4 ms·
> Shouldn’t it be possible to argue that consumers specifically bought a particular revision Except they didn't. They licensed a copy of the book, and that lic
by paxys 4y ago
> Shouldn’t it be possible to argue that consumers specifically bought a particular revision
Except they didn't. They licensed a copy of the book, and that license was revocable or changeable at any time. It's all there in the 175 page agreement they were forced to sign before the purchase went through.
Consumers lost the digital ownership battle a long time ago.
- Aerroon 4y agoDoes the button to buy say "license" or "buy"?
- paxys 4y agoSure sue them and go argue about it in court. There's already multiple decades worth of precedence against you in the matter.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoBuy...a license.
- account42 4y agoBuying a license is what you do when you hire a legal firm to draft you one. Not when you click "Buy" on a Kindle E-Book on Amazon.
- pnt12 4y agoI wholeheartedly agree: don't say something in the UI and the opposite in the ToS. I can slightly sympathize that digital media may have different rules than physical, but some are just misleading.
- mock-possum 4y agoyou bought a license. this is not the checkmate you think it is.
- User23 4y agoNo they didn’t. You don’t need a license for using a legally acquired copy. The copyright act already grants you that right. Please stop repeating this lie created by publishers’ lawyers.
- politician 4y agoI'm pretty sure that with careful prompting we can use LLMs to regenerate the text of the book (that is, "a close approximation in the style of the author") and escape copyright entirely.
- smsm42 4y agoFunny that I can get a paper copy of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, for which I own all the rights, in perpetuity, and can resell or gift it as I wish, for $5.94, but a digital "license", which gives me no rights and can disappear at any moment, and I can not do anything with it, costs $7.99, or 35% more. You literally are paying for your rights to be taken away, isn't it marvelous? Oh yes, and if I'm ok with a used copy, it's $2.15. Would I shame anyone (including myself) if somehow, by an unexplained miracle of nature, it happens that a DRM-less digital copy of the same book appears on their hard drive? No, I won't.