4 ms·
Campbell's law is not simply a "social variant" of Goodhart's law. The two have a subtle but crucial difference. To paraphrase a DonaldTrumpism, Goodhart's law
by tpoacher 4y ago
Campbell's law is not simply a "social variant" of Goodhart's law. The two have a subtle but crucial difference.
To paraphrase a DonaldTrumpism, Goodhart's law says "Sounds good, doesn't work".
Whereas Campbell's law adds "Worse still, it'll certainly backfire", and makes that the focus.
Incidentally, the other "law" alluded to in the text, also has a name:
> The (Lance) Armstrong Principle:
"If you push people to promise more than they can deliver, they’re motivated to cheat."
A more general rephrasing: if you create / hold people accountable (e.g. by forcing a promise) to unreasonable expectations of performance that cannot be delivered there will be a motivation to cut corners, e.g. cheat.
(Popularized by Andrew Gelman; I first encountered this in an article by friend/colleague Nick Yeung, about the bad side of forcing phd students to publish, also an interesting article in its own right: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-019-0685-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-019-0685-4 )