8 ms·
Secret Service, ICE,and fake cell tower spying
- CyberDildonics 4y agoIt's unfortunate that what everyone was afraid of happening but expected to happen, happened.
- sambull 4y agoNow it will probably be a service offered by private entities via satellite.
- user3939382 4y agoI can only imagine the people running these organizations share the perspective of Jack Nicholson in A Few Good Men https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FnO3igOkOk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FnO3igOkOk They believe they are the law, not that they're subservient to it.
- hermitdev 4y agoI think part of the problem is the apparent lack of accountability for violations. I mean, what were the repercussions for any of the violations the OIG found? Careers need to be ended and people sent to jail over this. This is a civil rights violation en masse and needs to be treated as such. There should be no exceptions; a warrant should be required per the 4th amendment.
- vasco 4y ago[flagged]
- surge 4y agoSome people are on TikTok so everyone forfeited their privacy?
- claytongulick 4y agoWhile I definitely sympathize with your sentiment, TFA is mostly about how confusing and inconsistent the laws are. According to the article, Ron Wyden and several others tried to pass a bill to clarify the guidelines, but it didn't make it out of committee. Perhaps we should write good, clear laws and guidelines before we break out the pitchforks. I may be naive, but I still believe that most law enforcement officers want to do the right thing, and dedicate their lives to helping others. Of course egregious violations should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tsimionescu 4y ago> I may be naive, but I still believe that most law enforcement officers want to do the right thing, and dedicate their lives to helping others. That is extremely naive, especially when talking about these sorts of federal entities.
- l33t233372 4y agoCan you elaborate? What do you think most law enforcement officers want to do, and what do you think being federal changes about it?
- zmgsabst 4y ago“A few rotten apples spoil the bunch” as the saying goes. Due to never facing consequences for illegal actions, a culture of flouting the law and abusing rights has been normalized — for both federal and other agencies. The few “bad apples” rotted their organizations.
- miguelazo 4y ago>What do you think most law enforcement officers want to do Get paid large salaries and good benefits without having to go to college, in a country that doesn't respect the trades enough. And plenty of them like the power, especially the "bad apples."
- KennyBlanken 4y agoRemember, we have a supreme court that recently decided sniffer dogs are acceptable grounds for searches, despite them being worse than a coin flip. Our court system doesn't care about "fair." It cares about punishing.
- 8note 4y agoIt's likely that there's no law saying that the tools for "acceptable grounds for search" have to on average increase the probability of finding something The courts are doing they're job wrt the law
- claytongulick 4y ago@dang I'm not sure what the correct approach is to ask about this - my comment on this thread was flagged. I believe flagging it was inappropriate, as there wasn't any rule violation, just perhaps an opinion that is unpopular (support for law enforcement officers). I don't mind being downvoted for comments that are unpopular, but I think inappropriate flagging is harmful. What redress is there?
- nsajko 4y agoI'm guessing users flagged your comment, not mods. The redress is for other users to "vouch" for your comment, as I have done right now. For contacting Dang, see the "Contact" link at the bottom of the front page.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoIf dogs are on average worse than a coin flip, than just stopping people randomly (with a coin/dice) would be more honest, fair, and cheaper.
- moremetadata 4y ago> They believe they are the law, not that they're subservient to it. The public would be shocked at the level of criminality within the state, not satisfied with making up the law as they go along to suit their needs, they even go and break it.
- _8j50 4y agoYou give them too much credit. Thinking you are the law means you give a shit about justice. These people have quotas to meet and promotions to get and bosses to please. Violating your rights is just one mean to an end. A law that isn't enforced is cheaper than the paper it is written on.
- ryandrake 4y agoI think for a lot of them, especially the LE agents that come from a military background, the A Few Good Men reference actually applies. They really think we are in this endless war, and that they are patriotically defending their country from hand-wavey "enemies." If that's true, the ends justify any means, up to and including breaking the law. The law written by non-warrior civilians--what do they know about these dangers lurking around every corner? This perpetual-warrior mindset is evidently pervasive throughout law enforcement and other branches of government.
- _8j50 4y agoYou are right about them using the "perpetual warrior" thing, I think that to most of them it is just a mask they wear to not feel or look like the bad guys as opposed to that being their motivation.
- mindslight 4y agoI once heard a park ranger literally say "I am the law" while telling a story to a random visitor about how she had her sister with dogs come live with her, even though dogs were prohibited in the park (or something like that). This isn't to impugn park rangers in general nor the fantastic national park system, just a datapoint about how warped people's viewpoints can get with even an inkling of power. The whole concept of sovereign immunity needs to be massively neutered, especially as extended to individuals employed by the state rather than the state itself.
