4 ms·

Do you know that all the scientists referee for these journals for free ?

• ripap 4y ago
  I don't think this is true in general. Certainly, they aren't paid by the publisher, but I'd imagine most referees are in paid employment with institutions that expect them to review the occasional manuscript as part of their job.
  • sega_sai 4y ago
    Nowhere in my contract or in anyone else's contract (as far as I know) it is written that I need to referee papers. People do it as a service to the community. And I don't necessarily ask to be payed for that, I was just answering the point about "I want everything to be free all the time and never pay for anything". We pay with our work to referee the papers. Sure there are extra costs to host the papers, typeset, but they should be nowhere near 2.5k GBP per paper.
    • ripap 4y ago
      Academic jobs are weird, right? I think trying to write down contract that specifies everything involved would be pretty challenging. At any rate, the last time I was employed as astrophysics faculty, my offer letter told me that I should “engage in scholarly activities”. I certainly interpreted that as an invitation to review the odd paper on the university's dime.