4 ms·
Can you name a company (or a part of a company that is a profit center, or even an indie developer). That makes it's money primarily from selling GPL software?
by jiggy2011 15y ago
Can you name a company (or a part of a company that is a profit center, or even an indie developer). That makes it's money primarily from selling GPL software?
Software that used to be sold commercially but was subsequently GPL'd , starving artist type programmers scraping by on donations (i.e earning significantly less than the median programmer salary for someone of their skills) or companies that produce GPL software but make money selling either support or software/hardware based around their GPL software (that itself is not GPL) don't count.
- burgerbrain 15y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3500373 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3500373 "don't count" Says you.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThey don't count because they are not selling software. They are selling something else and the software is essentially a byproduct. This means that there are categories of software where GPL does not really fit at all, games for example.
- rue 15y agoYou're technically correct, burgerbrain made a poor argument. GPL software is in no way a barrier to earning money. It's, in fact, crucial to most software today, even if indirectly.
- jiggy2011 15y agoNot sure I agree. Your correct that a huge amount of software today uses libraries that are distributed under some form of libre licensing although in most cases this is LGPL , BSD or Apache style licenses rather than GPL. Sure perhaps they run some stuff on a GNU/Linux server but in most cases this could just as easily be a BSD , Solaris or even Windows server. There are many types of software where GPL is absolutely a barrier , namely just about anything where the software is the end product. For example pretty much any video game or for example Adobe Photoshop/Illustrator. Some products simply don't lend themselves well to selling support , very few people are going to pay $1/min to get help running a program that is simple enough to figure out on their own from reading the manual and that should 99% of the time just install and run especially if it's not something mission critical that requires 6 nines uptime.
- rue 15y ago> Sure perhaps they run some stuff on a GNU/Linux server but in most cases this could just as easily be a BSD , Solaris or even Windows server. Could be, but isn't [1]. There's a bunch of embedded GPL code in routers and various little bits of all kinds of systems that enable our current lifestyle, too. I won't argue that for most (though not all) actual software intended to be sold, GPL probably isn't the best of ideas. But that doesn't prevent earning money while using GPL software. [1] And certainly hasn't. I won't overlook the historical effect GPL'd code has had.
- bmelton 15y agoWhy wouldn't they count? Companies that sell software generally have services divisions as well. My company sells software for large amounts of money, and we have a separate division of the company that sells services. If a company exists to make money, why would you discount one of their profit centers as invalid because of another of their profit centers?
- jiggy2011 15y agoMany software companies don't have service divisions, or have a service division that consists of people answering the phone and providing basic "talk you through the installation" type support. I assume that the software your company sells for large amounts of money is not GPL , if it is pure GPL I would be very interested to know who they are and how they manage to get people to actually pay for it when they could just download it for free online. If a company exists to make money, why would you discount one of their profit centers as invalid because of another of their profit centers? That's not what I'm saying, what I'm saying is that I've never seen a company create GPL software as a profit center in itself and I really can't think of a business plan that would make that feasible.
- bmelton 15y agoSourcefire does almost exactly that. Their software is open source and you can download and install it for free. They sell licenses and services, and you can pay for quicker updates to firewall rules and the like. As commercial customers, you can have their software engineers onsite tuning things to your environment, etc. Covalent is a company that sells Apache. Obviously, they didn't manufacture Apache webservers, but, like Xamp or Wamp, they sell value added bundles that include Apache configurations pre-compiled with PHP or Perl or what have you. Again, they also have a services division, but I don't personally know much about it. For the record, no, my company does not sell GPL software. It was proffered as an example that non-GPL-based companies rely on both software sales and services, and it doesn't really matter whether or not the software is GPLd. I don't know why you'd hold it against RedHat that their software is freely downloadable when they're still selling more than a few copies of RHEL.