6 ms·
I'm a big proponent of retirement savings. I read Bogleheads, know the rules and limits around IRAs, 401(k)s, capital gains taxes, backdoor and mega-backdoor Ro
by ryandrake 4y ago
I'm a big proponent of retirement savings. I read Bogleheads, know the rules and limits around IRAs, 401(k)s, capital gains taxes, backdoor and mega-backdoor Roth, Roth 401(k)s, and so on. Not an expert by any means but squarely a retirement savings nerd. A lot of the problem is nobody in their 20s and 30s wants to hear about it. Even here on HN, when you bring the topic up, people's reactions range from "La la, I can't hear you!" to "Bro take that vacation and live in the moment, don't save for a day that might not come!" I think my highest-downvoted post ever here was something like "Maybe it's not financially wise to spend your 20s backpacking and finding yourself."
I know a lot of people in my age cohort who don't have even a dime saved up. And these are not the average struggling American like in the article. They're privileged well-to-do techies. They don't have the very critical "pay yourself first before paying your bills" mindset. I don't know what their plan is if they get critically sick to the point where they can't work, or when their health inevitably deteriorates in their old age. They just kind of shrug and say I'll cross that bridge when it comes. Trading in the Tesla is not going to pay for assisted living.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI don't think Bogleheads applies for the vast majority of americans. The article in question is about a 66-year-old single mother of three, working two jobs. She's most certainly not figuring out capital gains tax.
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoBogleheads isn't about capital gains tax. It's about steadily investing in a passive portfolio, dollar cost averaging in, and taking advantage of compounding returns. It's also about living frugally below your means, but not everyone wants that second part :)
- Retric 4y agoMany people don’t have a realistic option to live below their means. Not only do people make little money the US government literally kicks you off food stamps if you have 2,000$ in the bank.
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoIn society broadly, you're absolutely right. For most of the folks reading these comments, we do (though that's obviously changing given the downturn).
- sfhlihfdhcd 4y agoyou realize most audience here is first time emigrants who make much less than Americans on the same job and have zero network to navigate the intentionally opaque 401k et al hacks? not to mention most come from places with actual humane retirement and working law safeguards so they fail to negotiate a buffer for the complete lack of those in the us. so yeah, you're out of touch with both the topic in the article and the audience here.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoYeah, like I said, the article is about a 66-year-old single mother of three working two jobs to stay afloat. She already had to move in with two roomates because she can't afford otherwise. Let's not blind ourselves to our own privilege, lest we become "let them eat cake" people. Many Americans cannot afford to steadily invest in a passive portfolio and don't have a realistic avenue to live any more frugally than they already to to any meaningful, life-improving extent.
- mamonster 4y ago"Blind ourselves to our own privilege" I'm gonna be the asshole here, the article clearly states she adopted 3 children. Now because it isn't a particularly good article we don't know if maybe she adopted her nieces or nephew or whatever, but probably not(based on the video). That decision alone is a very big red flag that (coupled with the ominous "I have a live-for-now philosophy") that we are looking at a person that made some questionable decisions in her life.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoMaybe questionable decisions, maybe selfless decisions? I don't think we should judge her.
- Fauntleroy 4y agoGood intentions do not make up for negative outcomes.
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoThat depends on your values. I definitely know some people who have and would make a sacrifice like "Adopt 3 people and potentially change their life outcome for the positive, at my own personal expense"
- RickJWagner 4y agoBogleheads teaches financial responsibility from step 1. It is the right path for everybody, but not everybody finds it or wants to learn.
- elijaht 4y agoI agree. I had a friend who told me that he had to spent less in months when my companies stock was down, because he was literally using his base + equity in full nearly every month. He also told me he hadn't opened a 401k. He is in his early 30s working in tech and just his base would facilitate a comfortable lifestyle. It really shocked me
- malka 4y agogiven the likely state of the world when I'll be old, i'd rather enjoy my money now.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThis is fine, but the problem is most people who think this then vote for wealth transfers from working to non working once they need help.
