2 ms·
An author, and by extension the vehicle that they choose to shepherd their work after death, should have full rights to do whatever with their work. Having sai
by andsoitis 4y ago
An author, and by extension the vehicle that they choose to shepherd their work after death, should have full rights to do whatever with their work.
Having said that, I can speculate that an author could stipulate that no changes may be made but I can also imagine that many may choose to allow flexibility.
- Syntonicles 4y agoI think they choose the simplest path that sounds reasonable. Who would have anticipated edits like these? All I'm suggesting to provide an easy alternative. The simplest path for me is throwing an MIT or GPL snippet in my root folder. A copy/paste clause on a static website should be sufficient.
- JPKab 4y agoNetflix owns the rights. This isn't the author's family or anyone else. Just a dumb bunch of soulless LA based execs virtue signaling/moralizing in between their coke/hooker binges. https://www.scotsman.com/news/people/netflix-acquires-rights-to-roald-dahls-childrens-books-3393120 https://www.scotsman.com/news/people/netflix-acquires-rights...
- andsoitis 4y agoNot only are you wrong to imply that Netflix is making edits to the books (it is the publisher, Penguin), Penguin is also going to publish the classic versions: https://abcnews.go.com/Business/wireStory/penguin-publish-classic-roald-dahl-books-after-backlash-97441402 https://abcnews.go.com/Business/wireStory/penguin-publish-cl...
- JPKab 4y agoSo they're editing the Kindle versions and kind enough to allow us to spend money on the originals we already paid for? Awesome.
- JPKab 4y agohttps://techcrunch.com/2021/09/22/netflix-is-acquiring-the-rights-to-roald-dahls-books https://techcrunch.com/2021/09/22/netflix-is-acquiring-the-r... Netflix owns RDSC. RDSC had to authorize changes by Penguin. I'm sure you're excited about the new version, given your confident denunciation that was dead wrong.
- pharrington 4y agoThe publisher should definitely be able to choose what they wanna sell, and issue new revisions as they see fit. Going into my house and rewriting instances of the work that I already own is insane. This is just as ridiculous as if Amazon were to delete ebooks you've purchased for your Kindle.
- kelnos 4y ago> The publisher should definitely be able to choose what they wanna sell, and issue new revisions as they see fit. I agree with the first half of your sentence, but not the second. If an author finalizes their work, then that's it. The publisher can choose to publish or not publish it, but they do not own the copyright on the work, and are not permitted to make modifications and then distribute what can only be considered an unauthorized derived work. Granted, copyright holders may of course contractually allow publishers to do this. I can only assume this is the case for Dahl's works, as I'd be surprised if a major book publisher did something that would infringe on an author's (estate's) copyright. But I don't think this should be the default, and I'd hope and expect copyright law agrees with me.
- einherjae 4y agoNetflix owns the Dahl’s estate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 4y ago> An author, and by extension the vehicle that they choose to shepherd their work after death, should have full rights to do whatever with their work. Nope, not with the sold copies. Not to mention copyright terms in the US are ridiculously overextended by congressmen comfortably sitting in Disney's pocket. So no argument about "extension" plays anymore - they overplayed their hand so hard there it is not even close to something natural, it's purely "the law is what I can buy" now.