5 ms·

MailCrab

196 points by lukastyrychtr 4y ago

mns 4y ago
This looks quite nice and lean, we started using https://github.com/maildev/maildev https://github.com/maildev/maildev especially for the arm64 support.
tenken 4y ago
I have used the Java smtp test email server FakeSMTP which has been around since around 2015. It can run via CLI as a service with no GUI, or with a GUI interface via Swing: http://nilhcem.com/FakeSMTP/ http://nilhcem.com/FakeSMTP/
cheapliquor 4y ago
snibbety snab
tigerlily 4y ago
Tweede golf, means "second wave" in dutch.
- yurishimo 4y ago
  As someone who recently moved to NL and is trying to learn Dutch, I've found that translating plurals is probably the most annoying part of my life at the moment. "De golven" is the plural form, so "golf" makes sense, but Google Translate doesn't really know that. It did suggest "golven" in the "See also" section, but it wasn't obvious at first. Especially when the sport golf is also spelled the same way! Other things I have trouble with is sentence structure, but that's not really annoying so much as it is frustration bourn of ignorance. I'll get there one day!
- Aachen 4y ago
  Which sounded like a covid thing to me. Must have been interesting to watch the access logs for tweedegold.nl in fall 2020! (That is, I assume the name was chosen before covid but the About page doesn't say.)
emptysea 4y ago
One of the things I like about Django is the builtin support for a console backend for emails In dev it means you can have sent emails get logged to the terminal which makes debugging easier. But it only really works well with text emails, this seems like a more robust solution
- axelthegerman 4y ago
  Yep very nice if all you need is an email or two, maybe an activation code or link. Definitely an email heavy application benefits from something more advanced like MailCrab PS Ruby on Rails also logs emails to the console
- nickjj 4y ago
  The terminal solution is handy but sometimes it fails because you could end up with a sign in link or some type of link with a very long token that wraps to multiple lines making it impossible to click. Rails also prints emails to the terminal and has a backend solution that doesn't really send emails out but I still prefer using MailCatcher to display them in a UI (it has both amd64 and arm64 Docker support[0], real-time updates and a ~25mb compressed Docker image). [0]: https://hub.docker.com/r/schickling/mailcatcher/tags https://hub.docker.com/r/schickling/mailcatcher/tags
  - noduerme 4y ago
    It also just works for all frameworks if you hack the receiver and BCC: emails you want to test to yourself to make sure they're actually being sent and look alright.
orra 4y ago
I don't know if the author is on here, but I wonder what it was like doing the frontend in Rust (Yew). How does the developer experience compare to Vue, I suppose?
- mmbaeten 4y ago
  Hi, the author of MailCrab here :-) Yew is nice, especially if you enjoy writing Rust. However, it definitely takes more time and dedication than writing a frontend in React, Vue etc. Yew and the surrounding ecosystem keeps improving, and it is way more usable than when I first tried it. The tooling I used (Trunk https://trunkrs.dev/ https://trunkrs.dev/) is very minimal with respect to the number of features compared to many of the popular web-bundlers (Webpack etc.) but it works well for most simple use-cases.
jbergstroem 4y ago
Longtime mailhog user here; this looks like a nice improvement for cold start developer environments! Another option in the same space (emphasis container size) is https://github.com/inbucket/inbucket https://github.com/inbucket/inbucket
brightball 4y ago
For shared non-production environments, I’ve always been a big fan of Mailtrap.io in this space. Same idea of faking delivery but puts it in a location where non-devs can access and review it. https://mailtrap.io/ https://mailtrap.io/
- jerz 4y ago
  You could also look at https://imitate.email https://imitate.email Similar idea to mailtrap but has a web widget so that you can embed it in the projects you’re building, improving the UX for devs and testers. (Disclaimer: It’s mine!)
- Ocha 4y ago
  Also, there is https://mailsnag.com https://mailsnag.com that has more generous free plan and error simulations. Helped me uncover couple bugs in my projects
- drewjoh 4y ago
  There's also: https://usehelo.com https://usehelo.com
achairapart 4y ago
In this space there is also Mailpit[0], written in GO, runs from a single binary (also has Docker images). [0]: https://github.com/axllent/mailpit https://github.com/axllent/mailpit
- ed25519FUUU 4y ago
  A tiny cross-platform binary, a tiny docker image image? That’s every bullet point but the written in rust one!
- xslvrxslwt 4y ago
  According to Discord, Go was (or at least it used to) cause huge latency spikes because of it's GC - they've rewritten it in Rust and now it's A LOT faster, without any latency spikes. https://discord.com/blog/why-discord-is-switching-from-go-to-rust https://discord.com/blog/why-discord-is-switching-from-go-to...
  - Scaevolus 4y ago
    300ms latency spikes on a particularly pathological production workload are irrelevant for the stated use case of a test email server.
    - Diti 4y ago
      When does one decide whether an environment is a test? I would like to test SMTP notifications of a staging server at work, approximately 15 million emails to be sent. This is NOT production, but those 300 ms spikes would be unacceptable. That Rust rewrite seems to be a godsend.
  - ptman 4y ago
    The go GC has kept evolving since.
  - joaonmatos 4y ago
    Which is a factor that really does not matter for a test server
tambourine_man 4y ago
Typo * _its_ own bullet
- mmbaeten 4y ago
  Thank you, fixed it :-)
dcormier 4y ago
That’s nice since MailHog seems dead. I’ve had PRs open for their SMTP server package for years. One for a bug, the other to support Unicode recipient addresses. Once I got one of their attention on Twitter and they said they would have it looked at the next week, but nothing seemed to happen.
tiffanyh 4y ago
Embarrassed to ask, so what’s the use case for this?
- ed25519FUUU 4y ago
  One use-case I can think of is integration and validation tests. Send emails, then use the API to programmatically retrieve and check content.
- ianpurton 4y ago
  It's really useful during development to test email send functionality in your app.
rikkipitt 4y ago
Looking forward to trying this out. I do a lot of email testing locally for paced.email and vend.email. MailHog is 90% of the way there, but seems like it's fallen by the wayside...
andrei_says_ 4y ago
Like the Ruby mailcatcher?
RobertRoberts 4y ago
It's finding systems like this that make HN valuable from time to time. I didn't even "think" to look for a system like this, and I could use it right now, and I find there are multiple other ones similar in the same posting from comments.
FuckShadowBans3 4y ago
[dead]

