5 ms·
> Are any other manufacturers pushing as hard here? Why would they. Most of those things are not sustainable. You don't want alluminium wires in your car.
by hulitu 4y ago
> Are any other manufacturers pushing as hard here?
Why would they. Most of those things are not sustainable.
You don't want alluminium wires in your car.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoIt is really funny when West is discovering magic of cheap aluminum for wires, while former Eastern Block is ripping aluminum wires from walls because it is no.1 reason for fires.
- jasongill 4y agoAluminum is perfectly fine as a conductor, and perfectly safe. In the USA, we've used aluminum for most of our power transmission and distribution since the beginning of "the grid". Everything from the power plant to the meter at your home is connected with aluminum. Where aluminum causes fires is due to the fact that it expands and contracts more than copper does, and it can oxidize and corrode when not properly cared for (for example, when dissimilar metals are used, or when exposed aluminum wire ends are not properly coated). We can assume that someone at Tesla is familiar with the properties of aluminum and can insure that they are using the right connectors to mitigate these issues. (or at least, we can hope)
- axus 4y agoPerhaps the decrease in reliability was pitched internally as a way to sell more Teslas in the future?
- tylerag 4y agoThe other problem in house wiring is that when you tighten down the screw to attach the aluminum wire to the terminal, the aluminum work hardens, and expansion/contraction/vibration will cause it to break.
- chollida1 4y ago> It is really funny when West is discovering magic of cheap aluminum for wires, while former Eastern Block is ripping aluminum wires from walls because it is no.1 reason for fires. Aluminum was used for a short time in the west for household wiring and was quickly outlawed.
- zip1234 4y agoIt's commonly used for the main wire into homes. As long as it is sized properly and uses the appropriate connections it is fine.
- newaccount74 4y agoI would assume those "high voltage conductors" are more like rigid bus bars, and not flexible wires. Edit: Judging by the picture on this article [1] I am wrong. [1]: https://hackaday.com/2022/01/13/exploring-tesla-model-s-high-voltage-cabling/ https://hackaday.com/2022/01/13/exploring-tesla-model-s-high...
- schiffern 4y agoTesla does use traditional stranded copper too, but the aluminum I referenced is indeed a rigid bus bar. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35014013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35014013
- brookst 4y ago> You don't want alluminium wires in your car Why not? I^2*r says that running 75% less current will generate 94% less heat. Existing copper wires would be a disaster if cars ran on a 3V system. Aluminum at 48V will be fine, as long as it’s sized appropriately the same way copper is today.
- KaiserPro 4y ago> Why not? I^2*r says that running 75% less current will generate 94% less heat. Thats not the argument, you can do that now with copper cables. Aluminium is a good conductor, but it is reactive, brittle and not as malleable as copper. also, copper has almost half the resistance per meter than aluminium. So even for solid bus bars, it doesn't make that much sense, unless you have structural bus bars.
- eimrine 4y ago> copper has almost half the resistance per meter than aluminium. But 4 times the weight
- brookst 4y agoMost car wiring harnesses are affixed to structural members and don’t need to flex. And twice the resistance doesn’t matter. So you go one gauge bigger. If the material is cheaper, more available, and suitable, that’s fine. We don’t insist on gold wires because they’re “better” than copper. It’s all tradeoffs. I don’t see a reason to be philosophically opposed to aluminum other than “it’s possible to do it wrong”, which is of course also true for copper.
- KaiserPro 4y ago> cheaper, more available, and suitable Indeed, but automotive wiring is subject to intense and persistent vibration and heat cycles. so all those ties become stress points for fatigue to cluster around. I'm not saying its never a good idea to use an aluminium wire loom, but I'm struggling to find a situation where its required
- linsomniac 4y ago>You don't want alluminium wires in your car. Why not?
- jfengel 4y agoI assume, for the same reason you don't want them in your house. It expands differently from copper as it warms, and the connections can loosen. If Tesla has switched to aluminum I imagine they've found a way to fix that. Possibly by making the entire electrical system out of aluminum, so that it all expands the same way, or possibly a connector designed to avoid that.
- linsomniac 4y agoThe primary reason you don't want aluminum in your house is that homegamers will improperly do repairs, primarily replacing devices (receptacles, switches) with ones that are not rated CO/ALR rated. I doubt that failure will be as likely in the cars. Properly terminated, there is no problem with aluminum wiring in your house. As another replier mentioned, most houses do have aluminum wiring in the run to the house and the run from the meter to the panel, and sometimes in the larger runs like stove and dryer. It's also worth noting that the newer aluminum formulas like Southwire SIMpul, are not like the old aluminum like was installed in my house in the early '70s. But, buyers are still gunshy from the '70s, so copper is generally preferred
- rr888 4y agoCopper costs 6x Aluminium and is much rarer + in a car you want to be as lightweight as possible. You need a good reason to avoid it.