4 ms·
> They should just launch an installer The organization of Windows malware creators would like to thank you for your idea. /s. DEB is an archive format.
by hulitu 4y ago
> They should just launch an installer
The organization of Windows malware creators would like to thank you for your idea. /s.
DEB is an archive format.
- pxc 4y agoA bit more charitably: sometimes you might want to open up a DEB file and poke around in it in a system which is not Debian-based. AUR package authors do this on Arch, for example, as do the maintainers of the Nixpkgs entries for some proprietary software which is only distributed upstream as DEB files. So the Linux desktop ecosystem as a whole doesn't necessarily know ahead of time which way you want to use a DEB file. Of course, an archive manager which can detect whether you're on a Debian-based system or not, and appropriately choose whether or not to show you an 'install' button after opening the archive, is very much possible and would be quite nice.
- dmonitor 4y agoThat's kind of the point on .deb not being the best format for distributing packages. Having it be treated by the OS as both an archive format and an application is unnecessarily confusing. MacOS applications are secretly just folders, but most users don't even know that. It might be obvious to someone like you or I, but most people don't want to do more than just click the app and type their password to launch/install it. I have more than a handful of gripes about Windows, but I can at least say that clicking an .exe has a very clearly defined and understandable behavior.