10 ms·
I don't get this article -- I do a lot of academic research and love online materials. When I have to access a book that is physical only, half an entire aftern
by crazygringo 4y ago
I don't get this article -- I do a lot of academic research and love online materials. When I have to access a book that is physical only, half an entire afternoon gets wasted. Online books are orders of magnitude faster to get, to search within, and you can highlight and annotate to your heart's delight.
Everyone agrees rare books and manuscripts need to be kept, which the article admits, so that's not an issue.
So ultimately the question is "regular books" and the crux of the article's argument seems to be:
> One glaring problem with libraries’ increasing their reliance on digital texts is the relatively large number of errors in the Google Books corpus. As archivist Paul Conway has shown, “the imperfection of digital surrogates is an obvious and nearly ubiquitous feature of Google Books.” But, even overlooking the outright errors in the scanned pages, my point is that “content”—what books contain—goes far beyond words in a particular order and beyond page images of a single representative copy. As we detach texts from books, we enable a certain range of procedures while disabling others. Online editions can offer up texts for investigation and discovery, but they are not replacements for the material they represent.
This makes no sense to me. I've never seen an "error" in a Google Books page image. The OCR for sure, but who cares, and that can always be redone. And in terms of "enabling a certain range of procedures while disabling others", online enables a ton, while I'm at a total loss of what is "disabled". Again -- for rare books and manuscripts, of course. A beautiful gilt binding, absolutely. But for just your everyday workhorse books that make up 99+% of a library's content... I just totally and utterly fail to see anything being lost at all. (And so many original covers/bindings are replaced with generic library covers/bindings when acquired, so it's not even that.)
- ravagat 4y agoI agree that the article lacked structure. I'm curious do you still do research at your local libraries? As in physically go out to the library even if you're still using online/digital materials there.
- duskwuff 4y ago> The OCR for sure, but who cares, and that can always be redone. And that's only an issue at all for books which were scanned from print copies. Books which were uploaded in digital formats by the publisher won't have that issue.
- xen2xen1 4y agoAnd with the GPTs of the world, OCR is a vanishing issue.
- mdp2021 4y agoYou know an OCR with a Statistical Language Model acting as text plausibility checker?
- hewlett 4y agoThey probably mean the use of GPTs to correct OCR errors
- mdp2021 4y agoThat is what I meant. But you have to integrate the subsystems properly, and I am not aware of an engine that does it.
- xen2xen1 4y agoIndeed, that is part assumption on my part the OCR will get better with a GPT like setup, but, as I said on another comment, I have trouble believing OCR won't be one of the better applications, as "is this an A" is much more straightforward than most of what GPTs have been doing.
- Spooky23 4y agoYes, instead of technical limitations of OCR, we’ll have inscrutable language models making up random shit, and people too lazy to look at the primary source material.
- onecommentman 4y agoI foresee a day when the expectation for any peer-reviewed article in a major journal will be to provide proof that every citation was validated against a physical copy of the material cited, not just an online version of the citation. Give the grad students something useful to do…get a free flight to the appropriate physical repository, tour around the campus, meet some friends…
- DemocracyFTW2 4y agoStoring books digitally may make them more available in the present, but it will also likely mean that they're be less available at some point in the future. Physical libraries with physical books have proven they can last for centuries, sometimes for millennia. For all we know, none of our digital storage media lasts significantly longer than decades, and even to pull that off, you have to constantly invest in copying and duplicating your data. Hard drives of the seventies, floppy disks, countless numbers of tape formats, CDs have all gone obsolete or are in the process of getting obsolete and are only accessible with dedicated hardware that would be very expensive to replicate from scratch, if even possible. A book does not have to be decoded to be read; even microfilm is more secure than an SSD or spinning HD when it comes to readability in the future in a low-tech / no-tech / replicated tech scenario. When the grid comes down, tap water will become scarce and digital written literature will just vanish.
