11 ms·
> I'm going to contend this isn't so much subverting EU rules but rather trying to ensure that Apple won't get blamed when someone uses a cable that can't handl
by kelnos 4y ago
> I'm going to contend this isn't so much subverting EU rules but rather trying to ensure that Apple won't get blamed when someone uses a cable that can't handle the power when plugged in given that there's not a good standard out there for this and no enforcement of the "ok, there's something - try this..."
That's just not true. The USB-IF won't certify a cable unless it can do 20V @ 3A, which is around 2x the voltage at 3A that the iPhone would even try to do.
If true, this is just money-grab and spiteful behavior out of Apple, nothing more.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoWhat percent of cables coming out of China, sold on Amazon or in convenience stores/gas stations, do you believe have been certified by USB-IF?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- falcolas 4y ago3rd party misbehavior does not justify Apple misbehavior.
- comfypotato 4y agoIt’s not misbehavior by Apple if it’s to protect against 3rd party misbehavior.
- falcolas 4y agoSo why aren't we yelling at Apple for not doing this now with their USB-C powered Macbook Pro's with their 100W+ chargers and cables? Or thunderbolt cables? If there's such a huge pool of potential trouble brewing with a 20W phone, why do they even allow such maleficent third party malfeasance? /s
- arcticbull 4y agoThey do, you can't charge a 16" M1 MacBook Pro at 140W without the MagSafe cable. The USB-C port is capped at 96W. And I believe to charge at 60W+ you need an e-marked cable. ... which is roughly what's being proposed here for iPhone. Since some Samsung devices charge at 45W and require 3A (hence e-marked) cables, one can infer Apple wants to do something similar for iPhone in the future.
- error503 4y agoYou don't need e-marking for 3A charging. A non e-marked cable can deliver up to 60W (3A@20V). It must route the CC pin to be able to negotiate a higher voltage (>15W 3A@5V), but this is (spec) required for all USB-C cables. Edit: I should add that it is possible for a fully complaint combination of devices to not charge at max(sink power, source power), because not all possible combinations of voltage and current may be supported. For example a 60W charger may support 20V@3A, but if the 60W sink only supports 12V charging, it needs 5A and this combination won't support 60W charging. In practice this should be rare though, it would be terrible product design.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 4y agoYou're totally right, in part I confused >60W with >=60W, and as you rightly point out, non-marked cables should support 20V/3A. Re: your edit. There is this exact kind of profile incompatibility between the Leviton T5636 and the HomePod mini when two devices are plugged in. The outlet should support 30W for each receptacle, which is more than enough to provide the 18W/20W the HomePod mini requires. But for some PD profile incompatibility reason (9V/3A probably), it does not get enough power. And it is in fact terrible product design. Leviton is pointing the finger at Apple but in reality, who knows.
- error503 4y ago> Which source? The charger or the device? Because either could be at fault. IMO it's harder for the source to be flexible with voltage, and especially current limit, so I'd put somewhat more blame on the sink here for not being flexible enough. Generally a sink should expect to be plugged into an 'unknown' source, so should at least make an effort to support multiple voltages. Designing a multiport power source with a shared power limit is a bit of a tricky problem.
- widowlark 4y agoenjoy your user protection for 3x the cost
- comfypotato 4y agoYes: I can invest more in a device and get a better product, Apple or otherwise. 3x? Lol, get out of here with your bullshit.
- joseftexas 4y agoLet them be. I have seen a grandpa sufferring for 10 years on iPhone (he bought new one every 2 years). He just upgraded to S23u and very happy with it. His wife still sticks to i13pm. Some just want burn thru their cash because they believe it is worth it. Some didn't know. We can only help the later group by informing. The former group won't bulge even if the realized it. It is human nature.
- bilbo0s 4y agoTo be fair, it's not Apple misbehavior. It's essentially just Apple saying if you use a cable not OK'd by us, you're on your own. I don't think anyone expects people not to plug in non certified cables. It looks like it's just putting into writing a stance of, "Hey, if you fry your phone using junk cables, that's on you."
- falcolas 4y ago> if you use a cable not OK'd by us, you're on your own That is misbehavior from Apple, because it adds a cost to the consumer. MiFi is absolutely not free. The consumer friendly option is allowing the use of a perfectly good USB-C cable (from J5 Create, for example) that doesn't have the MiFi tax without artificial restrictions.
- bilbo0s 4y agoNo one disallows using the J5 cable. That's the entire point. That's what makes all this fair. It's the consumer who chooses what products s/he will use. The only thing being codified here is that if you happen to use a janky cable Apple didn't certify, the results are on you. All that, to my mind, is totally reasonable. You can use a certified cable. You can use a non certified cable. The consumer is totally free to make any choice s/he chooses. They only warrant that if you use the certified cable, your phone won't blow up.
- falcolas 4y agoThen we're reading this sentence from TFA quite differently: > Shrimp states that Apple will limit data and charging speed for cables connected to iPhone without the MFi certification. To me (and I'd wager it's the same for most folks), that's Apple implementing a technical block on the cables separate from their actual capabilities.
