazakhstan’s independence, the two countries have developed a strong and wide-ranging bilateral relationship, jointly referred to as an enhanced strategic partnership since 2018. > Kazakhstan’s military participates in U.S.-funded military exercises like Steppe Eagle, Viking, Eager Lion, and Shanti Prayas. --- > North Korea The Russian border with North Korea is about 20 miles long.
- gebruikersnaam 4y agoIran have helped the US in Afghanistan, do you consider them a NATO ally? Just like surrounding, the meaning of ally needs changing to accommodate one's world view.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoCitation? And please, a post-Shah citation. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/26/world/middleeast/iran-taliban-afghanistan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/26/world/middleeast/iran-tal... > For 20 years, Iranian officials have said they wanted the U.S. military out of Afghanistan. Iran supplied Afghan insurgents with weapons to use against American soldiers. It sheltered Al Qaeda’s top leaders in Tehran. It courted the Taliban with diplomatic visits, covertly and then publicly. The best I can find is an "enemy of my enemy" relationship, which has never been considered an alliance. https://www.usip.org/publications/2018/06/iran-and-afghanistans-long-complicated-history https://www.usip.org/publications/2018/06/iran-and-afghanist... >For decades, Tehran has supported the Hazara, a Shia minority and the third largest ethnic group in Afghanistan. In the 1990s, the Taliban government repressed the Hazara—excluding them politically, isolating them economically, and killing more than 1,000—during the civil war that erupted after the 1989 Soviet withdrawal. Tensions heightened in 1998, when the Taliban killed nine Iranian diplomats working at a consulate in northern Mazar-i-Sharif. After the 9/11 attacks and the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan, Iran worked closely with the United States and regional powers to establish a new Afghan government free of the Taliban. > Iran’s relationship with the Taliban shifted, however, as U.S. and NATO forces stayed in Afghanistan. Tehran viewed the Taliban as a useful tool to counter U.S. influence on its borders. It provided Taliban forces with enough military equipment to pressure the United States but not enough to generate American military retaliation. In 2016, the Taliban chief, Mullah Akhtar Mansour, was killed in a U.S. drone strike as he returned from a secret visit in Iran to his sanctuary in Pakistan. By 2017, Russia reportedly used Iran to funnel weapons to the Taliban.
- andy_ppp 4y agoIf they were really scared of more NATO invading Ukraine is the fastest way to get a larger border with NATO (win or lose).
- andrewflnr 4y agoI think they were planning to set up a puppet government as a buffer. Throw out the "nazis", "restore" the "rightful" something something... even just making the Donbass republics a real thing would have helped. Reality intervened, obviously. I bet they weren't betting on Finland bidding to join NATO, either.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoUkraine joining NATO has been a hotbutton topic for the last 10 years. It was decided 6 months before the invasion that it would Ukraine would join, and I don't the two facts are entirely unrelated.
- ginko 4y agoYou can't join NATO if you have an ongoing territorial dispute. Ukraine would have been unable to join while Crimea and parts of Donbass/Luhansk were occupied.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI agree this has been a prerequisite for full NATO ascension so far. However, The process starts with a promise of NATO membership which was given. Since 2014 NATO has has operated several trust funds and aid packages to modernize the Ukrainian military. There has also been a NATO/US presence in Ukraine, training, and joint exercises. Prior to the war, Ukraine sought entry despite ongoing conflicts, claiming "NATO is the only way to end the war in Donbas". Since the start of the war, Former US Ambassador to NATO and others have called for Ukraine to be offered membership, despite territorial conflicts.
- thr717272 4y ago"Russia only feel their borders are safe when there are Russian soldiers on both sides of them" is a saying I read recently.
- BobbyJo 4y agoIsn't Donbass on the border with Russia?
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoNot between, but making it more difficult for Russia to safely send troops into the Donbas region. Depending on the routes Russia takes to get materials and troops into the Donbas, and to protect other routes into the Donbas, we have: Turkey - blocking entry of north seas warships into the Black Sea / Sea of Azov. Ukraine itself, which can send missiles onto the Russian roads currently funneling troops into the Donbas region.
- thr717272 4y ago> Not between, but making it more difficult for Russia to safely send troops into the Donbas region. Based on the way you write it seems you think this is problematic. Do you?
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoI don't understand your question? I was addressing a strawman. That is all.