- bell-cot 4y agoTHIS. Ask a real historian or research librarian about all the really important books that we know existed, but do not have, because there was no Devout Brothers of Document Preservation faithfully maintaining copies of them through the centuries.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y ago> Storing books digitally may make them more available in the present, but it will also likely mean that they're be less available at some point in the future. Physical libraries with physical books have proven they can last for centuries, sometimes for millennia. I don’t k kw about paper books lasting millennia. If you want to preserve books for millennia, you should carve them onto clay tablets and then bake them. The resulting baked clay tablets are pretty durable, even compared to the best paper.
- crazygringo 4y agoFirst of all, this is what the Library of Congress is for. Sure it's not a bad idea to have one library with physical copies, or maybe even 2–3 or even 10, but we don't need thousands of them. But second, no, physical libraries generally don't last for centuries and certainly almost never for millenia. They get sold off, torn down, they burn down, and so on. On the other hand, you can keep an entire copy of Library Genesis on a home computer if you want. The sheer number of digital copies means none of this is going anywhere. And if the grid goes down and society is collapsing, then a collection of a good proportion of the world's books on your hard drive powered by a generator or solar is going to be infinitely more valuable than some physical library you have to hike for days to get to with a chance that raiders will kill you on the way. ;)
- JohnFen 4y ago> I just totally and utterly fail to see anything being lost at all. It sounds like you don't find ordinary physical books to be valuable. I am of the opposite opinion. Having them digitized and available online is a good thing, but losing access to the physical copies is a real loss to a number of people. The two primary things I can think of at the moment are... People who don't have access to the internet or have machines on which they can read electronic books. There are lots of such people. People who find that reading a physical book is simply a better reading experience than reading on the screen. I am one of those. Reading on a computer or tablet is fine for consulting reference material, but if I want to actually read, quite a lot is lost by reading it on the screen. I've tried reading on screens, and it's just so uncomfortable that I can't do it and be happy about it. Which means that if I didn't have a physical copy, I'd probably just not read the book.
- crazygringo 4y agoIt's always going to be cheaper for a library to lend internet/devices for reading than maintain a large physical collection for lending books. And then there's print-on-demand. You don't need a library for that. That's awesome that you personally love reading on a physical page, but that's not a reason to warehouse hundreds of millions of physical books that get checked out once a decade.
- JohnFen 4y agoWell, I'm hardly alone in my preferences, but my point was to answer the question "what is being lost". I gave two examples of real things that are being lost. That loss may or may not be economically required -- but it's still a loss either way. > It's always going to be cheaper for a library to lend internet/devices for reading The economics of this may differ depending on where you are, but I'm 99% sure that this isn't the case where I am.
- crazygringo 4y agoVirtually everwhere has cheap enough mobile data in 2023 to read books with, so internet is not an issue. And I think you may be severly underestimating the cost of maintaining library-sized collections of books, in labor and utilities and maintenance and real estate. Consumer digital devices, especially things like e-ink readers, cost almost nothing compared to that.
- bombcar 4y agoThere are two types of research. There's the "academic" style where you know what you want and you want to get it, where online materials shine. Then there's the "browsing" type of research where you have an idea of what you want, and you go to a book on that, and you look at the books around it on the shelves; that's something you get from a library (or bookstore) that doesn't really happen online.
- crazygringo 4y agoIt's trivial to browse titles online if there's an interface for it. In fact, I find browsing related titles on Amazon to be a tremendously quicker way to find related books than organzed by Dewey Decimal or similar at a library -- because collaborative recommendations, number of reviews, and actual review content are such strong signals that are totally absent in a library.
- mdp2021 4y ago> to find relevant material There you show the possibility of having selected an activity among many possible. Your expression suggests /to seek/, ex IE sag, "to track", which is not /to search/, ex Lat circare, "look around" - to explore. Parts of the exploration (the complementary part of exploitation) is benefited by having a large amount of material in front of you, browsable. And having thousands of volumes at hand and immediately remains invaluable; electronic experience remains different.
