3 ms·
Math is language independent. Shouldn't ESL students be able to use workbooks in their native language?
by zozbot234 4y ago
Math is language independent. Shouldn't ESL students be able to use workbooks in their native language?
- reocha 4y agoMath teachers speak English.
- dorchadas 4y agoYou'd think so, but I've taught ESL math. Good luck getting them to understand what's even going on without speaking their language. Especially if some, like my students, come in at high school having only really had five years of formal schooling. You need the language to teach the math, basically. Also, not all of the kids I had were literate in their first language (A Mayan language, so most weren't) or even their second (often another Mayan language) or third (Spanish usually), so you can't just say 'Give them a workbook'
- NDizzle 4y agoI'd sure hate to be taught math from a workbook alone.