3 ms·
...it's not a true representation of reality to suggest that taking $84 million out of the bank will result in the cancellation of $84 million in business loans
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
...it's not a true representation of reality to suggest that taking $84 million out of the bank will result in the cancellation of $84 million in business loans...
Again, the issue is spending, not loans. Consider two possible uses for the money:
a) You can hire a programmer to do maintenance on the welfare administration system.
b) You can hire a programmer to build Fred Wilson's new venture.
By taxing the money, you devote it to welfare admin apps. By leaving it untaxed, you devote that programmer's labor to Fred Wilson's venture.
The relevant question: is purpose a) or b) a more valuable use of that programmer's labor?
- notahacker 15y agoMy point is that contrary to intuition debiting (and spending) $84 million from a bank account or invested in the stock market doesn't necessarily correspond to an $84 million short term decrease in the spending power of companies spending revenues generated by borrowing from that bank or floating on that market. Because of the amount of credit in the system, that $84 million can be simultaneously spent by many people anyway; the government joining the spending party might crowd out rather less or rather more private sector investment expenditure than they collect through tax revenues. The only certain loser is the rich person.