7 ms·
PFAS ban affects most refrigerant blends
- loeg 4y agoDo the remaining alternatives work, and are they excessively expensive? > Laboratory test equipment and centrifuges would receive a 12-year exemption as no alternatives are currently available. Oh, so there are no remaining alternatives that work in these applications.
- kube-system 4y agoThere are a lot of alternatives that are cheap and perform well... but many of those have other safety concerns. Some common examples are hydrocarbons or ammonia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_refrigerant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_refrigerant
- spqr0a1 4y agoEthane (R-170) is a fine low-temperature refrigerant for lab equipment. The performance characteristics are at least as good as halocarbon refrigerants. The main drawback is flammability but propane has a similar concern and is already widely used in residential refrigerators and similar size systems.
- RobotToaster 4y agoFrom personal experience things using propane refrigerant seem to make a high pitched noise, I'm not sure if that's a property of the refrigerant or how devices using it are built.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoThere's no "reason" propane has to be louder but most propane refrigeration systems are used in industrial or cost-conscious applications where making the equipment quiet is less of a priority. When designing pumps it takes a non-trivial amount of engineering effort to ensure that the bulk of the noises emitted are above/below human hearing range.
- xxpor 4y ago>widely used in residential refrigerators and similar size systems. Not in the US (because of the flammability), unless something's changed very recently.
- jabl 4y agoUSA is kind of the exception. In much of the rest of the world, propane or butane are the norm in domestic refrigerators.
- xxpor 4y agoMost of the world doesn't build their residential buildings out of light wood frame :/
- scythe 4y agoA fuel-air explosion will not be contained by a reasonable amount of concrete or masonry. The real safety lesson is to control sources of ignition and prevent the buildup of released gases.
- slackdog 4y agoIf your house is on fire, you best GTFO no matter what kind of refrigerator you have. American homes have plenty of propane/natgas appliances anyway, so what difference does one more make?
- vondur 4y agoI've seen pentane used in small refrigerators in the US.
- jrimbault 4y agoMagnetic refrigeration seems (to a complete layman) to show promise. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_refrigeration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_refrigeration
- sargun 4y agoI for one, hope that someone figures out a way to make this cost effective. I think thermoacoustic coolers are another promising solution.
- hadlock 4y agoI remember reading about this in Popular Science in high school. Residential refrigerators powered by this technology by 2006! Twenty years after that magazine article I haven't seen any substantial progress towards a commercial product.
- scythe 4y agoThe problem with most alternative refrigerant technologies (magnetocaloric, electrocaloric, thermoelectric) is the same: the temperature deltas tend to be rather small, at best 25 C. That is roughly the thermal performance of the recently published "ionocaloric" cooling system; 20 C is very good for a magnetic system. For air conditioning, a delta of 25 C will just do (assuming outdoor temperature below 50 C!), but heat pumps may need to cross temperature gaps of 40 C or more.
- arsome 4y agoHydrocarbons work quite well and are (comparatively) minimal impact on climate change. There's been some paranoia about fires, particularly in automotive applications but it's actually a quite small amount needed to do the job.
- mschuster91 4y agoThe problem are large building air conditioning systems, grocery store chillers and industrial machines - they contain an awful lot of coolant and are very expensive to replace which means they tend to last for decades.
- throw_away1525 4y agoAmmonia (another dead simple molecule/process) is used in these services quite often, as far as I know.
- jabl 4y agoFrom what I understand, at least here in Europe CO2 has been common in recent supermarket and similar installations.
- amluto 4y agoOne can buy large building air conditioners that use water to move heat around. There will still be refrigerant somewhere in the system, but there won’t be long refrigerant pipes anywhere. I don’t know how popular these are. I have seen multiple condo buildings with a water source heat pump in each unit. The usual suspects (Mitsubishi, Daikin, etc) have hydronic systems with outdoor heat pumps on their websites. Chiltrix markets a small-building solution.
- rsync 4y agoWhy do centrifuges need refrigerant?
- kazinator 4y agoYou probably have to sometimes spin biological materials that have to be kept cool.
- rleigh 4y agoBecause they are temperature-controlled and contain a refrigeration unit. In biological and medical applications, you might want to have the samples kept cool for stability. You'll transfer them from a fridge or on ice into the cooled centrifuge and back again after you've spun it down. Since in these big units the rotor is often a big hunk of anodised aluminium, it also helps maintain temperature stability.
- empyrrhicist 4y agoWhile we were waiting for a contractor to replace our failing AC and furnace, he had to come back like four times to recharge the system (supply chain issues getting the new unit). Now I wonder how much refrigerant we were unintentionally breathing, and how much PFAS we were bio-accumulating during that time.
- ben7799 4y agoIf you read that article carefully you probably don't have PFAS in your system. It would have to have been replaced in the last 10 years to possibly have it. The older stuff had HFCs/CFCs but didn't have PFAS. I am in the same situation. My system has had to be recharged every 2 years or so but has not failed yet. Overall we're talking very small amounts leaked on mine.
