20 ms·
I think people miss that the US government (as basically all governments) is not a singular entity with absolutely aligned objectives. Or even how tools don't h
by godelski 4y ago
I think people miss that the US government (as basically all governments) is not a singular entity with absolutely aligned objectives. Or even how tools don't have universal purposes. It's far from inconceivable that the US government wants to use use Tor to hide spies (CIA) as well as use Tor to help people communicate against their own governments (Department of Democracy). This isn't even opposing objectives, which we also see in any large entity (see encryption in general).
Painting the US government with a broad brush as "absolute evil" is just as bad as painting it with a broad brush of "savior of the world." Neither allows us to actually improve our government because in the former you can't encourage good actions and the latter doesn't allow you to discourage bad actions. If everything is bad then there are no degrees of bad. If everything is good there's no degrees of good. If Democracy is an optimization problem (it is) then this is like trying to find the optima by going in a constant direction with a constant step size.
I thought it was rather obvious that "shit is complicated and requires nuance" but I'm often impressed how common it is to pretend things are simple and obvious.