- thr717272 4y agoI'm just pointing out that the way you phrase it makes it sound like: "[robbers has a legitimate concern that] with all these cops and all this cameras and security doors they can hardly pull off a heist any longer"
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoYou probably won't read this after 4 days, but the way I was phrasing it was solely meant to show that the rhetorical question asking what states are between Russia and Donbas (none) is irrelevant to the point the original commenter was making.
- andy_ppp 4y agoWere the countries around China coerced to be friendly with America somehow? I’m pretty sure the CIA do a lot of evil shit to maintain American power around the world but I’m really not sure they are this omnipotent. I think these countries are simply more scared of China than they are the US, until that changes China will be surrounded by US friendly countries.
- treaxc 4y agoThe point that roenxi made is that color revolutions in Russia and Kazakhstan would encircle China from the West and North in addition to the existing U.S. allies Japan and South Korea from the Southwest. It isn't a moral statement, just one realistic scenario that China is afraid of.
- rhaway84773 4y agoYou’ve pretty much eliminated all agency that exists in those countries and their people. This is the only way to support Russia and China today. By using a “Great Power” theory which pretends smaller countries have no agency and their people have no value, other than how they affect the interactions of those larger countries. The U.S. is also surrounded by a bunch of countries. Somehow those countries aren’t clamoring to join the Warsaw Pact or kowtow to China.
- 8note 4y agoThere's no power close to the US that could counterbalance it. If there was an equivalent south American power, you might see Mexico and central American countries looking to escape American influence, but no such power exists
- Gibbon1 4y agoThe history of Eurasian Powers in the New World is highly negative and the US keeps those guys away.
- 8note 4y ago
- gebruikersnaam 4y agoWhich countries surrounding China are US-friendly?
- ericmay 4y agoJapan, South Korea, and Taiwan are 3 that make up a Pacific encirclement (probably the Philippines and perhaps Australia if you want to go that far). Typically that’s what people refer to when they say “surrounded” but obviously China isn’t completely surrounded. The reason these three are used in this context is because Chinese power projection assumes an outward eastern presence in the Pacific and not westward or northward. Though ultimately this is of China’s own doing. They broke the “don’t interrupt your enemy while they are making a mistake” rule with respect to the US and very rapidly turned the tide against themselves and now find that they are the ones making the mistake and seemingly unaware. The mistake being supporting Putin, taking over Hong Kong prematurely, and pissing off the Philippines and Japan for no good reason. This has caused Pacific national to rally around America and has caused an American-skeptic Europe to unite strongly under NATO and turn China-skeptic. The whole “wolf-warrior” diplomacy thing was a massive fuck up.
- gebruikersnaam 4y agoSurrounding seems to have gotten a new meaning: just being somewhere in the vicinity.
- philliphaydon 4y ago> and pissing off the Philippines and Japan for no good reason And Vietnam, and India, and every country that borders the South China Sea. It’s like a kid who goes school and buys everyone gifts to make friends but still treats everyone like crap.
- ericmay 4y agoYea you are correct. I’m not sure what was going through my head with leaving them out. May have been thinking about the “strong American Allies” aspect.
- pastacacioepepe 4y ago> The US is executing the same broad strategy against both China and Russia - surrounding them with US-friendly states who then get military support. It seems to be working extremely well against Russia since they can barely get Russian troops into the Donbass safely. Following this then it would make sense for both China and Russia to feel threatened and react accordingly. I would expect the US to react even harder if any of their "enemies" would setup a missile base in Mexico or Canada.