- dylan604 4y agoThere's a reason Cartman's "Respect my authority" bit is so good. These types of roles are especially attractive to a particular personality type. There are jobs where it is best to have people that do not want to be in that position vs having people seeking to be that position.
- projektfu 4y agoI see that even in my condo's HOA board. There are three types - those that are lurkers but will vote occasionally, those that do not really want to be there, but they feel they are qualified and it's their duty to do the work, and those who want to exercise power and exempt themselves from the declaration/by-laws as much as possible. You need at least one of the second to balance one of the third.
- bladegash 4y agoHaving had worked in DC much of my career, more specifically within the IC, I think more likely they believe in a general utilitarian philosophy that “the ends justify the means”. It is a common Western world view to begin with, but my personal observation is it is especially common in the grayer professions of the world. Took me personally reaching a point in life and asking the big question “do they really?” or in my case, “doesn’t it matter how you get to those ends, too?” before my own worldview/choice of profession began to shift.
- zmgsabst 4y agoThe impact on public morale when your “necessary” actions are discovered is an outcome too. I find people who say “the ends justify the means” tend to ignore outcomes of their actions which don’t support their desired bad behavior — and generally completely ignore higher-order effects, such as the corruption of the US IC undermining the US rule of law in a way no foreign adversary ever could. I don’t think US IC members have the wisdom to know what ends come from their means — they just shut their eyes, utter the catechism, and commit illegal acts that undermine the US.
- ethbr0 4y agoImho, A Few Good Men is a great movie because, especially for 1992, it spoke directly to those gray areas. About ten years later, after 9/11, the US established Guantanamo Bay detention camp, where in 2023 there are still people (32?) held outside of normal legal processes. I would expect that the 32 remaining, out of almost 800 total, are a clear threat to the United States. But is it right to keep them there? What are the moral implications of the rest of America looking away while ugly work is done with their authority and in their name? Colonel Jessep isn't 100% wrong (Santiago's death may have saved lives, but his death shouldn't have happened), and Lt Kaffee isn't 100% right (Jessep broke the law, but people are not owed unvarnished truth without earning it). Everyone's who's worked for a large corporation, even outside the IC, knows that many things are done in that grey area, with the expectation bosses would deny asking someone to do it. See the recent news about Union Pacific train wheel bearing inspections being pressured to pass. To me, the balance of any system is accepting an optimal level of corruption/abuse, in order to permit efficient functioning. Grease lets things slip, yet also decreases friction. It's ugly, sad, and terrible... but also necessary. A perfectly enforced code of laws would rapidly implode any country in the world, because it wouldn't leave room for interpretation and exceptions.
- BurningFrog 4y agoThat's not what that character believes. It's more that a nation of law and order is very desirable, but to maintain that society, those who threaten it must be fought by any means necessary. I don't know how true that is, but I can't rule out that that is how the world really works.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> law and order is very desirable, but to maintain that society, those who threaten it must be fought by any means necessary Thats is one and the same thing. When people who 'protect' the law don't follow the law themselves, you no longer have rule of law.
- BurningFrog 4y agoSure. But that's a word definition argument, not a practical one.
- user3939382 4y agoIf it's a definition argument it's a pretty significant one, that underpins the functioning of our society. Is the law something the public has, through its representatives, consented to? Or is it something the administrators and enforcers of the law have decided unilaterally without that consent?
- thephyber 4y agoYou seem to be making an argument that law enforcement should do anything to keep order, no matter the legality. I would argue that as soon as a “good guy” cuts legal corners, they set a bad example for those next to them. Those little corruptions have outsized consequences over time, like compound interest. I was in Los Angeles when LAPD brass were trying to figure out what to do after the Rampart District had been revealed for a perfect example of this corruption.
- BurningFrog 4y ago
- upofadown 4y agoBack in the day you could do off the books phone tapping with a set of alligator clips, a capacitor and a memo recorder. If you didn't want to do it yourself you could just get someone else to do it, preferably someone who works in a large central office (with or without phone company knowledge). The result was not usable in court, but it would save you immense amounts of time sitting around figuring out what criminals were doing. Things like Stingrays preserve the capability of off the books phone tapping. This sort of capability is very important for things like drug trafficking where none of the people involved are very likely to file a police report. So I suspect that the attitude of the law enforcement people involved is that they have been asked to do a job that is practically impossible without this capability.
- ROTMetro 4y agoThen use the legal process laid out to get rid of the Fourth Amendment.
- fallingknife 4y agoThe fact that people involved are not filing police reports is a strong indication that it shouldn't be a crime in the first place.
- m463 4y agoI also wonder if reality is more like No Country for Old Men
- WarOnPrivacy 4y agoFor my entire life, I've judged the competency of news orgs by whether they prioritize citizens' need for Gov accountability over baked-in deference to the NatSec state. This article serves us first and that feels a lot like relief.
