3 ms·
I love reading this stuff to figure out what new words elite white people have for me. Apparently I’m not a “minority” or a “naturalized citizen” anymore, and m
by rayiner 4y ago
I love reading this stuff to figure out what new words elite white people have for me. Apparently I’m not a “minority” or a “naturalized citizen” anymore, and my kids aren’t “second generation Americans.”
- tptacek 4y agoI'm involved in local politics in Oak Park, IL, also known as the People's Republic of Oak Park, 85.5% Clinton in '16, 72% college educated, median income about $15k higher than Evanston, and I have never heard any of these words in the elite white conversations I am continually dragged into. These guides get published to give The Groups something to do. Very few people in the real world --- yes, even the elite whites --- take them seriously. The only durable change I've noticed in the last few years is capitalizing Black, which is something our mutual fave John McWhorter has been advocating for some time.
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s definitely “in the real world” here in DC, especially in the legal profession. This is where Sierra Club is, after all.
- tptacek 4y agoSo, in The Groups, then, and around the headquarters city of The Groups.
- testfoobar 4y agoIt's also heavily pushed in high school level journalism now.
- tptacek 4y agoWhat, and where?
- testfoobar 4y agoI'm sorry I can't point you to a public online source. My comment is anecdotal; relying on my own observations across family and friends with kids at the HS level. It is pretty obvious speaking to them that their advisors and administrators expect all written pieces to comply with DEI principles. I have asked if there is a formal style-book and no one has pointed me to one yet. But there is a powerful group think. Not complying is asking for censure or excommunication.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoThere's a sign in the assistant principles offices at my local high school which defines what critical race theory is, including the "critique of liberalism" part. I would ban public high schools from encouraging a "critique of liberalism". Being a critic takes no skill and doesn't help the world. Critical theory, and critical thinking are extremely overrated skills. We need constructive thinking and constructive communication.
- tptacek 4y agoIt is not in fact the case that you can work out what Critical Theory, Critical Legal Theory, and Critical Race Theory (3 distinct concepts originating at 3 different points in the 20th century) axiomatically from the the word "critic".
- viridian 4y agoI'm in academia, just underwent this sort of training this week. Not interested in risking self identifying so I'll only go so far as to say that the Sierra Club's language is fairly close to how we are expected to talk with students, faculty, and staff. It is of course a "learning process" and so there is room for "growth and critical conversations", but the die has been cast, so to speak.
- tptacek 4y agoThe parent comment is referring to high schools. I'm not surprised, and don't think anyone else is either, that there might be a university that has gone fully up its own butt this way. I'm curious to hear stories about high schools that have formalized it in some way, though. Do you have a story like that?
- prawn 4y agoI know you were responding to the "elite white people" bit, but is there an age element at play with this? If there are people that have absorbed the idea that you unquestioningly adjust your speaking/writing to be a perfectly respectful person, I'd guess they were 20-30yo?
- LudwigNagasena 4y ago> capitalizing Black, which is something our mutual fave John McWhorter has been advocating for some time Is this sarcasm? I am not quite sure what this is supposed to convey.
- tptacek 4y agoNo, there is nothing sarcastic about this.
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoI don’t think John McWhorter has been advocating that.
- tptacek 4y agoHe started hedging when the NYT adopted it as their house style (understandably, because the NYT's rationale was silly, overreaching, and a little incoherent), but he's talked about this on Lexicon Valley before: it's proper noun describing a specific set of people for whom "African" is an imprecise descriptor.
- Pigalowda 4y agoI’m at UW - mentioned in the article. It’s rampant and absurd here. I can’t wait to get out. This place has only driven me right politically.
- testfoobar 4y agoWe'd have to know the CMYK value of your skin before sharing updated 2023 nomenclature. Please download the app.