3 ms·
"Now everyone is afraid of something that should be safer than the status quo." I agree when talking about it at a population level. But that still doesn't mea
by giantg2 4y ago
"Now everyone is afraid of something that should be safer than the status quo."
I agree when talking about it at a population level. But that still doesn't mean much. The status quo is extraordinarily low, mostly due to people's lack of knowledge or bad decision making. These autonomous systems can address part of this on the reactive side (object in the way, apply brakes). It's still lacking in the proactive side (someone is weaving, maybe I should leave some extra following distance; I'm about to be rear ended at a light, let me pull ahead if its safe).
So yeah, the vehicles are better drivers than the worst people, probably better than average. But I'm not convinced they're safer than the best drivers, especially when looking at overall accident avoidance and not just accidents they're liable for.
- nyrikki 4y agoSchool bus drivers are safer than airline pilots per exposure hour, in fact they are safer than walking. The big problem with driver assistance products is the automation bias issue with human drivers. Mixed in with humans being really bad at maintaining attention while bored. We see this even with highly trained airline pilots with backup crashing due to automation bias. Despite the common myth, drunk drivers have higher fatality rates than those who are hit. Selling driver assistance as self driving or allowing it to be used without serious attention detection safeguards won't make distracted or impaired drivers safer. I'm fact for first responders, highway workers and pedestrians, any form of driver assistance that allows drivers to checkout of the driving task, they will be far less safe. The only way that these companies claim that there systems are safer today is the they disengage quick enough to claim they weren't at fault but without time for the distracted drivers to respond. By ignoring automation bias, which is a well known human flaw, they pad their numbers and make them seem safer, while not having enough data to even make statistical claims that they do. Outside of naive beliefs that autonomous cars are safe driving confirmation bias the common myth that self driving cars are safer is baseless. I get that is the goal, but assuming it is true without evidence is part of the reason the public is starting to doubt the claims.