- hgsgm 4y agoYou are confusing competency with bias.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y ago> You are confusing competency with bias. If you mean the conservative derogatory version, I am not. Deference to NatSec has long cut a deep gash across both major political ideologies. Neither serve us when they fail to be an fact-based adversary to Gov/Corp/LEO. If you mean the stock vanilla version where everyone prefers one thing to another, that seems too generic a term to be useful in this context.
- transpute 4y agoTwo questions on technical counter-measures: 1. Could OpenWRT + LTE modem be configured to lock onto a whitelist of known-good provider cell tower IDs? 2. If the physical location of a known-good tower is available, could a directional LTE antenna be used to ensure that tower's signal is the "strongest"?
- zekica 4y agoI'm not sure, but you can write a script to warn you if you are locked to an unknown cell id.
- px43 4y agoFake towers have always been super easy to detect. There are ways to be sneaky about it, but law enforcement doesn't care because it's not like they're going to have to face any consequences.
- transpute 4y agoIf they are easy to detect, could OpenWRT and GrapheneOS block them, or be driven by a crowd-sourced blocklist?
- LinuxBender 4y agoFor a while maybe. When such lists/apps become common enough then Siemens and others would just sell a addon for a fee that does a better job of spoofing the legit towers some of which they make. Then the block-lists would just become a placebo.
- transpute 4y agoSounds like cell towers have weaker identification than the average web/SSH server.
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoIf you can crowd source a blocklist and effectively keep the cops from interfering with your efforts, then you've solved a hard problem. If you have that level of coordination, you might be able to find something more impactful than interfering with surveillance to use it on.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoOversight is just another big lie.
- macinjosh 4y agoWhy are there no consequences for these people?
- hgsgm 4y agoBecause When in the Course of human events it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the Powers of the earth, instead of a ting, we retreat to the bread and circuses.
- anigbrowl 4y agoBecause every time someone proposes meaningful consequences a bunch of moaners come out with procedural arguments arguing that their conception of a just system is more important than the reality of an unjust one, and they get offended if you challenge their civic religiosity. Judicial opinions are full of such Paglossian nonsense.
- O__________O 4y agoWorth noting that both Secret Service and ICE likely have exceptions to Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable search and seizure based on context. Without specific examples, it’s hard to say if laws as is are being violated. If laws are not being violated, then real issue is if the exceptions should stand.
- notch898a 4y agoAs if they need much effort elsewhere. ICE (HSI) got a search warrant against me because an anonymous dog allegedly accused me of wrongdoing. That anonymous dog allegedly told an anonymous officer, who allegedly told an HSI detective. I was served a warrant based off 3rd degree, inter-species hearsay. How do you even argue against that. I still have no fucking clue what that was all about and I never interacted with a dog that alerted on me. Then the cost of the (fruitless) search warrant was sent to collections, and I now have debt collectors chasing me where the debt document literally says guarantor "ICE" on it.
- O__________O 4y agoUse of K9s as pretext for plausible cause is well known issue, that said, without knowing specifics of the situation, impossible to comment on legal merit of them submitting the cost of search warrant for debt collections.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> submitting the cost of search warrant for debt collections I'm not sure how that would even work.
- notch898a 4y agoThe way it works is they have a private party perform part of the search, then have that party bill it to you.
- 4y ago
- credit_guy 4y agoThe title is much stronger than the content. You'd think that in an article about someone "breaking the law" you'd learn about a court of law determining that fact. Otherwise, at least in this country, "innocent until proven guilty". It's part of the journalistic unwritten rules to add "allegedly" in such a title. What we learn instead is that an internal audit found that the Secret Service and ICE broke some internal DHS policy and generally internal policies are stricter than laws (otherwise they wouldn't be needed). The actual law appears to be complex, as the article itself states later: Legislators recently have tried to make CSS usage clearer. In 2021, US Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) and a bipartisan group of other lawmakers introduced a bill, the Cell-Site Simulator Warrant Act, requiring the government to obtain a warrant to deploy a CSS device. "Current federal, state, and local policies regulating Stingrays are confusing and inconsistent, opening the door to abuse and unconstrained, invasive surveillance by law enforcement," the Project on Government Oversight (POGO) said in support of the bill. The bill never made it out of committee.
- LegionMammal978 4y agoAs I understand it, the allegation here is that only by following the internal policies would their activities be allowed under the Fourth Amendment, and by breaching these policies their actions are illegal under the Fourth Amendment, not under any more specific law. Of course, as you say, this all depends on the nature of how the internal policies were breached, so it's far from a given.
