4 ms·
This is consistent with the upper middle class growing at the expense of the rest of the middle class: https://www.brookings.edu/research/squeezing-the-middle-c
by rayiner 4y ago
This is consistent with the upper middle class growing at the expense of the rest of the middle class: https://www.brookings.edu/research/squeezing-the-middle-class https://www.brookings.edu/research/squeezing-the-middle-clas.... This is partly the result of the shift to knowledge work, and partly the result of Reagan-era tax cuts to the upper middle class that have never been challenged by either party.
I’m convinced that the most significant and tangible aspect of income inequality in practice is not between the middle class and super rich, but between the middle class and the ordinary rich (I.e. Biden’s protected class of people making up to $400,000).
I live near Annapolis, which has always had plenty of old money yacht club types. But you could still buy a 3BR family home for under $300,000 even in 2015. Historically it’s been a place where military officers and GS-scale workers, farmers, and established tradespeople could own a nice house, a used boat, etc. It was only in the last few years, as more and more knowledge workers started moving outward from the DC area, that housing has increasingly become unaffordable. Similarly in Eugene Oregon where my wife grew up, housing prices have skyrocketed. Non-college educated but stably established folks in her family are having trouble finding affordable housing. The only billionaire there, Phil Knight, has been there forever. It’s all the yuppies from California that are the cause of the problem.
I think that’s the real story behind the growing frustration over “income inequality.” America has always had rich people. But Americans don’t really care what people do in the Hampton or in Beverly Hills do or buy. But the premiumization of the economy hits people at home.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAt least some of this phenomenon is due to dual higher income earning couples pairing together at rates much higher than before, which obviously follows from the fact that more women are earning more money than ever before.
- winkeltripel 4y ago> It’s all the yuppies from California that are the cause of the problem Yuppies may be a piece of the puzzle, but the massive surge in institional home ownership is surely the larger factor (the NIMBY obstruction of home construction is surely a factor too). Which means that it is indeed the billionaires fault, since it is their money backing it.
- AmVess 4y agoNot really. That is a local issue. People leaving the west coast have completely swamped everything from Nevada over. Starter homes in the nice cities in Idaho went from $85k to $400k in 4+ years. It isn't corporations buying these homes, but rather people fleeing the west coast in massive droves. The same is true for the east coast. Flights of large numbers of people from both coasts have put pressure inward, too. Nebraska, Minnesota, and Wisconsin have had large increases of people moving there with attendant pressures on housing prices and availability in those areas.
- rayiner 4y agoThat's wrong for the reasons mentioned here: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/housing-crisis-hedge-funds-private-equity-scapegoat/672839/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/housing-cr... For one thing, institutional buyers don't buy up enough of the supply to really move the needle in most metro areas. For another, institutional buyers generally turn homes into rentals. They can't really overpay for the housing unless there's lots of yuppies around who can pay the high rents. Supply shortages are certainly a factor, but they're related to the problem I pointed out. California knowledge worker yuppies are facing supply shortages in their own market, and getting pushed out to cheaper markets like Oregon. That has a particularly negative effect because they have so much more money than the people who are already living in those places.
- onetimeusename 4y agoDo you think H-1B immigration into white collar and tech jobs has inflated the size of the upper middle class?