- 29083011397778 4y agoYeah, that nuclear winter when Russia launches nukes isn't much of a retirement, and savings won't help much unless you saved in non-perishable canned goods. Actually, wait. Sorry, that was the reason the previous generation didn't bother to save.
- malka 4y agoMine is more related to climate change.
- option 4y ago“ what their plan is if they get critically sick to the point where they can't work, or when their health inevitably deteriorates in their old age” best case scenario plan - become a financial burden to their children and family. most likely plan - become a financial burden to society.
- LatteLazy 4y agoWhen inflation > interest rates, saving is a loss making activity. That's the environment we've been in from 2008 until about 2022. You're not wrong and I am the same as you, but we can't blame people for adapting to their circumstances...
- lotsofpulp 4y agoRetirement savings means investments, not FDIC insured savings accounts. However, it has not been that long that it has been as easy as opening a Vanguard/Fidelity/Schwab account and buying an index ETF or target retirement date ETF, so I cannot blame someone in their 50s and 60s today for not following advice that has only been easily accessible for 15 or 20 years.
- cykros 4y agoThis. Also, we take 401(k)'s for granted, but even those are only a little more than 40 years old, and widespread use did not happen instantly. That Gen X didn't make hefty use of them is hardly surprising, given the limited access along with the limited education in place. Their parents had defined benefits pensions. Their children have commission free IRA's, 401(k)'s, variable annuities, and a handful of other lesser known alternatives. They got the 70s and 80s economies to grow up in, and the dot com bubble, GFC, and now a looming recession after many got sucked into some YOLO moonshot plays in the bull market of 2021, upon realizing how much ground they needed to try to make up rapidly. I don't envy their situation.
- rhacker 4y agoIf you have non-mortgage debt, it makes no sense saving (unless you're just saving for a temporary large purchase like a house).
- cykros 4y agoThat depends if it's fixed rate debt or not. Fixed rate debt that came about over the last decade is often accruing interest at a lower rate than you can reasonably get with some fairly safe instruments, be they treasuries, money markets, or some more exotic fixed income securities. If you're paying down debt financed at 5% and getting a 7% return on your savings, it's a non-trivial decision to pay it down any faster than you absolutely have to. I'm sure in no rush to pay down my car loan any quicker than is required.
- SkyPuncher 4y ago> I think my highest-downvoted post ever here was something like "Maybe it's not financially wise to spend your 20s backpacking and finding yourself." People backpacking know this, so it pretty much falls on deaf ears. I've also found these types of people tend to live an incredibly frugal lifestyle. Saving in their 30's becomes far easier because they tend to not have the lifestyle bloat. While their overall income will be lower, they need less to retire and generally seem to remain surprisingly financially independent.
- settrans 4y agoI _thought_ I knew a lot about capital gains taxes until filing my own taxes this year. After firmly boarding the tax-loss harvesting hype train, I had fallen prey to the intuitively appealing idea that short-term capital losses could offset gains from the sale of a rental property held for less than one year. It turns out that short-term gains from the sale of business property flow (Form 4797) directly to your Schedule 1, without an opportunity for Schedule D losses to offset them. Now as a result I'm sitting on a 5-figure tax bill and 6-figure capital loss carryforward.
- sfhlihfdhcd 4y agoand you just learned laws that are overly complicated are there exactly for that! so it's working perfectly as intended. sucks to be you though.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe intention is to prevent commingling of business gains/losses with personal gains/losses. I see no reason to assume bad intentions. https://www.realized1031.com/blog/what-is-the-difference-between-a-schedule-d-and-form-4797 https://www.realized1031.com/blog/what-is-the-difference-bet...
- l3mure 4y agothat's some good schadenfreude, thanks
- dennis_jeeves1 4y agoMy heartfelt sympathies...
- mfer 4y agoThe way people handle money is a cultural problem. Not only is it a lack of savings, many people have a lot of debt that's growing. The way many view money is to spend more than they take in. Driven by consumerism. Consider how often people see ads trying to influence them to spend. They work and it's shaping our culture.
- malka 4y agoI intend to die covered in debts.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhat kind of debt would you be able to obtain?
