4 ms·
at some point this kind of luddism will become self-defeating; we can only hope that it doesn't engulf the whole human race this is banning the safest refriger
by kragen 4y ago
at some point this kind of luddism will become self-defeating; we can only hope that it doesn't engulf the whole human race
this is banning the safest refrigerants, forcing either a switch to dangerously inflammable refrigerants or to systems without refrigeration
- smt88 4y agoBanning harmful substances isn't luddism. What do you think luddism is? What is the harm of this ban?
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoYou know why these substances exist right? Because the prior substances were cutting a hole in the ozone layer. And at the time the new-then substances weren't proven bad yet. And those ozone eating substances themselves came about because the prior refrigerants were more flammable or poisonous and the then-new substances were not yet proven bad. It's an endless game of whack-a-mole.
- FourHand451 4y agoI don't think any of this is alarming. Nor a reason we should stop trying to solve new problems as we learn of them.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoI'd rather be exposed to the known-known of propane refrigeration in my consumer devices (car, window unit, refrigerator, mini-split, etc) than risk exposure poorly understood chemicals to reduce the chances of a refrigerant fire from one tiny decimal per capita per lifetime to a slightly smaller tiny decimal per capita per lifetime.
- mustacheemperor 4y agoIt sounds like an endless march of gradual forward progress, since each generation of refrigerants has been less destructive that the one before.
- kragen 4y agothe refrigerants that will still be allowed are literally the ones used in the very first vapor-compression refrigerators in the 19th century: blends of light alkanes, called 'chimogene' at the time; see us patent 87,084 from the year 01869 for example these (and sulfur dioxide) are what cfcs were invented to replace because they were dangerously inflammable if your 'endless march of gradual forward progress' ends up where it started after a century and a half of 'progress' i really question your definition of 'forward'
- slackdog 4y ago> You know why these substances exist right? Because the prior substances were cutting a hole in the ozone layer. Refrigeration may end up back where it originally started (before freon even), using ammonia. Ammonia is somewhat dangerous on a local level (you don't want an ammonia leak in your house..) but AFAIK it doesn't eat up ozone and the local hazard is something that can be mitigated with the right sort of product design.
- labcomputer 4y ago> Ammonia is somewhat dangerous on a local level Like saying that the Ohio train disaster may cause lung irritation, that quite undersells the problem. Ammonia refrigeration is inherently dangerous and has been banned from domestic refrigerators for a long time for good reason. Some regulations are written in blood.
- slackdog 4y agoI think it could be possible to use ammonia in domestic refrigerators safely if appropriate measures were taken. Particularly, require that refrigerators be installed with vent pipes leading from a tamper-resistant enclosure straight to the outside. Such vents would be similar to those used in waste plumbing to protect people from toxic sewer gasses like hydrogen sulfide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drain-waste-vent_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drain-waste-vent_system But jabl is probably right and something like propane would make more sense.
- jabl 4y agoI don't think we'll see ammonia used in domestic refrigeration. Industrial use, sure. I think what we'll see for domestic refrigerants (refrigerators, AC, heat pumps) is hydrocarbons like propane or butane (already a reality for refrigerators in most of the world), and in some cases CO2.
- kragen 4y agoi went to a hotel with an ammonia refrigerator in the kitchen a couple of weeks ago
- dymk 4y agoHow do you feel about leaded gas?
- nordsieck 4y ago> How do you feel about leaded gas? I think it should be banned. Sadly, aviation has enough political muscle that they're still allowed to use it. Which is amazing to me, given lead's extremely harmful effects.
- cypress66 4y agoDo you really think the people flying their small cessna with 100LL have so much political muscle? I strongly doubt so.
- jeffbee 4y agoIt's not the pilots alone, it is also the piece-of-shit-airplane industry which employs a handful of people here and there, enough to have a little suction in Congress.
- jabl 4y agoAlso GA is, in the end, a relatively small-scale activity, so leaded avgas isn't much of a public health hazard like leaded automotive gas was back in the day. More of an occupational hazard for people working on and flying those planes, and higher maintenance requirement on the engines. Hopefully they can manage to roll out G100UL at scale so 100LL can finally die. And then that final TEL plant on the planet can be shut down for good.
- r00fus 4y agoLet's not forget those small airports where nearby residents are at higher risk due to leaded avgas. That's why small airports have been forced to close. Get rid of leaded avgas and we can have less municipal airports closures.
- VLM 4y agoThe meta goal of greenwashing means you can't use Peltier coolers as it would take insane amounts of power to replace a condensing fridge, like dedicated circuit 15 amps. They're very inefficient... if you're burning coal. What if you're not burning coal? Consider this loophole... imagine a crappy anti-green energy wasting Peltier cooler connected to a solar panel. Half the day it chills down to -70C and then all night long it slowly warms up to -50C until sunrise. Probably the bottom quarter of the fridge is a giant ice block with fans blowing on it when the fridge above warms up, whereas the cooling is solar and below and is on full blast whenever the sun is up. Minor problem is now you're dumping 1500 watts of heat into your kitchen whenever the sun's up. Nice in the winter, not so much in the summer. And some idiot is going to gain access to the cold-sink to "chill their vodka" and end up with frostbite when they touch the -70C sink. And good luck periodically defrosting that beast. But, in general, its not an overly crazy idea.
- ilyt 4y agoNo, it is utterly terrible solution, as even the worst refrigerant beats peltier coolers.
- VLM 4y agoMy point is even the best refrigerant powered by coal or even "rando outlet power on average" is less green than the worst Peltier cooler powered by a solar panel. So as per OPs original claim that if we ban every chemical more hazardous than distilled water we can have no refrigeration is not entirely true, we can in theory redesign the entire system around not using any refrigerants. It would be an environmental disaster if not powered by solar, or maybe wind, of course, but it would technically work.
- ilyt 4y agoWell, no, coz you can use refrigerant like CO2 and that could be taken from atmosphere.
- kragen 4y agoi agree that tecs are a plausible solution for some applications, and i have in fact lived in a house with a small tec-driven refrigerator, but phase-change energy storage or tces are more viable solutions to the daily energy storage problem than the sensible-heat energy storage approach you suggest, among other things because the large ΔT you suggest would entail an absurdly large stack of tecs you can solve the waste heat problem by putting the tecs outside and running a coolant loop through the wall, filled with brine or propylene glycol; in the case of pces, the chilled coolant from the tecs freezes the ice inside your kitchen, in the ice reservoir which is used to cool the icebox tces systems (not to be confused with tecs) can be driven directly by solar heat rather than through pv however, i am not convinced that tecs are a viable alternative to vapor-compression refrigeration in general