2 ms·
> In theory this should mean that the average representative would be smarter, more capable, and of better moral character. That's not what I would expect from
by jfengel 4y ago
> In theory this should mean that the average representative would be smarter, more capable, and of better moral character.
That's not what I would expect from theory. I'd expect it to make the representative more reflective of the intelligence, capability, and moral character of the constituents. If the constituents are deficient, they'll send deficient representatives.
I think you're suggesting that having representatives better known to the constituents would weed out misbehavior, but I believe it just means fewer eyes on them. If there are red flags, it only takes one person to notice, and can publicize it to all of the rest.
It's not that I'm opposed to expanding the House in this fashion. As HL Mencken said, "Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard." I believe that the problems we have stem from the voters themselves, not the mechanisms they use, and will not be fixed by any changes to those mechanics. Still, anything we do different is an opportunity to interrupt the vicious cycle of distrust that I think is the core problem.