3 ms·
laws aren't good enough; we need machines and math to prevent publishers from censoring or revoking access, which need to be running free software, so it is und
by kragen 4y ago
laws aren't good enough; we need machines and math to prevent publishers from censoring or revoking access, which need to be running free software, so it is under the control of the user and not software owners who become single points of failure for this kind of censorship
of course machines and math aren't enough; sufficiently repressive laws could eliminate such machines, or limit access to them to an infinitesimal group, or prevent people from learning about them. but machines and math can offer enormous leverage to such book-burnings, as amazon swindle does, or instead offer enormous leverage to those who want to resist them
- andsoitis 4y agoIsn’t it that most authors want DRM because they are afraid that their works get pirated?
- kragen 4y agono, most authors clearly don't want drm or they wouldn't upload their work to dreamwidth, an archive of our own, hacker news, the internet archive, youtube, mastodon, facebook, twitter, etc. but even if they did, the interest of this narrow special interest group in not having their works get pirated is clearly less important than the public interest in having reliable access to honest knowledge about the past
- andsoitis 4y agoYour second paragraph. Are you really arguing that the majority of authors don’t want DRM but they can’t stand up as a majority group against Amazon? I don’t buy it.
- kragen 4y agoyes, that's exactly what i'm saying; amazon is organized and authors aren't that seems so obviously correct to me that it boggles my mind that someone could disagree
- andsoitis 4y agoThanks. I wonder whether authors have tried to exert collective power via publishers, or whether publishers are part of the issue. Did a bit of digging — seems like both JK Rowling and Stephen King are more in favor of watermarking.