3 ms·
I think they understood it better than they've given credit for. People don't remember the political climate at the time: 20 years ago, when the Euro was plann
by toyg 15y ago
I think they understood it better than they've given credit for.
People don't remember the political climate at the time: 20 years ago, when the Euro was planned and sanctioned, Germany was still divided, and West Germany was the top dog in economic terms among European countries (even more so than today) while most other countries (including France and UK) were fighting a recession. German public opinion didn't want to partake from the almighty Deutsche Mark, which was a rock in troubled seas (the British Pound was crashing, the French Franc was weak, the Italian Lira was losing 20% every 10 years, etc etc); French and Italian elites thought that a common currency would have allowed them to harness the German industrial strength, basically helping themselves to low interest rates they wouldn't have enjoyed otherwise.
The German establishment mostly saw the Euro as a straight-jacket, a burden to accept in order to bring about their own reunification, which otherwise would have been opposed across Europe (a reunited Germany would have been dangerously powerful on its own).
As it happens, it turned out better for them than for other members; this is why they keep insisting on a monetary approach to public policy that will keep others down, at least until this suites them.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoIn 1989 I did the backpack-across-Europe thing for the summer. The Berlin Wall was still up, the Soviets still in Eastern Europe, but just barely. Change was very much in the air. Everywhere I went, I'd ask people what they thought about the coming European Union. To a person, they were all cautiously supportive, but would also say "But I don't trust the Germans." Everyone expected the Germans would have designs on controlling the thing, and likely the ability to do it. Even the Germans seemed to expect it. These were the proverbial people on the street, so I'm guessing everyone pretty much knew how it was going to go in the long run.
- lispm 15y agoGermany has just 82 Million people. The EU has 500 million. That Germany dominates and even controls the EU is a myth.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThe USA has just 300 million people. The Earth has 7,000 million people. That the USA dominates the Earth is a myth.
- toyg 15y agoEveryone had designs on "controlling the thing", and the ability to do it: France had long set the EU agenda, BeNeLux and nordic countries were seen as the "reference implementation" for most processes, Spain was extremely aggressive in occupying key roles (Javier Solana, anyone?), even the UK was quite good (watering down ambitions of full political union, basically)... The real game-changer was the rushed enlargement. Now Germany can count on a political bloc of countries directly depending on the German economy, and for anyone else it's much more difficult to steer the boat with so many people on board.
- lispm 15y agoThe real game changer is that in many areas German policies worked better than others, especially in the current economic climate. Ten years ago this was open. Countries like Ireland were seen as 'Tigers'. The UK was adopting the service-oriented economy with a large banking sector boosted by North Sea oil and gas. Germany was struggling with the reunification. Now Germany has high debt, but was dealing with this problem years ago to keep in under control. More has to be done, but we are further than we thought. The industry is more competitive in terms of delivery capability, production technology and products. The decentral structure of the country enabled competition within the country - between Berlin, Munich, Stuttgart, Köln, Düsseldorf, Leipzig, Dresden, ... there is no such central structure like in France or the UK. Key was to keep employment high. Youth unemployment is very low. General unemployment is on a 20 year low. This kept people confident. Confident that they have enough to weather this economic crisis. Germans save more, they speculate less and many prefer renting instead of owning (and being in debt). There were some mistakes made (like some of the German banking system failed), but in general it looks okay.
- toyg 15y agoYes, but in terms of governance inside EU institutions this doesn't matter as much. If we had a situation were Germany was doing very well, but everyone else wanted to tweak the currency in a different way, it would go in a different way. As it is, thanks to the enlargement, on economic matters Germany can rely on a block of "faithful" countries whose self-interest is perennially aligned.