3 ms·
Lifelong tinnitus sufferer here. The prevailing theory (edit: this is misleading, it is not the “prevailing theory”, I typed that without thinking. It is actual
by fwlr 4y ago
Lifelong tinnitus sufferer here. The prevailing theory (edit: this is misleading, it is not the “prevailing theory”, I typed that without thinking. It is actually a new-ish/fringe-ish alternative to the actual prevailing theory of accumulated damage to ear fibers):
The theory I subscribe to is that tinnitus is a breakdown of the ears’ and/or brain’s noise filtering and suppression mechanisms. Long-term use of white noise makes tinnitus worse, which is a particularly cruel irony since white noise also provides short term relief from tinnitus. Active noise cancelling likely shares enough properties with white noise to cause the same effect.
Some users of noise cancellation are reporting another experience, that a sudden loud noise is perceived as extraordinarily and painfully loud, to the point that even a single incident can have long-lasting effects. This is called hyperacusis, and it is highly co-prevalent with tinnitus. Essentially, every loud noise you’ve ever heard has been pre-dampened by your ears/brain’s natural noise suppression mechanisms, and in hyperacusis sometimes this dampening isn’t applied and you get the full force of the noise - meaning that noise is literally the loudest thing you’ve ever experienced (even though it is not the highest decibels you’ve ever been exposed to).
Interestingly, one treatment for tinnitus and hyperacusis I’ve had success with is listening to audio with significant instantaneous jumps and dips in volume and frequency. The suggested mechanism of action is you’re stressing your natural noise suppression and it strengthens itself in response. Similar principle to weightlifting to stress your muscles so they grow stronger in response. Perhaps active noise cancellation is causing these problems because it’s relieving the usual stresses placed on the mechanisms and thus they are atrophying.
I avoid active noise cancellation and white noise. I have found passive noise cancellation works well - ear plugs and ear muffs, basically. They have their own drawbacks as they will affect different frequencies differently, with usual speech frequencies often being the most suppressed. Thankfully, Etymotic Research (an absolutely incredible auditory-health-first audio gear company) has the excellent ER20XS and EtyPlugs designed to reduce all frequencies equally. I can’t speak highly enough of them and how much they’ve helped me with my auditory issues. https://www.etymotic.com/product/er20xs/ https://www.etymotic.com/product/er20xs/
Most unfortunately, it seems tinnitus is highly responsive to attention: the more attention you pay to it, the worse it gets. Obsessive researching and reading about your tinnitus can and will make it worse. Sorry. Believe me I know it sucks.
- mdmglr 4y agoMy ENT recommended white noise long term especially for sleeping which I’ve been using for months. Based on everything I’ve googled the last few months this is the first time I’m reading the claim that “ breakdown of the ears’ and/or brain’s noise filtering and suppression mechanisms.” so I’m a little skeptical in what you are saying. My understanding is that tinnitus is the damage to the hairs in the cochlea. Which causes the audio processing nerves to have issues. Not anything to do with noise filtering. However as I’ve been suffering from tinnitus I don’t want to discount anything you are saying. Do you manually adjust volume or are you doing something automated? How can I do the same?
- fwlr 4y agoI’m not a doctor and your ENT is, you should listen to them and not me. I shouldn’t have said “Prevailing theory”, that gives the wrong impression. Makes it seem like “this is what doctors think” when it’s actually just what I think. I’ll edit that. I did have a semi-automated method for causing those noise jumps, I’ll see if I can find it for you. Well, I looked, and can’t find it. It’s on a lost machine. One should always keep backups, but one rarely does. I do recall the basic structure of my solution, it was a kludge job with an AppleScript that set system volume to a random amount and a shell script that slept a random number of seconds, ran the AppleScript, and ran itself again. I vaguely recall it was hard to find programmatic system-wide equalizer settings but that may be different now, and it may be different in Linux/Windows too. It was not a comfortable experience, it definitely made listening to music into an exercise like running on a treadmill, but subjectively it was very helpful. I do recall getting the idea for this from reading medical literature on hyperacusis, so theoretically there might be some scientific support for it, but I have no citations to give.
- mdmglr 4y agoSounds good. I can write a script to do that. I’ll give this I try. Appreciate it. Might try to see if eqMac has AppleScript support. Hang in there. Hopefully one day hearing damage can be cured.
- 4y ago