- bilbo0s 4y agoThat's not for the cable, that's for the accessory connected to the cable. I thought we were talking about the cables here? With respect to the cables, that's part of the USB C spec. Not the spec to which you are referring. The whole point of the E Mark is to signal that it is safe to send otherwise dangerously high speeds and wattage down the cable. So they're just saying that they promise to follow the spec for cables they certify. Now the accessories, you're right, but I don't know the rules for accessories. I do know them for the cables.
- justeleblanc 4y agoIf they can fake USB certification, why wouldn't they be able to fake apple certification?
- shagie 4y agoBecause when they fake using the Apple trademark for Made-For-iPhone, Apple will get them removed from various market places, retailers, or possibly even stopped at customs when importing them. Apple has no such enforcement capabilities for USB as they don't have any rights to that trademark.
- JohnFen 4y agoAnd we all know how well that works based on how few counterfeits there are on Amazon. /s
- onphonenow 4y agoWhen Amazon wasn’t responsive enough they pulled their products and sued suppliers using fulfilled by amazon. USB-if by comparison does nothing and neither do govt agencies- apple is perhaps most active in its enforcement efforts
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoAnd how does the USB-IF prevent an iPhone from getting fried by non-USB-IF certified cables? If they had some method of doing that, would the expense of operating it be a "money-grab"?
- shaunsingh0207 4y agoIsn't that just USB-PD and QC3? Which apple uses on their desktop products
- makeitdouble 4y agoIsn’t it the same issue right now when you’re using a random USB charger and a third party lightning cable, which is probably the case for the vast majority of people ?
- rhaway84773 4y agoDoes Apple restrict lightning cables the same way? Also, what about all the iPads and MacBooks that have been using USB-C for years? Does Apple not care about those products’ users? If it was concerned about the impact of uncertified USB-C cables, why doesn’t it already do these things on existing USB-C products it sells?
- Eric_WVGG 4y ago1. yes, they do 2. They definitely should. I've had plenty of experiences in the past seven years where cords kinda-sorta-not-always worked. If I plugged a shitty cord that didn't work into any device I own, I'd like it to respond "nah dude"
- wkat4242 4y agoLike all the Android phones with even higher charging speeds not actually 'getting fried'?
- mbreese 4y agoGiven that we have people who test various USB-C cables with devices (sometimes destructively)[1], this makes complete sense. The USB-C cable/charger landscape is crazy and there are a lot of dodgy devices out there. The conservative approach is to only allow the minimum allowed power with unknown cables/chargers. The EU mandate is to avoid having extraneous chargers that can't be used with multiple devices. I don't think there is a mandate for specific rates of charging. [1] https://www.engadget.com/2016-02-03-benson-leung-chromebook-pixel-usb-type-c-test.html https://www.engadget.com/2016-02-03-benson-leung-chromebook-...?
- goosedragons 4y agoThen why didn't Apple limit MacBook charging to only Apple verified cables and chargers back in 2015? Arguably the USB C ecosystem was far more sketch then now and all their laptops draw far more wattage than an iPhone. Or why didn't they do it when the iPad Pro moved to USB C? Doing it on iPhone just seems like an abuse of their oversized power in the smartphone industry.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mbreese 4y agoWhen running low on battery, people are far more likely to charge their phones with any random cable that's available. Bars, coffee shops, Ubers, airports, etc... frequently have random cables available for charging. Not all of these cables are all that high of quality or USB-IF certified. If you're running low on power for your laptop, you probably have your own charger available to you. It either came with the computer, or you likely bought it to use with the computer. Regardless, your charging mechanism here is probably more trusted. Honestly, if Apple comes out with iPhones with USB-C ports (like we all expect), some charge from a random cable is better than risky levels of high-power charging. This would be a pragmatic choice. If you want to blame anyone in this, blame USB-IF. They are the reason we have this mess to begin with. Apple is stuck here. You're right that they are an oversized power in the phone industry. They are going to get sued either way. You'll either have phones that get bricked because of a low quality cable/charger or people will be mad that their current charger won't work at 20A. Either way, they will get sued over something. At least this way, if they eventually have to relent to allow, they'll have cover for if/when phones get bricked from cheap cables/chargers. To me, this would make more sense from a defensive liability point of view as opposed to an effort to still extract money with the MFi program.
- rkangel 4y agoWhich would be fine, if the USB-IF did any enforcement at all. "Reputable" retailers like Amazon should not be able to get away with selling unlicenced gear (in much the same way as they shouldn't be allowed to get away with selling counterfeit).
- pedrocr 4y agoAre no brand lightning cables not a thing too?
