4 ms·
In order of effectiveness: 1. Buy and hold broad index funds 2. Throw darts at a board to pick individual stocks 3. Be knowledgeable, do your own research, r
by paxys 4y ago
In order of effectiveness:
1. Buy and hold broad index funds
2. Throw darts at a board to pick individual stocks
3. Be knowledgeable, do your own research, read financial reports, custom build a portfolio
4. Listen to expert advice (Cramer, anti-Cramer and everything else)
- rom-antics 4y agoYou forgot: 0. Get elected to Congress
- peanuty1 4y ago0. Be Speaker of the House (Nancy Pelosi)
- mooman219 4y ago> If one were to have $100 million invested in the Speaker of the House's stock-picking abilities at the beginning of 2019, the same investment would compound to $192 million as of today, slightly off the November high, when the portfolio hit its peak of almost $309 million. Pelosi's strategy generated a negative year-to-date return of 36.04%, accompanied by a negative one-year return of 36.61%, both slightly underperforming the S&P 500 (SPY). - Q3 2022 I wanted to take a look at this because given stock trades are public you'd think there'd be an ETF to track trades for the speaker of the house, but in reality it seems like people wildly overstate the profitability of their winning trades and understate their losses because "slightly underperforming the S&P 500 (SPY)" doesn't make the same headlines. In the long term, they appear to be no better off than the average portfolio picker.
- airstrike 4y agoThe last time I looked into this, the information on trades by members of the congress is delayed. Something like we know in which quarter they traded but not on which exact day, so the ETF doesn't really track their returns
- red-iron-pine 4y agoThis is a group tracking congressional trades https://unusualwhales.com/politics https://unusualwhales.com/politics they track "usual whale" trades, large or weird trades, often by well known figures. Congress is an obvious and easy one to track. However, they're not required to disclose the trades in real-time, so following it closely may not really help and may hurt in the long run, as quick blips pops or runs fizzle out or revert as the market starts to react. IIRC there is a 3-day or more lag. And that's optional, I think there is a 30 day requirement?
- wrycoder 4y agoI heard of a politician who was somehow an expert on cattle futures.
- epgui 4y agoThe problem I have with #4 is that you're picking a false expert. The word "expert" is supposed to mean something. Experts are usually not the people that do television for a living. And with #3 above #4, you're essentially considering yourself as the top expert. Those should be flipped, and greater care taken to identify and qualify expertise.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y agoDistinguishing between a false expert vs a true expert is the same problem as picking a good stock vs a bad stock. There have been an unlimited number of studies done on the matter, and the overwhelming consensus is that professional stock pickers as a whole can be beaten by goldfish when it comes to making predictions.
- epgui 4y agoThe real experts are not the people making predictions about price movements. The real experts are usually making below-average salaries as postdoctorate fellows. I'm not sure that they're that hard to identify.
- kortilla 4y agoWhy would you believe that? A post doctoral fellow would have very little knowledge of the markets. Markets are not just random walks, there is edge to be gained with information and that information can be quite expensive to acquire and refine. A fellow would not have the resources to do that.
- berkle4455 4y ago> 1. Buy and hold broad index funds Until you realize we're entering uncharted territory as the index funds no longer represent external indices but a huge portion of money flows and are becoming feedback loops.
- twblalock 4y agoSo what? Index funds still ultimately own shares in a diverse portfolio of companies. That's why they were a good idea in the first place, and it's why they are still a good idea. If your argument is that this feedback loop is distorting the value of the companies index funds invest in, such distortion would impact anyone who buys stock in those companies whether or not they do it through index funds. Therefore, picking and choosing individual stocks doesn't become more attractive even if we know index funds distort the market, unless you only invest in stocks that are not owned by index funds -- good luck with that.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoSo buy into a mutual fund that's not traded?
- TheCondor 4y ago"Being on TV" != "being an expert" Especially in the world of finance, I don't think you can possibly go on TV, in good faith, and make any recommendation other than "hire and expert" or "invest long term." It's fundamentally too late of someone is telling you about it on TV; could be a great company to invest in but not short term.
- hristov 4y ago#3 should be the best if you are actually knowledgeable. The problem is a lot of people are basically fooling themselves into being knowledgeable. There is a lot of dumb randomness in stocks but over a longer term stock prices tend to somehow follow underlying economic realities. But, sadly, the stock market is a merciless test proctor. You may do all the work you think is necessary, you may research until the cows come home and you may still be wrong because you read things that were biased, you did not look at things in the proper perspective, there was some important discovery somewhere that changed the industry, geopolitics, etc. So even if you are planning on doing your own research you should be well diversified. Also, do not listen to experts! The stock market is one of the few fields where "experts" will intentionally try to mislead you. Always try to get primary material, or as close to primary material as possible. And do not fool yourself into thinking that reading a bunch of secondary expert articles, or listening to Cramer or other experts is doing research. That's like hoping to become a paleontologist by watching friends.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y agoPlenty of people with perfect knowledge and perfect analysis have gone bankrupt waiting for the market to act rationally.
- senttoschool 4y agoThis isn't always true. If every single stock investor bought index funds, investing in stocks would be pointless because it would not reward companies that perform better.
- paxys 4y ago> If every single stock investor bought index funds Well they don't, so why discuss meaningless hypotheticals? Yes this advice doesn't make sense in a world where there are no active funds, no wealth managers, where day trading doesn't exist, hedge funds all shut down, there are no quants, no HFT, no one trading derivatives...but until that happens I'm still telling the average person to buy index funds.
- senttoschool 4y agoI'm still telling the average person to buy index funds. Ok, I just wanted you to say this. Your original advice should only be applied to an "average" person.
- bern4444 4y agoIf every investor was buying only index funds, all it takes is one investor to find one stock that has great fundamentals and is undervalued relative to its performance. They will beat out the other investors on this one pick. Once someone starts winning and getting a better return the money flocks to them and away from the index funds. That then causes index funds to rebalance, which causes those investors looking for a better return to find other stocks, rinse and repeat. It will never be the case that everyone is investing only in index funds. It would be so easy to beat out everyone else in that scenario.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoTo this point, a fund, esp. a big one, isn't even trying to find that value -- they're looking to benchmark and spread money, not pan for gold. So in a lot of cases they'll miss out on those hidden gems. And, again, they're not in the hidden gem business, they're in the min-risk, capture broad gains business.