3 ms·
I'm going to toss a totally crazy idea out there, but it may be crazy enough to work long term. Create an official Hacker News API where every Hacker News clie
by malandrew 15y ago
I'm going to toss a totally crazy idea out there, but it may be crazy enough to work long term.
Create an official Hacker News API where every Hacker News client has an API key and plan on offering write access only through the API. This would permit a diversity of interfaces, from browser based apps to terminal based apps. Monitor quality level of the posts per developer API key. Revoke or throttle write access of a client which doesn't maintain a high post quality count.
For example, I would imagine that a client built for vim or emacs would have a high level of quality and that a browser based client would have a lower level of quality. Developers of clients which contribute a lower level of quality would have the burden of solving the quality problem. Basically "push" the problem to the clients. After all that is the origin of of the word "problem" (Old French probleme, via Latin from Greek problēma, from proballein ‘put forth,’ from pro ‘before’ + ballein ‘to throw.’) "Throw" or "put forth" the problem for other developers to solve.
Hacker News would be better off if you could only contribute to it via an interface likely to be used only by hackers. This strategy is not unlike those employed by companies when they require you to submit your resume via curl or to hack into an unsecured server to upload your resume.
Will we lose access to some types of content, like design focused posts? Maybe. Would it be worth it? Maybe. But that's a whole 'nother discussion.
Personally, I would rather see 25% percent as many contributions of extremely high quality than as many contributions as we have today of lower quality.
It's not poor quality contribution overload. It's filter failure ;)
http://blip.tv/web2expo/web-2-0-expo-ny-clay-shirky-shirky-com-it-s-not-information-overload-it-s-filter-failure-1283699 http://blip.tv/web2expo/web-2-0-expo-ny-clay-shirky-shirky-c...