196 points by lukastyrychtr 4y ago

mns 4y ago

This looks quite nice and lean, we started using https://github.com/maildev/maildev https://github.com/maildev/maildev especially for the arm64 support.

tenken 4y ago

I have used the Java smtp test email server FakeSMTP which has been around since around 2015. It can run via CLI as a service with no GUI, or with a GUI interface via Swing: http://nilhcem.com/FakeSMTP/ http://nilhcem.com/FakeSMTP/

cheapliquor 4y ago

snibbety snab

tigerlily 4y ago

Tweede golf, means "second wave" in dutch.

yurishimo 4y ago
As someone who recently moved to NL and is trying to learn Dutch, I've found that translating plurals is probably the most annoying part of my life at the moment. "De golven" is the plural form, so "golf" makes sense, but Google Translate doesn't really know that. It did suggest "golven" in the "See also" section, but it wasn't obvious at first. Especially when the sport golf is also spelled the same way! Other things I have trouble with is sentence structure, but that's not really annoying so much as it is frustration bourn of ignorance. I'll get there one day!
Aachen 4y ago
Which sounded like a covid thing to me. Must have been interesting to watch the access logs for tweedegold.nl in fall 2020! (That is, I assume the name was chosen before covid but the About page doesn't say.)

emptysea 4y ago

One of the things I like about Django is the builtin support for a console backend for emails In dev it means you can have sent emails get logged to the terminal which makes debugging easier. But it only really works well with text emails, this seems like a more robust solution

axelthegerman 4y ago
Yep very nice if all you need is an email or two, maybe an activation code or link. Definitely an email heavy application benefits from something more advanced like MailCrab PS Ruby on Rails also logs emails to the console
nickjj 4y ago
The terminal solution is handy but sometimes it fails because you could end up with a sign in link or some type of link with a very long token that wraps to multiple lines making it impossible to click. Rails also prints emails to the terminal and has a backend solution that doesn't really send emails out but I still prefer using MailCatcher to display them in a UI (it has both amd64 and arm64 Docker support[0], real-time updates and a ~25mb compressed Docker image). [0]: https://hub.docker.com/r/schickling/mailcatcher/tags https://hub.docker.com/r/schickling/mailcatcher/tags
- noduerme 4y ago
  It also just works for all frameworks if you hack the receiver and BCC: emails you want to test to yourself to make sure they're actually being sent and look alright.