- LazyMans 4y agoI wouldn't worry about it, these gasses are included in the blanket PFAS classification, but they are fundamentally different and thus non-toxic. r134a, a common refrigerant, and likely what your system uses if it's less than 10 years old, is used in inhalers.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> r132a, a common refrigerant Are you thinking R134A? IIRC, R132A theoretically exists but nobody makes it. And R134A is an automotive refrigerant. Most residential systems in the last 10 years likely use R410A (which is itself a mixture of R32 and R125). That is getting phased out and generally replaced with plain R32, as far as I know.
- martijnvds 4y agoR32 is also on its way out, and new units here in Europe tend to come with R290 (propane)
- rootusrootus 4y ago
- kragen 4y agoat some point this kind of luddism will become self-defeating; we can only hope that it doesn't engulf the whole human race this is banning the safest refrigerants, forcing either a switch to dangerously inflammable refrigerants or to systems without refrigeration
- smt88 4y agoBanning harmful substances isn't luddism. What do you think luddism is? What is the harm of this ban?
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoYou know why these substances exist right? Because the prior substances were cutting a hole in the ozone layer. And at the time the new-then substances weren't proven bad yet. And those ozone eating substances themselves came about because the prior refrigerants were more flammable or poisonous and the then-new substances were not yet proven bad. It's an endless game of whack-a-mole.
- FourHand451 4y agoI don't think any of this is alarming. Nor a reason we should stop trying to solve new problems as we learn of them.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoI'd rather be exposed to the known-known of propane refrigeration in my consumer devices (car, window unit, refrigerator, mini-split, etc) than risk exposure poorly understood chemicals to reduce the chances of a refrigerant fire from one tiny decimal per capita per lifetime to a slightly smaller tiny decimal per capita per lifetime.
- mustacheemperor 4y agoIt sounds like an endless march of gradual forward progress, since each generation of refrigerants has been less destructive that the one before.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- inportb 4y ago> R152a also falls outside the PFAS definition. Oh, so it might be possible to use the contents of "canned air" gas dusters as refrigerant.
- CamperBob2 4y agoYep. Turn one of those cans upside down and spray it, and you'll see how that works very quickly.
- iosono88 4y ago[dead]
- londons_explore 4y agoWhats wrong with R600a (isobutane)? It can provide heating/cooling suitable for nearly all usecases in homes, offices and retail (ie. -100C up to +150C). It isn't awful for the environment if vented (no ozone depletion, greenhouse effect less bad than driving your car a few miles if you vent a fridge/freezer). Yes, it is flammable... But in typical quantities in a fridge (perhaps 60 grams), it's hard to do too much damage. It is also cheap, easy to lubricate, unpatented, made by many suppliers and efficient. I really don't understand why anyone would want to use anything else....
- akira2501 4y agoEvery flammable refrigerant I've seen is usually in a completely sealed system. There is no way to maintain them unless you completely vent the system and add ports yourself, manufacturers don't seem to want the liability and many governments force the issue by code anyways.
- londons_explore 4y agoYou typically need to completely vent the system for any maintenance on a refrigeration system anyway, if only for the fact it is important to weigh the amount of refrigerant (too much and you could get slugging, which is very expensive to fix). I think lack of ports is simply to save money - in the factory it's just as easy to fill once and crimp the system closed.
- akira2501 4y ago> You typically need to completely vent the system for any maintenance on a refrigeration system anyway On residential/small systems where it's commonly used today, sure. For larger systems this is not true. You're typically going to have a receiver and a valve you can use to store the charge entirely in the receiver. Then you can work on the system without having to dump or capture that charge. It also allows you to have additional cooling circuits, so you're starting to see this incorporated into smaller commercial designs for the additional cooling efficiency. > I think lack of ports is simply to save money They're required to be hermetically sealed in the US by IEC and in most Pacific Island countries by law where they're more commonly used in residential applications.
- StillBored 4y agoIs it time to admit that maybe the problem with r22 and some of the other CFC's were that people were using them as propellants for hairspray/etc, as canned air, and any number of industrial processes (packing peanut manufacture) that was basically blowing it into the atmosphere and the lack of regulations requiring refrigeration units to be repaired/leakchecked before pumping more refrigerant into them? It seems pretty clear that the fairly short lived damage they cause to a renewable resource (ozone) would largly be a non issue given modern refrigerant regulations. While the advantages make them pretty much the best in any number of areas.
- TheJoeMan 4y agoYou are following the explanation for the bans as they are told. R134a was introduced in the 90's, and in 2010's it conveniently is named bad at the same time the patent runs out. So the savior was the 4x as expensive R1234yf, introduced 2012. Don't worry that it's flammable. Here we are 10 years after R1234yf, it's time to explain why it can't be used anymore!
- chicob 4y agoPFAS are harmful, both to the environment and humans, so the transition to safer alternatives is commendable. The fact that this ban seems to fit the specific blend of a particular company, however, casts some doubts on how this process was conducted. Specially in a time when demand is projected to increase considerably.