3 ms·
Incineration is how you get rid of dioxins in soil. It's the only way! But mostly I am baffled by the public response to this incident. The thing about America
by jeffbee 4y ago
Incineration is how you get rid of dioxins in soil. It's the only way!
But mostly I am baffled by the public response to this incident. The thing about America is there are zillions of highly polluted sites in this country, we make more of them all the time, it takes us either decades or forever to clean them up, dioxins are a very common contaminant, and there are already hundreds of communities waiting in line for EPA actions to clean them up. So the idea that EPA actions will promptly remediate this site is somewhat ridiculous. If there are high levels of dioxins, and so far there is no evidence of that, relocating the people out of this town is the only action that can be timely taken.
Example: a site contaminated by high levels of vinyl chloride, the same junk that was spilled in Ohio, in the center of Oakland, California, has been polluted since 1960, identified since 1995, on the "national priorities list" i.e. Superfund, but no meaningful remediation has taken place and no responsible party has even been nominated yet.
- slackdog 4y ago> But mostly I am baffled by the public response to this incident. You saw the smoke column, yes? It looked like a mushroom cloud. It doesn't take a rocket surgeon to figure out why people have gotten spooked.
- jeffbee 4y agoBaffled == I am once again disappointed in the typical American's habit of ignoring systemic problems until they arrive literally in their own backyards.
- vorpalhex 4y agoDo you donate to any cleanup sites? Do you write your congress critters about them? Maybe you do and you are very engaged in pollution sites.. but I would be surprised. Everyone responds to local events more than remote ones. I don't care if the other side of the US has wildfires nearly as much as when the wildfires are close enough for me to smell them. People are self interested.
- DayDollar 4y agoSocialize the problems. Privatize the rewards. Its like socialism, but in a handstand.
- revertmean 4y agoThat's fair enough, but it's very weird to start criticizing people when they actually start to acknowledge the problem. Surely that's the time to start applauding them?
- slackdog 4y ago[flagged]
- mindslight 4y agoThe difference with this situation is that the responsible parties still exist while we're aware of the problem. They are who should be paying for the complete cost of cleanup, remediation, and damages to bystanders and property. Letting them slip out of the full liability with token or estimated damages, resume fraudulently transferring profits to shareholders, and putting the site in the back of the publicly funded queue is exactly what we don't want to happen. It's a terrible dynamic to rely on post-facto financial enforcement on business people that are mentally incapable of understanding what they've done wrong (as opposed to say proactive regulation that would have prevented this entirely preventable derailment, and separately prevented the deliberate chemical release), but it's all we've got right now.
- naasking 4y ago> But mostly I am baffled by the public response to this incident. Isn't this like being baffled that George Floyd's murder launched all of those protests when police have been killing black people for decades? Instead of being baffled, take heart that such problems are finally receiving the attention they deserve!
- kodah 4y agoThe logic you used, if I may summarize: "There's lots of accidents, some of them have been ignored for decades, why care about this one?" Frankly because it's high time people cared about what's happening to their environment and cities. Norfolk Southern is banking on the fact that rural areas and places like Oakland won't get national attention because they don't carry a lot of homogeneous national favor. Most of these derailments happen in rural areas that are cash strapped, just like the city of Oakland. Places that will be dependent on the company to come out and clean up their mess. Places that won't have funds unless aided by the EPA to check that the company actually cleaned up, and thoroughly. Places that don't have the national umph to make the NTSB to force the railroads into safer behavior. What you've failed to see here is that the Venn diagram of disasters that happen and get ignored in Oakland are a circle with places like Ohio. We all lose if a company can ignore devastating parts of Oakland or Ohio.