3 ms·
This is fine to do while we are still talking about space missions and quick landings, but the moment there is a base and people start to live there semi-perman
by paxys 4y ago
This is fine to do while we are still talking about space missions and quick landings, but the moment there is a base and people start to live there semi-permanently you won't be able to just pin it to UTC and call it a day.
Timezones are already bad enough in software. Having to additionally account for the moon would make people quit the profession.
- kube-system 4y ago> you won't be able to just pin it to UTC and call it a day. Yeah you’d have to call it 29.5 days. But joking aside, people live on ISS and use UTC despite their 90 minute “days”. What we should really do is just get rid of all this crap and go with metric time that starts at an arbitrary moment and isn’t dependent on location.
- newaccount74 4y agoHow about 1000 ".beats" per day? Swatch tried that, but it didn't catch on.
- kube-system 4y agoA “day” is a terrible horrible no good very bad unit. Units should be constant! https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Deviation_of_day_length_from_SI_day.svg#mw-jump-to-license https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Deviation_of_day_l...
- wkat4242 4y agoThe deviation is a couple of milliseconds :) Bad for scientists, not noticeable for normal life. Science could have its own standard?
- downvotetruth 4y agoUnits cannot be constant due to measurement imprecision. Units preferably would be defined such that the imprecision is minimized.
- wolverine876 4y ago> What we should really do is just get rid of all this crap and go with metric time that starts at an arbitrary moment and isn’t dependent on location. What do you do about relativistic effects which cause time to move at different rates in different places, including on the Moon. From TFA: > Clocks run faster on the moon than on Earth, gaining about 56 microseconds each day, the space agency said. Further complicating matters, ticking occurs differently on the lunar surface than in lunar orbit.
- BerislavLopac 4y agoHow is that even possible? Does cesium have a different frequency there?
- ssivark 4y agoYes — relativistic effects are so fundamental that they affect every system/process (including atomic clocks ) and therefore any measurement scheme. That’s why we talk about “time slowing down”. The movie Interstellar has one popular depiction of this.
- Beldin 4y agoLunar gravity is about 1/6th of Earth gravity. Clocks slow down due to gravity (Einstein's relativity). Thus, clocks tick faster if there's less gravity. Aside: we can measure this effect on Earth, between the foot and top of a mountain. Tom Scott has a video about exactly that.
- Scarblac 4y agoRelativity, different gravity well. Cesium is the same, actual time is different.
- slow_typist 4y agoIt does. Not for the observer on the moon, but on the earth. Hafele-Keating experiment: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hafele–Keating_experiment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hafele–Keating_experiment
- 4y ago
- OscarCunningham 4y agoPeople living on the Moon will need artificial lighting since the days there are 29.5 Earth days. The real issue will be Mars since their days are approximately the same as Earth.
- q7xvh97o2pDhNrh 4y ago> Having to additionally account for the moon would make people quit the profession. ...and it will make other engineers rich when they dive into the complexity, wrap a clean API around it, and start a lucrative time-as-a-service company.
- 015a 4y agoI think a more interesting argument is: Humans are 24-hour creatures (ok, maybe not precisely 24 hours, but close enough). That's how our internal clocks are wired. Its not nurture; its nature; and it would take generations living day-in day-out with a different cadence before we see biological adjustments. Sure, our clocks are 24-hours-a-day because that syncs up well with the rotation of the earth. That's the scientists' argument, and it isn't why we use a 24 hour clock. The real reason is because it syncs up well with our biology. Its hard to imagine a world where these two things aren't synced up, but we're headed to some soon, and its likely that any clock which doesn't sync up to our biology (TimeAwake + TimeAsleep = 1 Day = 86400 seconds) will be rejected by anyone who isn't ordered by their commanding officer to use it. Its like... just use UTC. Be done with it. The argument that "its an Earth Time, and we're Interplanetary now" feels like its coming from a sci-fi fan-fiction writer obsessed with The Expanse and solving problems before they exist. The most important priority for any timekeeping system is that its Useful. The second highest priority is that its Scientifically or Mathematically Beautiful, and this second priority is so far below the first one that we invented timezones and daylight savings time and everyone who has ever had to think critically about either of these things wants to jump off a fucking bridge but we tolerate it because they're Useful (and, we're getting rid of DST, because we've recognized that its Not So Useful, again, Usefulness drives everything). Here's what's going to happen: they'll invent some kind of new Lunar Time with 29.35 earth-day long days or some other nonsense. Every clock on the wall at Moonbase Alpha will have both Lunar Time and UTC and probably US Central Time because Houston & NASA. The scientists who invent it will pat themselves on the back. The janitors who clean the place will have their shifts scheduled in UTC hours and the Gregorian calendar ("yeah man I'm off at 8pm and I don't work again till Monday, yeah I guess it is weird that its been night outside for two weeks yet we still say 'monDAY', I don't know man I just work here same as you let's grab some drinks"). In 350 years, the Martian Humans will declare independence and reject all forms of Timekeeping that Us Earthlings invented, including the one the ESA (hint: EUROPEAN space agency) tried to invent for them, because Politics. Can we just, I don't know, focus on GETTING to the moon first, before we start paying people to retrofit our microwaves with new clocks?
- DiscourseFan 4y agoIdk we're planning these missions in the near/immediate future, so we need standardized times for those immediately future missions. Everything else comes later.