4 ms·
Whats wrong with R600a (isobutane)? It can provide heating/cooling suitable for nearly all usecases in homes, offices and retail (ie. -100C up to +150C). It i
by londons_explore 4y ago
Whats wrong with R600a (isobutane)?
It can provide heating/cooling suitable for nearly all usecases in homes, offices and retail (ie. -100C up to +150C).
It isn't awful for the environment if vented (no ozone depletion, greenhouse effect less bad than driving your car a few miles if you vent a fridge/freezer).
Yes, it is flammable... But in typical quantities in a fridge (perhaps 60 grams), it's hard to do too much damage.
It is also cheap, easy to lubricate, unpatented, made by many suppliers and efficient.
I really don't understand why anyone would want to use anything else....
- akira2501 4y agoEvery flammable refrigerant I've seen is usually in a completely sealed system. There is no way to maintain them unless you completely vent the system and add ports yourself, manufacturers don't seem to want the liability and many governments force the issue by code anyways.
- londons_explore 4y agoYou typically need to completely vent the system for any maintenance on a refrigeration system anyway, if only for the fact it is important to weigh the amount of refrigerant (too much and you could get slugging, which is very expensive to fix). I think lack of ports is simply to save money - in the factory it's just as easy to fill once and crimp the system closed.
- akira2501 4y ago> You typically need to completely vent the system for any maintenance on a refrigeration system anyway On residential/small systems where it's commonly used today, sure. For larger systems this is not true. You're typically going to have a receiver and a valve you can use to store the charge entirely in the receiver. Then you can work on the system without having to dump or capture that charge. It also allows you to have additional cooling circuits, so you're starting to see this incorporated into smaller commercial designs for the additional cooling efficiency. > I think lack of ports is simply to save money They're required to be hermetically sealed in the US by IEC and in most Pacific Island countries by law where they're more commonly used in residential applications.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoSave money, and force consumers to buy a new one when it breaks
- elil17 4y agoI'm not an expert in refrigerant selection but you've missed many critical aspects of a refrigerant: we care about viscosity, density, thermal conductivity, etc. because these all impact the energy efficiency of the system.
- zbrozek 4y agoSeveral light hydrocarbons seem like perfectly good alternatives. Propane is another one. And there's also quite a lot of use of ammonia for refrigeration as well. It's not clear to me why these simpler, non-chlorinated, non-fluorinated compounds are so grossly undesirable that we keep chasing more-complex alternatives. Is it really that people are simply horribly afraid of their flammability?
- SoftTalker 4y agoAmmonia is quite toxic. Some bad outcomes from leaky ammonia air conditioning in the past. Ok for industrial chillers with good leak detection systems.
- VLM 4y agoTexas state code requires machine rooms for ammonia systems to get 30 air exchanges per hour, same state building code requires houses to be under 1/3 air exchanges per hour. I'm a little fuzzy about the later, pretty sure about the former, and most people don't have the privilege of living in Texas (not sure if I'm kidding or not?), but it demonstrates the safety issue that ammonia cooling needs about a hundred times as much ventilation as a normal kitchen. And insert the usual quotes about building codes being written in blood so they aren't demanding a hundred times the ventilation just for fun.
- VLM 4y agoPeople are scared of the sealed container explosion. An external butane leak would be about as harmful as a leaking cig lighter. Internal leak? A perfect mixture of butane and air the size of fridge would certainly take out a wall, maybe an entire house if it knocks out a load bearing wall. The worst part about the internal explosion is its almost certain to happen when the owner is standing right in front and opens the door and the light kicks on along with maybe anti-frost heaters or whatever else is in there. I have seen some ideas proposed such as using the "smart" in a smart fridge for good not evil and locking the door if the system pressure drops below "X". Much more likely the "smart" in a smart fridge will never be permitted to be used for anything other than advertising and marketing, which is sad. Energy content of hydrocarbons is about the same (to one sig fig or less LOL) and just one gram of gasoline can blow a piston rod clean thru an engine block under perfectly bad conditions (already shattered bearings, etc) so a couple hundred grams under worst possible case in a confined sealed fridge could take out a house, most likely. (Edited to add: I have a better analogy: A perfect stochiometric mix of air and diesel the size of my coffee cup can blow the engine head clean off a diesel engine, IIRC that's how one of the brothers who invented the Diesel engine died in a lab accident a century ago. And that was just a little coffee cup sized engine cylinder. So imagine a sealed container the size of a fridge instead of a coffee cup... that'll take out a house for sure... neighbors will "probably" live but I wouldn't bet on it...)
- nigrioid 4y agoFlammable refrigerants are no joke: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A169-s4KHFQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A169-s4KHFQ
- amluto 4y agoFor better or for worse, people like to pump refrigerant through pipes in buildings, and flammability can be a problem. Also this requires a lot of refrigerant. One can separate the refrigeration part and the moving-heat-around part, though, by using good old H2O in pipes. Water is non-flammable, non-ozone-depleting, cheap, and has zero GWP. It can be a bit messy if a large amount spills indoors, though.