- pestatije 4y agoNot harder, but there was a reaction for sure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago> I would expect the US to react even harder if any of their "enemies" would setup a missile base in Mexico or Canada. The U.S. and Russia both made security guarantees to remove nuclear missiles from Ukraine following the breakup of the USSR. The closest-to-Russia NATO member with forward-deployed US nuclear weapons is Turkey, and it's been a NATO member since 1952. https://www.newsweek.com/nato-us-nuclear-weapons-europe-sites-1449697 https://www.newsweek.com/nato-us-nuclear-weapons-europe-site... The cold war never got hot with US nuclear missile subs in Russian waters, and vice versa with Russian nuclear missile subs in US water.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoNATO missile defences are present in the eastern block (Poland, Czech Republic, etc) and AFAIK those can be repurposed to launch offensive missiles as well. If having offensive missiles in a country takes 2 steps, where the first is gaining military access to said country and the second is to install offensive missiles, certainly the first step is the harder to accomplish. Additionally, when it comes to geopolitical power things are much more complex than you make them to be. I suggest reading this publication[0] to understand better what's going on. A few points: > Moscow claims that missile defenses represent an American perception of threats from Russian nuclear missiles. Therefore these defenses aim to neutralize them in potential conflict. Either Russian missiles would be attacked by a conventional air and space first strike, possibly involving these networks in Europe, or else these missile defenses would frustrate a retaliatory second strike leaving Russia defenseless. > While these missile defenses in and of themselves are no threat, they represent the first stage of a planned or potential U.S. buildup of a missile network in Europe that could then neutralize Russia's first and/or second strike capabilities as cited above and shift the burden of war to Europe. > If missile defenses were stationed at these bases, it would create a pretext for stationing offensive missiles there. This would force Moscow to assume the worst case scenario and could cause Russia to attempt to shoot them down leading to a conflict with America. > These defenses and whatever may follow them rupture the fabric of strategic stability where neither side has the freedom of action or margin of superiority that might encourage it to think it could employ coercive diplomacy or military force with impunity. That strategic stability equation is of critical importance to Russia because otherwise Washington might be tempted to think it could strike at Russia with relative impunity. > Finally, there is a fifth, and always unstated but critical aspect here. These defenses entrench the United States in Europe's military defense and foreclose any prospect of Moscow's being able to intimidate or reestablish its hegemony over Eastern and Central Europe, and even possibly the CIS. If missile defenses exist in Europe, Russian missile threats are greatly diminished if not negated. Because empire and the creation of a fearsome domestic enemy are the justifications for and inextricable corollary of internal autocracy, the end of empire allegedly entails Russia's irrevocable decline as a great power and, (the crucial point) generates tremendous pressure for domestic reform. .0: https://www.wilsoncenter.org/publication/352-missile-defenses-eastern-europe-who-threatens-whom https://www.wilsoncenter.org/publication/352-missile-defense...
- xoa 4y ago>surrounding them with US-friendly states who then get military support As is the standard playbook of dictator/authoritarian apologism, you completely reverse causality here and deny non-authoritarian countries self-determination. The US isn't "executing a strategy" or "surrounding [Russia/China]", it's that Russia and China are engaging in terrifying behavior, attacking and undermining their surrounding countries, promoting a pure might-makes-right and historical grievance narrative, making vast claims over neighboring countries sovereignty with their "spheres of influence" and China's ludicrous ocean claims, and on and on. And as a direct result their neighbors are banging on the door to get into Western security agreements they see as being able to defend them! NATO was falling apart. European military capability has massively decayed. Much of Europe was completely content to make occasional noises but otherwise pursue economic integration above all else. What has changed everything has been Russia and China's actions. Taking that and reversing it into a "woe is me why is everyone so mean" story is gross. >While I, personally, agree that it would be stupid I can certainly see that situation from the perspective of a hypothetical Chinese military planner. A destabilised Russia would potentially have a colour revolution leading to a US encirclement on 3 compass points. China would therefore have no choice but to support the war effort against Ukraine. Here's an alternative thought: Russia just fucking LEAVES UKRAINE. Stops committing mass murder, rape, genocide, child abduction, theft, purposeful destruction of civilian infrastructure, and war crimes in general. That China NOT invade an independent democratic country like Taiwan. That they stick to international treaties and norms and focus on making themselves rich and happy. That ever occur to you? Apparently not. Hopefully "Chinese military planners" aren't quite so evil and blind but of course in dictatorships that tends to not be the case.
