Still sounds like your opinion vs his. That's not "failing" that's at most "it doesn't work for me", but without explaining why it doesn't work for you, it rea

Still sounds like your opinion vs his. That's not "failing" that's at most "it doesn't work for me", but without explaining why it doesn't work for you, it really is little more than a wild claim. I've had great success with "Clean code" practices. Though I implement it more according to Alistair Cockburns' "Hexagonal Architecture", it's overall very similar and strives for the same goals using the same methods. So in that sense, N=1 it hasn't failed. It has helped at least one person.