orra 4y ago

I don't know if the author is on here, but I wonder what it was like doing the frontend in Rust (Yew). How does the developer experience compare to Vue, I suppose?

mmbaeten 4y ago
Hi, the author of MailCrab here :-) Yew is nice, especially if you enjoy writing Rust. However, it definitely takes more time and dedication than writing a frontend in React, Vue etc. Yew and the surrounding ecosystem keeps improving, and it is way more usable than when I first tried it. The tooling I used (Trunk https://trunkrs.dev/ https://trunkrs.dev/) is very minimal with respect to the number of features compared to many of the popular web-bundlers (Webpack etc.) but it works well for most simple use-cases.

jbergstroem 4y ago

Longtime mailhog user here; this looks like a nice improvement for cold start developer environments! Another option in the same space (emphasis container size) is https://github.com/inbucket/inbucket https://github.com/inbucket/inbucket

brightball 4y ago

For shared non-production environments, I’ve always been a big fan of Mailtrap.io in this space. Same idea of faking delivery but puts it in a location where non-devs can access and review it. https://mailtrap.io/ https://mailtrap.io/

jerz 4y ago
You could also look at https://imitate.email https://imitate.email Similar idea to mailtrap but has a web widget so that you can embed it in the projects you’re building, improving the UX for devs and testers. (Disclaimer: It’s mine!)
Ocha 4y ago
Also, there is https://mailsnag.com https://mailsnag.com that has more generous free plan and error simulations. Helped me uncover couple bugs in my projects
drewjoh 4y ago
There's also: https://usehelo.com https://usehelo.com

achairapart 4y ago

In this space there is also Mailpit[0], written in GO, runs from a single binary (also has Docker images). [0]: https://github.com/axllent/mailpit https://github.com/axllent/mailpit

ed25519FUUU 4y ago
A tiny cross-platform binary, a tiny docker image image? That’s every bullet point but the written in rust one!
xslvrxslwt 4y ago
According to Discord, Go was (or at least it used to) cause huge latency spikes because of it's GC - they've rewritten it in Rust and now it's A LOT faster, without any latency spikes. https://discord.com/blog/why-discord-is-switching-from-go-to-rust https://discord.com/blog/why-discord-is-switching-from-go-to...
- Scaevolus 4y ago
  300ms latency spikes on a particularly pathological production workload are irrelevant for the stated use case of a test email server.
  - Diti 4y ago
    When does one decide whether an environment is a test? I would like to test SMTP notifications of a staging server at work, approximately 15 million emails to be sent. This is NOT production, but those 300 ms spikes would be unacceptable. That Rust rewrite seems to be a godsend.
- ptman 4y ago
  The go GC has kept evolving since.
- joaonmatos 4y ago
  Which is a factor that really does not matter for a test server

tambourine_man 4y ago

Typo * _its_ own bullet

mmbaeten 4y ago
Thank you, fixed it :-)

dcormier 4y ago

That’s nice since MailHog seems dead. I’ve had PRs open for their SMTP server package for years. One for a bug, the other to support Unicode recipient addresses. Once I got one of their attention on Twitter and they said they would have it looked at the next week, but nothing seemed to happen.

tiffanyh 4y ago

Embarrassed to ask, so what’s the use case for this?

ed25519FUUU 4y ago
One use-case I can think of is integration and validation tests. Send emails, then use the API to programmatically retrieve and check content.
ianpurton 4y ago
It's really useful during development to test email send functionality in your app.

rikkipitt 4y ago

Looking forward to trying this out. I do a lot of email testing locally for paced.email and vend.email. MailHog is 90% of the way there, but seems like it's fallen by the wayside...

andrei_says_ 4y ago

Like the Ruby mailcatcher?

RobertRoberts 4y ago

It's finding systems like this that make HN valuable from time to time. I didn't even "think" to look for a system like this, and I could use it right now, and I find there are multiple other ones similar in the same posting from comments.

FuckShadowBans3 4y ago

[dead]