4 ms·
without ignoring manufacturer thermal limits The whole point is to ignore them because they're horrible and hold back what these CPUs can really do. Fuck the m
by userbinator 4y ago
without ignoring manufacturer thermal limits
The whole point is to ignore them because they're horrible and hold back what these CPUs can really do. Fuck the manufacturers playing these stupid marketing games.
Intel warrants their CPUs at TjMax 24/7, they'll automatically throttle when they hit that limit, and disabling all this other throttling crap makes them run that way for full performance.
- rincebrain 4y agoFWIW, I've managed to make multiple X1C6s thermally trip and shut off without changing from the safe configuration, which rather impressed me because I didn't know that was feasible these days. Mostly I mention it to say that there's not _no_ reason for thermal limits in modern setups...
- userbinator 4y agoI believe that's called a defective product --- and reminds me of a certain somewhat infamous series of Toshiba laptops which would overheat and shutdown if you spent too long in BIOS setup, because the fans were entirely software controlled. There's zero reason for all this extra "thermal management" crap beyond corporate greed.
- mjg59 4y agoYou can design hardware that's capable of dissipating the maximum heat output of every component simultaneously, but you'll end up with hardware that's significantly larger, heavier, and costs more to manufacture. Or you can design hardware that's capable of dissipating the expected heat output under a range of use-cases, and devolve policy management to the OS so it can (based on user preference) prioritise appropriately, allowing you to produce smaller, lighter machines that either cost less or generate more profit. Even if the motivation for cutting costs is to increase profit margins, users generally still seem to prefer the smaller, lighter hardware that works just fine under most circumstances.
- salawat 4y agoNo... That's what you, the manufacturer looking for a rationale to justify extracting more profit want. What people want is a box that does computing within spec and without melting, sterilizing their laps/hands, or otherwise introducing malbehaviors they have to work around. People want stuff that doesn't or is very difficult to break. When it does break, they want it to be a straightforward repair.
- ecpottinger 4y agoThat is them, not me.
- ecpottinger 4y agoI had an HP laptop that did that in Windows or Haiku. I rewired the fan to run 100% all of the time and aside from losing some battery time the laptop ran fine. And when plugged into the external power supply I would run it all weekend (4-days) non-stop with no problems.
- mjg59 4y agoThe EC may trigger an emergency shutdown if any monitored component (not just the CPU) ends up outside its thermal limits.
- rincebrain 4y agoIndeed; I've replaced the laptop since then, so I don't think I have the log, but I believe it very explicitly logged it was the CPU temperature provoking it before actually shutting down.
- voltagex_ 4y agoIs this normally logged anywhere? You may have just saved me RMAing a laptop.
- TobTobXX 4y agoI had a computer with a broken GPU fan and it thermally shut off. There where kernel log entries about temperature warnings, though I don't remember if it mentioned which component. Systemd should preserve them before the system shuts off.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mjg59 4y agoThe whole point is that the CPU is only a single part of the equation. Yes, you're not going to burn out the CPU itself by unlimiting PL1/2 (although if the system vendor cheaped out on power circuitry because they'd only designed for sustained 20W draw then you might burn that out), but you're now generating more heat than the system is designed to dissipate. This may result in obvious outcomes like the chassis heating up enough to burn your legs, but it may also result in other components being operated outside their thermal limits and their lifetime being shortened as a result.
- userbinator 4y agoThe experience of many users shows otherwise --- ThrottleStop has similar scary disclaimers, but I have yet to see any evidence of hardware damage caused by opening up the power limits and letting the CPU naturally attain its full performance. but you're now generating more heat than the system is designed to dissipate I believe that's more accurately rephrased as "now you have more performance than they wanted you to have", because that's how it's being used in practice. FYI, it is painfully obvious that you're toeing some sort of company line here. Edit: and getting flagged for pointing out the truth should itself be quite telling. ;-)
- mjg59 4y ago> "now you have more performance than they wanted you to have" "An unthrottled CPU without any OS-level policy will generate enough heat that the case temperature may rise to levels that violate safety regulations" can certainly be interpreted as "now you have more performance than they wanted you to have", yes. > FYI, it is painfully obvious that you're toeing some sort of company line here. I work for a company that develops trucks. While thermal dissipation is something that we do need to worry about, I can promise that it is absolutely not at the scale involved here. I've also been pretty consistent in criticising Intel for refusing to document DPTF. Whose company line do you think I'm toeing here?
- userbinator 4y ago"An unthrottled CPU without any OS-level policy will generate enough heat that the case temperature may rise to levels that violate safety regulations" can certainly be interpreted as "now you have more performance than they wanted you to have", yes. Despite literally zero evidence of that actually being a problem in practice? I've also been pretty consistent in criticising Intel for refusing to document DPTF. Whose company line do you think I'm toeing here? Not Intel, but there's plenty of evidence that DPTF just cripples performance; and why else would you jump in to an article about unlocking manufacturer-crippled products with FUD like "not the correct approach"? It's like posting "may cause processor damage" and advocating for stock speeds on every article about overclocking. For the record, I've been overclocking (not at extreme or competitive levels) since the early 90s and haven't killed any hardware because of it. The system I'm posting this from has been on a 50% overclock for over a decade and it's still rock-solid stable.
- arka2147483647 4y agoIf you remove the thermal limit, and if this breaks your cpu, for example, within one year, should intel then replace your cpu? Thermal limits like this are really about managing the manufacturers liabilities, and protecting the expected lifetine of the product.
- userbinator 4y agoThe ultimate limit that prevents processor damage, called THERMTRIP, is not possible to disable AFAIK --- it's a purely hardware feature. The one below that, PROCHOT, can be disabled, but it's not useful to do that because it'll just hit the THERMTRIP temperature and shut down instead. Like I said, Intel warrants their CPUs to be operational at TjMax continuously, and that's the temperature they'll reach and stay at automatically if not given enough cooling. There's plenty of stories of people with computers whose heatsink has somehow detached or become so severely clogged as to be at that limit all the time, and the CPUs survive just fine. This article isn't about that; it's about manufacturers artifically limiting performance beyond that to hit a marketing target like battery life or power consumption.
- mjg59 4y agoWhat? No, it isn't. It's about something that only affects Ultrabook-style devices, and it's extremely clear that it's not to hit a marketing target because if you run Windows the drivers disable the PL1/2 limitations.
- userbinator 4y agoThe existence of ThrottleStop and the experience of many others shows that this is also a persistent problem on Windows --- CPU is barely getting warm, and sometimes the fan doesn't even turn on, but then gets throttled to some insanely low speed. Search "800MHz throttling" for plenty of complaints. Disabling all the DPTF and other extra power management bloat puts the CPU speed and performance back where it should be.
- 4y ago