4 ms·
> For example you may have deer keeping the population of grass in check and wolves keeping the population of deer in check in such a way that no population eve
by roenxi 4y ago
> For example you may have deer keeping the population of grass in check and wolves keeping the population of deer in check in such a way that no population ever gets out of control.
Both populations can get completely out of control in a wildly chaotic dance with some pretty standard conditions. You might enjoy reading up on the logistic map [0]. True equilibrium is quite rare in nature, usually situations are chaotic.
People like to pretend the world is stable but the evidence really only says 'predictably chaotic'.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logistic_map https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logistic_map
- kilgnad 4y agoIt's not true true equilibrium, it oscillates around an equilibrium. You can call it an equilibrium zone. Within this zone you can get chaotic changes, but what you don't usually get is complete destruction and extinction as you do when you get an invasive species. It's impossible actually for things to be incredibly chaotic in the sense that they always overload. If this occured all the time you'd never form a sustainable ecosystem. Life would've died out quickly. Essentially Your chaos equation doesn't account for natural selection. This is the factor that holds things in equilibrium. So what you see is sort of a bunch of systems in an evolutionary arms race where each side is in a very stable equilibrium stalemate despite the fact that both sides are continuously evolving counter measures and new strategies.
- mandmandam 4y ago[dead]
- kilgnad 4y agoAs an example programmers can understand, machine learning is a better model for this than a logistic map. Natural selection is basically gradient descent with random walk as the "step" algorithm rather than back propagation. At each step, you randomly adjust the weights by a small amount. You do this with like 100 candidates and pick the best one that lowers the cost function the most. This is one generation, and you "selected" the best mutation that can proceed to the next generation of your learning algorithm. It's essentially an extremely accurate model of evolution. When you let gradient descent run in-definitely the weights will eventually converge on a minimum in general. By "in general" I mean that these weights will only converge within the vicinity of the local minimum. Keeping the learning algorithm running with random walk... what you will find is that the algorithm travels randomly all around the minimum and stays within a certain "equilibrium zone." This is exactly what happens in biology. A more accurate example would be adversarial neural networks, when you have two networks competing. What you will find is that for adversial networks you ALSO get convergence within the vicinity of a local minimum. The logistic map you present here is simply not an accurate model of evolution. I don't think an accurate model actually exists. The most accurate models are the algorithms we to do genetic programming and these models are simply simulations where we have a sort of "feel" for how the algorithm will converge. There is no closed form understanding of it. Our knowledge of these algorithms accurately reflects our knowledge of natural selection itself in the sense that you can't simply pull a random logistic map formula out of nowhere and claim it applies. It doesn't.
- roenxi 4y agoYou're talking about evolution here, but I was never talking about evolution; nor was the original article.
- kilgnad 4y agoMy entire initial post was about evolution and natural selection. And how cancer, growth and life needs to be interpreted within this framework. Your analysis is flawed because it is entirely missing this perspective in the same way a car is flawed when it's missing it's wheels. Reread my post initial post with this in mind, because you don't get it. I've been speaking about evolution from the beginning and you've been missing the point since the beginning.