- starkd 4y ago>> Guariglia argues the OIG should release the statistical data so that the public can better understand how often CSS devices play a role in investigations. While the innocence until proven guilty policy does indeed apply to individuals, it is not applicable to government agencies as a whole. Until they release statistical data or provide some level of transparency, citizens have a right to assume their rights are being violated.
- moremetadata 4y agoThe security services here in the UK do what they like, you only have to look at some of the stuff coming out of the troubles in Northern Island for example, or things like the Hillsborough disaster. The UK is terrible for this abuse of human rights and following their own interpretation of law, and it starts in childhood, usually under the pretence of teaching people/kids a law whilst they get abused. The British culture is toxic, it needed to be in order to force itself on the rest of the world as a criminal empire.
- can16358p 4y agoDo you really think governments and government organizations/forces obey the law? Don't get me wrong in an ideal world they should, but we're far from that world.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThe vast majority of time yes. Nobody obeys the law absolutely. The government is comprised of human beings.
- LocalH 4y agoWhen one is in a position of authority, where they assume rights that the individual does not have, then even a single misuse of that authority by that person, no matter how minor, should lead to blackballing from ever being allowed to be in a position of authority again, including political office. Want a police force that actually deserves respect? Then you must weed out the bad apples with vigor, and make it very clear that their behavior will not be tolerated. We could start by getting rid of "qualified immunity" as it stands, and recraft it in a much narrower fashion.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI agree with all of that. Police need more training, higher standards, higher pay, and more consequences for misconduct or betraying their mission and values. We also need to be more forgiving when mistakes are genuine.
- ape4 4y agoIn that article ICE != Internal Combustion Engine and CSS != Cascading Style Sheets. What a time to be alive.
- dboreham 4y agoAlso != Interactive Connectivity Establishment
- nine_zeros 4y agoFor most of my life, I didn't understand the American aversion to government. But having lived in this country and having seen innocent people put into precarious circumstances by poor government processes, I get it. The US government is very very incompetent. It is very important to keep power away from government agencies in America.
- arrozconcosas 4y agoThis is why making the government more effective or powerful has major unintended consequences. Checks and balances, fundamental rights, separation of powers are all beautiful things that are under-appreciated today
- browsertasker 4y ago[flagged]
- kytazo 4y agoHaven't read it yet but keywords like Secret Service, ICE,and fake cell tower spying are music to my ears
- foota 4y agoAmusingly, perhaps, this could reasonably be read as either Immigration and Customs Enforcement or Interactive Connectivity Establishment
- snickerbockers 4y agoHow do these things even work? Do phones not have some sort of security certificate authentication?
- WelcomeShorty 4y agoIt is more a WHY do these things work and the reason is, that the whole "security" part of these networks are build to do one thing: Make sure the operator of the network knows who to bill for what. Nothing else. Not to protect your ID or the content of your messages. Just and only to bill correctly. It is even forbidden for your phone to indicate IF and HOW your session is secured. Just to make sure you are not aware you're being MitMed.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoIMSI catchers should be made illegal in general. If they want data from mobile users, ask the telcos, they have all the data in their logs. Except for some minor edge cases, using an imsi catcher is only beneficial to the three letter agencies, if they're doing shady stuff and don't want the telcos to find out. Also, with any matter of surveillance, where a mass of personal info is gathered, everyone involved should be notified about the data collection in some reasonable amount of time (eg. max 30 days, unless the courts prolong it for 30 days more and have to keep manually prolonging that), so everyone gets a letter "on date X. y. 20ZQ, a police investigation done by XYZ gathered your data from X hour to Y hour in location of cell towers QWE and WER, where the following lines from the log have been forwarded to the agency: ..."
- blue039 4y agoThe problem is much deeper unfortunately. If they banned IMSI catchers it just makes the job marginally harder. When I mean marginally I truly mean MARGINALLY. Right now a police officer can fire up some software, draw a selector box around a region, and pull everyone who was in that region inside some timeframe. They don't need an IMSI catcher for that. Cell phone data from advertisers is often enough. It's real minority report pre-crime level shit. This of course all ignoring the fact that IMSI leaking happens with EM emissions which can be argued are incidentally picked up anyway and therefore information that doesnt require a warrant. Like a license plate for your car. We need much, much stronger privacy laws. But first we need to get people into congress that actually care.
- voicedYoda 4y agoI care. And I consider running, but it feels like a race to the bottom...
- ssss11 4y agoThis comment is gold. Another way to attack the problem is to educate end users. How do we convince Bob down the road that giving private information to corporations is a cause of some of our own problems? Usually I get retorts of condescending looks with a “I’ve got nothing to hide” -type response. We need to draw the whole problem space out for regular people somehow but it’s big and complex.