- DiogenesKynikos 4y ago> it's that Russia and China are engaging in terrifying behavior, attacking and undermining their surrounding countries, promoting a pure might-makes-right and historical grievance narrative, making vast claims over neighboring countries sovereignty with their "spheres of influence" and China's ludicrous ocean claims, and on and on You're giving an extremely dramatized version of what China has actually been doing. > attacking and undermining their surrounding countries China hasn't fought a foreign war in over 40 years. That's actually pretty incredible, when you think of the fact that most major powers have fought many wars in that same timespan. > promoting a pure might-makes-right and historical grievance narrative I have never seen China promote a "might-makes-right" narrative. China consistently states that the United Nations framework is the basis for international relations. That's why, for example, China has never recognized Russia's occupation of Crimea - it's contrary to the UN Charter. > making vast claims over neighboring countries sovereignty China's territorial claims haven't expanded in many decades - since its founding. In fact, the PRC has reduced its claims over time. It inherited a bunch of border disputes from the previous government (the ROC), some of which is has resolved through negotiation (for example, with Mongolia, Vietnam and the USSR/Russia). If you look at the South China Sea dispute, for example, you might be surprised to learn that Taiwan (a.k.a., the ROC) has nearly identical territorial claims as the PRC. I say "nearly" identical, because the PRC has settled some aspects of the dispute with Vietnam through negotiation. Taiwan actually occupies the largest, most valuable island in the South China Sea.[0] The reason why China has been pouring cement on reefs is because it is a latecomer to the scramble for the South China Sea islands, and all the largest islands and reefs are already occupied by other countries, as you can see from this list: [1]. All of the countries bordering the South China Sea have extensive, overlapping claims. The US strategy is fairly successful because it comes in and offers to help various countries enforce their claims versus China. The downside for these countries is that they risk worsening their relationship with China, which is the most important economic partner for every country in the region, and that they might get dragged into a military conflict between the US and China. That's why countries in the region have gone back and forth between cozying up to the US and China. 0. Taiping Island: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Island https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Island 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_maritime_features_in_the_Spratly_Islands#Features_by_area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_maritime_features_in_t...
- chaostheory 4y agoI think you’re ignoring the fact that China has been very aggressive with its border claims in the Pacific. Under Xi, they’ve literally invaded small islands controlled by south East Asian countries. It’s more than enough to push countries like Vietnam to the US.
- rhaway84773 4y agoThe obvious question should be is why states around Russia and China choose to be U.S. friendly, whereas states around the US also choose to be US friendly. For example, why does Canada KK pose restrictions on China despite them investing a ton of money in Canada, and the Philippines, barring a short neutrality under the ridiculous Dutarte also chooses to impose restrictions on China, and be closer to the U.S., despite China also investing a ton of money in them and being closer to them.
- dirtyid 4y agoWell first, match context, there's neighbouring countries and regional countries. Countries neighbouring PRC, i.e. land connected are just as friendly towards PRC, and by friendly I mean relatively geopolitically aligned because PRC settled borders with 12/14 of them (India/Bhutan hold out) and they know they're too close to PRC to step out of line. This is similar to US, except US who only has 2 land neighbours, CA/MX, both of whom she knocked the shit out historically into compliance. The you have regional countries, expecially once limited to maritime access, they hedge, just like South America is now hedging PRC against previously almost uncontested US influence. The broader answer is because PRC hasn't (had chance to) done what the US did, kick the shit out of their neighbours or exploit shit kicked countries near their adversaries and coerced geopolitical compliance that over generations becomes ingrained on a cultural level. PH/JP/SKR/TW are structurally coupled to US post WW2, and all had very strong anti-US sentiment across society and politics earlier on in their existence, but lacked power to kick US out and generations of US influence and increased dependence in more than just economics now makes them bias compliance towards US interests. Canada good example, used by British to wage existential war on US, and US seriously considered annexing Canada until British was comprehensively defeated and Canada stopped becoming geopolitical threat. Even then Canadian domestic politics was antiUS project until well into the 70s, meanwhile anytime Canadian leadership tried to depart from US strategic interests, it gets reigned in. Ditto with Mexico, and rest of Americas via Monroe Doctrine. The TLDR is US empire wasn't built on friendship, it was built on opportunistically ruining / exploiting ruined countries and turning them into vassels structurally to be friendly, until over generations, people start drinking the koolaid and the cause becomes reversed. Alternatively, like in South America, beatings will continue until geopolitical compliance improves. Money and influence ops is rarely enough to dislodge such alignment. Which raises the unpleasant implication that countries around PRC won't be friendly until PRC successfully asserts regional hegemony and it can't convincingly do that without basically kicking US out of east Asia forcefully. Sometimes the only way to win over geopolitical "friendships" is by kicking the old friend out and demonstrating implications of trying to remain unfriendly.
- papito 4y agoIt's very baffling why, after Russia conducted multiple invasions of bordering countries, the states elsewhere became "US-friendly". Russia is the victim. Yes? Thirteen time zones of territory, and their prime time TV is filled with sadistic dreams of marching into Europe, and we know what happens when the Russian army comes. It's just.... a mystery.