- drewcoo 4y agoIt's a social problem. And how do we deal with social problems in the US? Tell people they need more individual responsibility.
- falcolas 4y agoSo, perhaps the problem is that proper retirement planning requires you to "know the rules and limits around IRAs, 401(k)s, capital gains taxes, backdoor and mega-backdoor Roth, Roth 401(k)s, and so on", which is beyond most folks ability - or available time. It also requires a non-trivial amount of slack between your income and expenses, especially if you want to invest enough to beat inflation for your savings period and up to 35 years after. The value of $1 in 1985 (~35 years ago) is equivalent to $2.78 now. With as many folks as are living paycheck to paycheck (and usually they aren't backpacking), not having that slack - or time to manage that slack "properly - is not really all that surprising. I also feel it's worth calling out that the fact that your target cohort is 20-something backpackers shows a cognitive bias on who is actually having issues with their retirement funds. The reality is that most folks who are having issues right now are older Gen X, not young Gen Z.
- salawat 4y ago"Retirement" amounts to giving up control of your Capital to a bunch of companies, who may perpetuate God knows what in terms of social ills as a business model. In short; companies have found a way to screw workers out of even their wages by convincing us that "we have to invest in them to make our living for later". When you realize that the entire system is basically set up so that as an employer, you're siphoning off funds from your employees for witholding that by default are conservatively invested (read: in whoever has managed to become the too big to fail company from convincing institutional investors to foot the bill)... Ot really starts to make a bit more sense why sweeping change has a hard time happening except in tech circles.
- cykros 4y agoThis concern is why ESG investing has picked up, though personally I'd call that more of an opportunistic way to convince people they can have their cake and eat it too (and take a nice fat cut of the profit in the meantime), given how much of this trend has been characterized by gaming scores, rather than a renaissance of people actually digging into the companies they invest in to ensure their money is doing good in the world. I don't have a great solution to apply to the masses. Personally I enjoy researching my investments, but am well aware people don't all feel this way. Not investing for the future, however, feels like rather than finding a solution, it is just the "throwing one's hands up in the air and giving up" option. And the results are, well, what you might expect. Perhaps the best solution is for people to find what DOES interest them to invest in. The options aren't limited to company stocks, or real estate, debt, or even commodities. A larger and larger portion of the market has been opening up to retail investors with increasingly minimal costs. Perhaps no solace to the 50+ crowd that hasn't started yet, but at least hope for younger generations to have better options to avoid the same fate.
- cykros 4y agoAlso, for what it's worth, money in the bank = that bank having more bank reserves = that bank effectively having greater leverage to do gods know what with. If your goal is not to give anyone else your capital to do anything with, you'd better at least have it in hard cash, if not outright hard commodities. Otherwise, don't fool yourself into getting a smaller return while still doing what you thought you were avoiding.
- fdye 4y agoOn a similar note, I know >3 individuals with successful businesses, think small construction shop or solo professional suite. They make good money, but everyone I've talked to doesn't have an IRA/401K or anything stashed, its all in their business. They have lots of cashflow, but are an injury, change in business climate away from ruin. Many don't have plans for hitting 60+ when they can't work anymore to keep the business going. They likely assume they will sell their business, but lately the valuations on these small time shops has been very low and many "boomer" businesses are having a hard time finding people interested in purchasing. Think mom/pop grocery store, ice cream shop, stationary store, etc. They own their home most likely, but thats all gonna get sucked in end of life care...
- beej71 4y agoThere's another group of people like me who _hates_ dealing with retirement shit. It's not that I don't feel it's important--I do. It's that the entire infrastructure for dealing with 401Ks and retirement, I think, sucks. Moving money from one place to another is terrifying--so many different steps along with the fear you'll accidentally pull the money "out" and have to pay taxes and penalties on it... I can hear everyone saying, "It's easy--I had no problem with it". So it's not rational. But I'll bet I'm not alone. (For the record, I'm doing OK in the retirement department. Well above average for my age and well-well-well above median. I still goddamn hate it. I'd rather have paid more tax in exchange for more Social Security payout any day.)
- RickJWagner 4y agoBogleheads. This is the way.