- crazygringo 4y agoI disagree -- electronic experience isn't different. You can build any kind of interface for electronic "looking around" or "exploring" that you like. While in a physical library, you are limited entirely to a single fixed physical layout. There is nothing a physical library can do for exploring that can't be replicated on a computer. But a computer can add all sorts of incredible improvements. And why would you only want to have thousands of volumes at hand for immediate access, when you could have millions instead?
- mdp2021 4y agoThe public libraries I know request a form of subscription to access digitized material, involving the use of public identity - linked to the accessed books. As opposed to "access the shelves, pick the item, read it in place". But some will deny personal data treatment, particularly in terms of matching accessed material and identity. So, general use of electronic documents through libraries will be off-limit to an important class of people. (Those who regard private intellectual activity as near top in the list of rightfully strictly private matters by principle.)
- crazygringo 4y agoThe public library I go to (NYPL) requires a proof of identity (driver's license, etc.) to get a library card which is required to check out material for use on-premises in a reading room. There is only a tiny fraction (< 1%) of material that any random person can just walk in and browse. And this is the case with all reference libraries that I'm aware of. (Edit: meant "research" library, mistyped "reference".)
- mdp2021 4y ago> that I'm aware of I want to reach your area to finally one day visit Bass' Strand; you should come to Europe one day and have the experience of free access to the shelves :)
- crazygringo 4y agoIs there a research library (e.g. more than a million volumes) in Europe that you can browse most/all the collection of without even having to provide an ID card? In my experience, Europe tends to require mandatory ID for things in general much more often than the US does.
- hedora 4y agoThe main problem with digitization is that it facilitates censorship and forgery. We are already seeing a lot of this; especially in DRM’ed collections. If everyone just downloaded the entire library locally (this is completely feasible with consumer drives), and used some sort of snapshotting rsync, then this problem would go away. DRM prevents that, even for some public domain works.
- onecommentman 4y agoHere’s an issue I ran into recently where digitization fell flat. Wanted images of a particular issue of a regional newspaper from the 1940s. I am in the US State where it was published and it was one of the top three newspapers at the time, so (I thought) no problem. The State library even sent me a copy of the digital archived copy of that issue. But the scanning had been done from a bound copy of the newspaper and done with a (state-of-the-art at the time) low resolution scanner. Two or three words of each line (right side of right page, left side of the left-facing page) were missing…not just distorted, missing. Contacted them to get the original and they said they didn’t have the original physical copies of those issues from the 1940s, just those scans. (Library of Congress says the State library have the only complete physical collection.) So I am dealing with lacunae (you know, the stuff archeologists wrestle with when texts are missing from 2000 year old burnt papyrus) from newspapers that are less than 100 years old. With 2000 year old burnt papyrus, new tech can maybe fix the problem. But there is no original source material to work with for this 1940s newspaper. In addition, any early scanned photos from that issue run the gamut from bad to totally unusable. No future AI would be able to reliably reproduce anything from many of the photo scans…there is simply too little signal left. A trivial rescan issue with today’s scanning tech, but what can you do when the original is unavailable? The content in question relates to art and artists, so the published graphic images are important. Early digitizations often don’t meet the needs of researchers. If the physical source material was tossed and unavailable for rescan, no matter how recently published, some text fragments and images are more “lost” than the burnt papyri of Egypt. Physical archived copies of core documents are still important, even/especially bulky “ephemera”.
- dorchadas 4y agoAnd I find I remember next to nothing I read in digital books, even eink books, whereas I can constantly recall stuff from physical books I've read. Plus, the act of phyiscally reading it does something, and I can generally remember roughly where I found something without need for a search. Physical books just for me are a no brainer when I can get them. They're orders of magnitude better than anything digital for research, even if it isn't as 'efficient' and time gets 'wasted' (I'd also put forth an argument it isn't necessarily wasted).