4 ms·
Is this even all that unusual? Certainly mechanical issues occur sometimes that require a plane to land again shortly after taking off. Given that the plane w
by kelnos 4y ago
Is this even all that unusual? Certainly mechanical issues occur sometimes that require a plane to land again shortly after taking off. Given that the plane went back into service 14 hours later, it seems unlikely that it was a software problem (similar to the MAX issues over the past few years), no?
I'd of course be curious to read more details and an explanation of the root cause, but it's presumably too soon for that...
- SoftTalker 4y agoIf you read AvHerald you’ll see that worldwide there are half a dozen mechanical incidents on various commercial aircraft every day.
- cm2187 4y agoMechanical incidents is one thing, but is it also the case of pilots declaring an emergency? [edit] though it looks like they declared an emergency out of an abundance of caution
- sokoloff 4y agoDeclaring an emergency is, oddly, fairly routine. There are surely dozens each day. (I’ve declared three in a little over 1500 hours of flying piston aircraft.) When you have an abnormal condition that gives you doubt about the aircraft state and priority ATC handling would be helpful, declare an emergency. It’s as simple as that.
- bombcar 4y agoYep. Emergency isn’t the “we’re all going to die” it’s “something is not right and we’re deviating from the flight plan and need priority”. https://www.flightradar24.com/blog/squawking-7700-in-flight-emergencies-from-a-pilots-perspective/ https://www.flightradar24.com/blog/squawking-7700-in-flight-... Closest I ever got was 7600 for a full radio stack loss.
- inferiorhuman 4y agoThis was the first revenue flight for that plane. Inappropriate? Yes. Unusual? Not for Boeing. The US Air Force stopped taking deliveries of the KC-46 for a period of time because of sloppy assembly (FOD). One of the ME3 airlines stopped taking delivery of 787s built at the east coast plant because of FOD and other sloppy assembly problems (and Boeing's had to stop delivery a few times on the 787 because of assembly/manufacturing problems). Boeing got into a bit of hot water with the 737NG because they were hand building parts that were supposed to be CNC'd. Stuff like that. One of the key problems that I vaguely remember is that Boeing did away with a lot of the manual quality control checks in favor of automated checks with no oversight. As Tesla's learned some things are extremely difficult to automate.
- userbinator 4y agoFor those not familiar with the acronym FOD: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_object_damage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_object_damage
- salawat 4y agoAutomated checks no one is actually looking at may as well not even be happening.
- inferiorhuman 4y agohttps://fodprevention.com/boeing-overhauls-quality-controls-good-or-bad-for-fod/ https://fodprevention.com/boeing-overhauls-quality-controls-... https://www.heraldnet.com/business/boeing-revamps-quality-control-more-high-tech-fewer-humans/ https://www.heraldnet.com/business/boeing-revamps-quality-co... https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2006/04/17/boeing-parts-and-rules-bent-whistle-blowers-say/5f4e0e7d-9f0a-44b8-afe5-6c90dfd82229/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2006/04/17/b...
- salawat 4y agoDoesn't change my point. In fact, reinforces it. You must check. How do you know the device is calibrated? Is the sensor you're relying on still trust worthy? What happens when your fancy Bluetooth sensor breaks, and you've forgotten how to measure things the old fashioned way? Now I'm glad Boeing is taking inspiration from Toyota; but American companies tend to lose sight of a key part of the teachings of Demmings: just do it right the first time is wrong. You must build your business around the assumption it will be wrong, (because it always will be), and generate data to be reviewed that can be acted upon to improve processes. Besides which; remember, the real objective there is cost savings by Quality department downsizing, coupled with remaining Quality Inspector upskilling, which comes with increased cognitive overhead for the inspector, which will manifest in a lower detection rate because you can only be in so many places at once. T. Decade-on Quality Assurance guy/builder of testing departments. Companies hate us because we're the one group in the building who can objectively measure how badly everything sucks; yet you can't let up, no matter how badly you're treated because once you stop looking, someone down the line'll pay for it. And that's just not Quality.
- landemva 4y ago737MAX has a design problem that attempted to use software to cover it up. Boeing stuffed in big fans which needed to be higher to not scrape the runway. The fans stick out forward from the wings, which can cause the plane to pitch up. Software attempts to hide that design flaw, and pushed down really hard a couple times into the ground. Really needs a new type certification, though FAA and flying public generally don't seem to care.
- nickff 4y agoWhat do the issues you mention have to do with this specific airplane?
- rob74 4y agoThe MCAS also adjusts the horizontal stabilizer, same as the trim system. So I assume if pilots see problems with the trim system on a 737 MAX, they get even more alarmed then they would on other planes...
- throwawayben 4y agoDifferent handling at the edge of the flight envelope is not a "design problem". The design is fine, it just handles differently from the other versions in certain regimes so they (attempted, poorly) used software to avoid that
- cjbprime 4y agoMy understanding is that it was failing an airworthiness requirement without MCAS: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/25.175 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/25.175 If by "different handling" we mean "not airworthy", I wouldn't say the design is fine.
- throwawayben 4y agoI believe that is false, as MCAS should (when correctly implemented) only apply at the edge of the flight envelope and those airworthiness requirements are all related to normal regimes. I can't find anything supporting your understanding
- rob74 4y ago"no autopilot trim and no electrical trim" doesn't sound like a mechanical issue to me, but the underlying issue certainly could be. Of course, things like this do occur, but you would think that on a newly delivered plane that passed Boeing's QC, this wouldn't happen. And, as a pilot, if you see these issues you probably start wondering what else might be wrong. After all, one of the most pointless and horrifying aircraft accidents in recent years (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Airlines_Flight_261 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Airlines_Flight_261) also initially looked like a trim issue. Not to mention the two 737-MAX crashes of course, where it was also ultimately the horizontal stabilizer trim that flew the planes into the ground.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe lesson is, if you have a trim issue, turn it off and land.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm wondering how it passed preflight. Isn't the trim tested?
- vultour 4y agoI don't think it's tested explicitly, but you usually need to trim the aircraft for takeoff.
- bombcar 4y agoYou test the range of motion preflight but you can’t test the results of said motion without actual airflow over the stabilizer.
- WalterBright 4y agoUm, if the stabilizer moves, it works. No need to test airflow.
- bombcar 4y agoYou can get a trim tab that "works" but doesn't "stay" in position (one of the walk-around checks on a small plane it to set the trim max in one direction, make sure it moves correctly when you move the stabilator, set in the other direction, recheck) but you can't reach them on a large jet. There have been cases where the ONLY thing working on the tail was the trim tab, the yoke cables broke - you can land a plane with only the trim if you really need to.
- WalterBright 4y agoOn a jet there should be an indicator of the trim position that is independent of the actuator mechanism.