- rektide 4y agoUSB-IF does enforcement... for USB-IF certified cables. Personally Im super glad there are a world of much cheaper more affordable cables that work quite adequately. I do wish we could as a society defend ourselves better but certification is an expensive & absurd trust mechanism. If certification were a lower cost, faster process I'd respect it as a social safeguard, but certification isnt easy. For one, it's not one off... USB-IF has to go shopping from time to time in the wild to make sure the goods are still good. It's expensive, but for a reason. Ultimately relying on centralized trust actors, and using aggressive legalist pursuit to enforce compliance, is 100% against the spirit Im looking for. It has some upsides, but that's obvious legalistic authoritarianism, is the lawful-evil square on the D&D alignment chart. It's what I think the EU is trying to get away from! So let's talk alternatives! Personally it frustrates angers & saddens me that our systems are blanketly unobservable. USB-HID spec has really good telemetry for chargers to self-report their output voltage & current (a monitoring task many already perform). Devices ought be able to detect input voltage fairly well (and again many implicitly do, they again just dont report). Being able to see graphs of output/charger power versus input power seems like a dead simple ask, and the difference between those two is loss. Being able to make whats happening easy to see would let us all help self-police, would let us become smart informed consumers, who know how to gauge the quality of what we have & share that good information out. It should just be a standard feature in computing that objects extrospect, report; computers rhat are black boxes lack the fundamental "soft"-ness that is computings best & highest angel.
- Analemma_ 4y agoSpoken like someone who has never bought USB-C cables on Amazon. Outside major brands, the majority are junk that act wildly out of spec. The USB-IF doesn't care.
- shagie 4y agoFrom several years ago... A Google engineer sacrificed his Chromebook Pixel to test USB-C cables - https://www.theverge.com/2016/2/3/10905432/usb-c-cable-fries-google-engineers-computer https://www.theverge.com/2016/2/3/10905432/usb-c-cable-fries... > Google engineer Benson Leung has been on a mission to prove that all USB-C cables are not created equal, and that mission appears to have ended — or at least climaxed — with one cable totally frying his computer. Leung has been testing USB-C cables and posting reviews of them on Amazon for a few months now, and the most recent cable he tested, made by SurjTech, turned out to be "completely miswired" — something he didn't realize until after it "managed to destroy my test equipment," he says, including a Chromebook Pixel. And the older article A Google engineer is testing USB Type-C cables so you don't have to - https://www.theverge.com/2015/11/5/9674462/usb-type-c-google-engineer-third-party-cables https://www.theverge.com/2015/11/5/9674462/usb-type-c-google... His reviews: https://www.amazon.com/gp/profile/amzn1.account.AFLICGQRF6BRJGH2RRD4VGMB47ZA/ref=cm_cr_srp_d_gw_btm?ie=UTF8 https://www.amazon.com/gp/profile/amzn1.account.AFLICGQRF6BR...
- blep-arsh 4y agoSo if I buy a counterfeit MFi cable it still has a solid chance to destroy my phone before the MFi validation logic kicks in.
- shagie 4y agoIf you buy a counterfeit MFi cable, it has a good chance of being intercepted by customs (similar to how they intercept counterfeit goods - https://abc7.com/counterfeit-goods-us-customs-border-protection-billion-worth-in-items-cbp/12464650/ https://abc7.com/counterfeit-goods-us-customs-border-protect... and https://www.nwonewswatch.com/local-news/us-customs-seize-counterfeit-electronics-at-the-border-5999805 https://www.nwonewswatch.com/local-news/us-customs-seize-cou... ).
- JohnFen 4y ago> The USB-IF won't certify a cable And so? How many people know that USB-IF exists? How many people know how to tell if USB-IF has certified a cable? If you don't have the packaging, how do you know if the cable is certified? The USB-IF is pretty inadequate here, even if we ignore the existence of fake certifications. They can't even work out how to mark the different USB-C cables so you know which ones are what kind, leading to all sorts of problems and confusion for users.
- SR2Z 4y agoAs someone who doesn't know about USB-IF but has used all kinds of cheap Amazon USB-C cables: this issue is stupid and overblown. 99% of the time, all I need from the cable is <60W of power capacity. I don't need data, and I wouldn't even notice if the cable was 1Gbps or 40Gbps. I've literally never had a problem with _that_ use case. Even when I need the cable for data transmission, all of the ones I have are either from my phone, laptop, dock, etc., etc. and follow standards, or are from no-name Amazon brands but _still_ seem to follow the spec completely fine. Sure there are exceptions like the Nintendo Switch, but virtually all devices at that price point can handle bad cables.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rolenthedeep 4y agoThis comment is the first time I've ever seen an individual care about USB certification. It's about as effectual as the CE mark.
- not_me_ever 4y agoEnd of 2022 we bought 50 different certified(!) USB-C cables off of Amazon. We needed about 800 for our test farm, and did thorough tests before buying. 24x7@50w with 1h/day@80w (we had planned on 100w, but gave up on that fast). 3 were good enough for safe use with 20V@3A. 47 were sub standard. We had to unplug 9 during our testing, as they started to melt. One of them started to smoke after 60 seconds. USB-IF certification means nothing, as everybody can just buy it, or fake it. With EPR 240W incoming I am getting seriously afraid for friends & family.
- fsckboy 4y agoyou should repeat the test to see if Amazon even ships you the same cables twice, big variable in there