4 ms·
Does the Google policy of allowing dogs at work offend Muslims? Does Google have dog-free zones?
I'm curious about this. It seems that such a policy would not create a friendly work environment for Muslims.
While I'm not Muslim, I would not like to work around dogs or most other pets for that matter (although I would be ok with a fish tank).
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- ivankirigin 19y agoGenerally, I believe people have the right to be offended by anything and voice their opinions about it. Because it can be for anything, people shouldn't have the right to force change. This should be as much company policy as the law allows. Also, I love dogs. They're so cute! http://mfrost.typepad.com/cute_overload/pups/index.html http://mfrost.typepad.com/cute_overload/pups/index.html There is a funny story related to this. My company has a tiny branch on the other side of the country. Essentially an elite group of engineers wanted more sun, and started a skunk-works. After paying tens of thousands of dollars for a video-conference system, it wasn't used often. This is because a golden retriever would be the only one on the small office side. He'd come after hearing the system start and would sit in front of the camera. The owner was off doing real work.
- amichail 19y agoHow is this different from allowing people to bring guns to work that they may point at you occasionally?
- ivankirigin 19y agoWaving a gun at someone is a direct threat, which is totally different. In some states, you can bring guns to the office. If a dog is poorly trained, only a fool would bring it to the office. I suppose allergies make this more complicated, but that wasn't really the question.
- amichail 19y agoI think people have better judgment than dogs. In a way, someone pointing a gun at you is less dangerous than a dog -- no matter how well trained it may be.
- willarson 19y agoNormally when you try to make a point using reduction to absurdity you jump straight to nuclear missiles: i.e. "How is this different from allowing people to bring nuclear missiles to work that they may point at you occasionally?" Unfortunately this is a contrived comparison. People who are bringing dogs into work are not bringing them as weapons that they then deliberately threaten their coworkers with. The key differences here is intentionality: bringing a dog to work is not intrinsically threatening, point a gun at someone is. Your comparison only becomes valid if the individuals brought their dogs into work and threatened to assault coworkers with them. This is likely not part of Google's acceptable policies.
- amichail 19y agoThe point is dogs are less predictable than people and may decide to attack for no obvious reason. It doesn't matter that their owners did not bring them to work to intimidate coworkers.
- willarson 19y agoYour argument is based your intuitive view on the comparable reliability of dogs and people. It is your personal opinion that dogs are less predictable than people. Personally I find your opinion to be troubling, how can a much simpler creature be more complex and less predictable? There have been between 17 and 26 dog related deaths per year for the past two decades in the US. There were 28874 gun related deaths in 1999 in the US. These numbers don't tell a very complete story, but I think they are sufficient to raise doubts about your premise that dogs are less predictable or more dangerous than armed humans.
- ivankirigin 19y agoWatch the dog whisperer. Dogs are extremely predictable. Now I'm exposing my biases :). I suppose a serious reason not to allow dogs is that some people might not know how to act around them, and would become a danger to themselves. But again, only the most well behaved dogs should be included. I should also mention that I don't feel very strongly about any of this.
- SwellJoe 19y ago"How is this different from allowing people to bring guns to work that they may point at you occasionally?" Wow. You're really nuts. What kind of dogs are you hanging out with? ;-)
- ivankirigin 19y agoI should note that this can conflict with what should also be a major goal: keeping employees as happy as possible. This is one reason why managers and HR folks have annoying jobs.
- willarson 19y agoReligious acceptance is a two-way street. Demanding that other religions accept your religious tenants is bigotry. As a world with diverse conflicting religions we have to remember that our relationship with a higher power (or lack thereof) is a personal issue: we ought to apply our standards to ourselves, attempts to force them on others end with catastrophe. The typical response to my statement is "What if their religion supports eating babies?" This is what secular government is for, it formulates these things called laws which trump religious preference. The response to that response is "there is no truly secular government." Imperfection is one of the few realities we can count on, condemning a solution for its lack of perfection is insincere. Remember that we're all using operating systems built the Wrong Way.
- amichail 19y agoThere are two issues here. If indeed most Muslims don't like being around dogs, then there is definitely a problem with Google's policy. The other issue is that some people -- like me -- simply don't like being around dogs even though this has nothing to do with religious beliefs.
- willarson 19y agoFirst, just because most Muslims don't like being around dogs doesn't automatically indicate that there is a problem with Google's policy. People that don't like being around dogs will place a lower value upon working at Google. People who do like dogs will place a higher value upon working at Google. If more people like dogs than don't like dogs, Google will benefit from their policy, and those who dislike dogs will suffer for their intolerance. If the opposite is true then they will suffer from their policy and people who dislike dogs will benefit. Regardless of your policy someone is being discriminated against, so moral arguments will be irresolute. As such, economic reasoning seems as good as standard to judge by as any other. The claims of discrimination by allowing dogs in the workplace suffer from assuming that the status quo is some how more just than an alternative: don't worry, someone gets screwed no matter what.
- amichail 19y ago
- SwellJoe 19y agoDon't like dogs? Work somewhere else. The vast majority of offices don't allow dogs. Google allows a lot of things that most offices don't...you take the good with the bad. I've been to the Google offices quite a bit, and dogs are not a major source of annoyance for anyone, as far as I can tell (though, truth be told, I like dogs a lot--though the majority of them are small dogs and I tend to like them less than proper sized ones). Nobody makes you work at any particular office or in any particular type of environment...it's up to you to decide where you'll be happiest. Seems pretty obvious to me, but maybe I'm too much of a free market fanboy to see how oppressive Google's dog policy is for dog-haters.